San Diego Chargers 2010: Can They Win Without Jackson and McNeill?

Alex JennyContributor IAugust 18, 2010

SAN DIEGO - SEPTEMBER 9:  Tackle Marcus McNeill #76 of the San Diego Chargers enters the game against the Chicago Bears at Qualcomm Stadium September 9, 2007 in San Diego, California.  (Photo by Donald Miralle/Getty Images)
Donald Miralle/Getty Images


Last Year's Record:            13-3

Wins:  Raiders (x2), Dolphins, Chiefs (x2), Giants, Eagles, Broncos, Browns, Cowboys, Bengals, Titans, Redskins

Losses: Ravens, Steelers, Broncos

Biggest Playmaker            Philip Rivers

QB, NC State, Drafted No. 4, seventh year

Philip Rivers has turned himself from an above average, trash-talking quarterback into one of the game’s best.  Rivers is coming off a pro bowl season in which he threw for 28 touchdowns to just nine interceptions and for 4,254 yards.  With LT Marcus McNeill and WR Vincent Jackson currently holding out, Rivers is going to have to step up and play better than ever. 

Impact Player            Antonio Gates

TE, Kent State, Undrafted, eighth year

Gates, a college basketball star, worked out as an undrafted free agent for the Chargers and the Chargers made one of their biggest signings of the decade.  Gates has been to the pro bowl the last six years and is a threat vertically from his tight end position.  Gates is a huge red zone target for Rivers, and can change a game very quickly.

Biggest Offseason Addition            Ryan Mathews

RB, Fresno State, Drafted No. 12, Rookie

With the loss of record holding RB Ladanian Tomlinson, the Chargers needed a feature back.  They have incredible confidence in Mathews, as they jumped 16 spots to grab him at No. 12 in the first round.  Mathews will be immediately inserted into the starting lineup and may carry the ball around 300 times this year, according to head coach Norv Turner.

Biggest Offseason Loss            Jamal Williams

NT, Oklahoma State, Drafted second round (Supplemental Draft), 13th Year

Jamal Williams is aging (34), but made the pro bowl three straight years from 2005-2007.  After missing all but one game of the 2009 season with an elbow injury, Williams was cut by the Chargers and signed by the Broncos.  However, the Chargers may lose production here, as they list Antonio Garay as their starter and rookie Cam Thomas as the backup at the ever-important 3-4 nose tackle spot.  Garay has appeared in 16 games since being drafted in 2003 (signed off the Jets’ practice squad last year) and Thomas may well end up starting, as a true steal in the fifth round. 

Biggest Draft Steal            Cam Thomas

NT, UNC, Drafted No. 146, rookie

Thomas, standing at 6’3” and roughly 330 lbs,  addresses the need of a solid nose tackle, with the departure of Jamal Williams, and could push for a starting spot early on.  He was projected by many experts to go in the second round of the draft.  This draft was deep at defensive tackle, and grabbing Thomas in the fifth round was definitely a steal. 

Biggest Draft Reach            None

The Chargers had a very solid draft overall.  They may have jumped a bit higher than they needed to take Ryan Mathews in the first round, but he will be a big factor in the Chargers’ offense from day one and proved he can be a feature back at Fresno State.  In addition, the Seahawks very likely could have taken Mathews at 14.  Second round ILB Donald Butler is out for the season with an Achilles injury.

Offseason Grade            B

The Chargers had a good draft, filling needs with Mathews, Thomas, and SS Darrell Stuckey from Kansas.  They gained depth at CB after the departure of Antonio Cromartie by signing Nathan Vasher and Donald Strickland.  Right now, their biggest concerns are two of their best players on offense, Vincent Jackson and Marcus McNeill.  Both could hold out well into the season, possibly not returning until Week 10 (when they must return to accrue a season towards free-agency) or beyond.

X-Factor            Jackson and McNeill

The Chargers must have players step up in place of Vincent Jackson and Marcus McNeill during their holdouts.  I don’t believe they have anyone on their roster capable of their production (maybe Malcolm Floyd at WR), but replacing these two is crucial if the Chargers are going to contend in the playoffs.

Name You Should Know            Shaun Phillips

OLB, Purdue, Drafted No. 98, seventh year

Somehow Shaun Phillips is not a well-known playmaker.  He has been very consistent for the Chargers and has been overshadowed by fellow OLB Shawne Merriman.  He has recorded 41.5 sacks in the last five seasons and plays a crucial role opposite Merriman.

Rising Star            Malcolm Floyd

WR, Wyoming, Undrafted, seventh year

Malcolm Floyd may be a bit old to be considered a rising star, but when he was finally given the chance as the No. 2 receiver in 2009, he caught 45 balls for 776 yards, an average of 17.2 yards per catch.  If Vincent Jackson does not play this year, Floyd will be a go-to guy for Rivers.  He is an outstanding deep-threat with the ability to catch the ball with ease over smaller defenders. 

Offensive Outlook            B+

Insert Vincent Jackson and Marcus McNeill into the starting lineup and the Chargers offense receives an A.  However, they are not there, and the Chargers are likely left with Legedu Naanee as their second receiver (one career start) and former undrafted free agent Brandyn Dombrowski at left tackle.   The Chargers also have an untested rookie RB, but they do have the ever-consistent Antonio Gates at tight end and Rivers at quarterback. 

Defensive Outlook            B

The development of a consistent, dominant nose tackle is vital for the Chargers.  Shawne Merriman recently returned from a holdout but simply must regain his 2007 (and earlier) form.  Stephen Cooper and Kevin Burnett will be solid inside, with the secondary composed of Quentin Jammer, Antoine Cason, Eric Weddle, and rookie Darrell Stuckey

Special Teams Outlook            A-

Little Darren Sproles has been electric as a return man since he entered the league.  Nate Kaeding has the best field goal percentage in NFL history…in the regular season.  He has been sub-par in the playoffs, missing three field goals in the Chargers' playoff loss to the Jets.  Punter Mike Scifres is very good at what he does.

Projected 2010 Record            10-6

The Chargers are currently missing two important pieces in their WR and LT, but they have a lot of weapons on both sides of the ball.  If Merriman can return to his pro bowl form, the Chargers’ pass rush will take a lot of heat off of the secondary, and the Chargers must be productive at the NT spot.  The Chargers are putting a lot on the shoulders of rookie RB Ryan Mathews, while Malcom Floyd and Antonio Gates will continue to be deep threats in place of Vincent Jackson. However, the Chargers will need to run the ball far more efficiently than a year ago, averaging 3.3 yards per carry.  All that said, the Chargers have a pretty clear path to an AFC West title. 

For more NFL News and Analysis visit The 3-4


    Betting Odds on 1st NFL Coach to Be Fired

    Los Angeles Chargers logo
    Los Angeles Chargers

    Betting Odds on 1st NFL Coach to Be Fired

    Scott Polacek
    via Bleacher Report

    Report: 44-Year Old T.O. on CFL's Teams' Negotiation List 👀

    NFL logo

    Report: 44-Year Old T.O. on CFL's Teams' Negotiation List 👀

    Scott Polacek
    via Bleacher Report

    Cowboys, Chargers Should Target Earl Thomas for Trade

    Los Angeles Chargers logo
    Los Angeles Chargers

    Cowboys, Chargers Should Target Earl Thomas for Trade

    Seattle Seahawks
    via Seattle Seahawks

    Ingram Disrespected in Madden 19 Rankings

    Los Angeles Chargers logo
    Los Angeles Chargers

    Ingram Disrespected in Madden 19 Rankings

    Will Reeve Jr
    via Chargers Wire