San Francisco Giants' Loss Another Call for More Instant Replay

Tom DubberkeCorrespondent IJuly 19, 2010

SAN FRANCISCO - JULY 18:  Travis Ishikawa #10 of the San Francisco Giants slides in to home plate under the tag of New York Mets catcher Henry Blanco #4 in the ninth inning AT&T Park on July 18, 2010 in San Francisco, California. Ishikawa was called out on the play and the Mets went on to win 4-3 in ten innings.  (Photo by Ezra Shaw/Getty Images)
Ezra Shaw/Getty Images

The Giants lost yesterday’s game to the Mets after home plate umpire Phil Cuzzi mistakenly called Travis Ishikawa out at the plate in the ninth inning, following Freddy Sanchez's bouncing ball, and Mets third baseman David Wright’s high throw to the plate.

Not only did the replays show that Ishikawa was safe, but even the Mets’ catcher Henry Blanco even admitted that Ish was safe on the play .

Of course, the cries for more instant replays are always loudest when it’s your team getting burned by the blown call.

Still, after the fiasco with Armando Galarraga’s almost perfect game, and the blown calls in last year’s postseason, it’s long time for MLB to take action to make more calls challengable by instant replay.

None of the reasons given for keeping the current system in place hold any water. First, we now have replay on home run calls, and the world of major league baseball hasn’t come crashing down.

Also, the whole argument for “human error” being a part of the game is just a stupid appeal to a “tradition” that doesn’t make any sense. It’s a little like making today’s players use the mitts they used back in 1910 or making them play bare-handed, the way they did in the 1870′s.

Even now, the umpires do, in fact, sometimes reverse their calls. On Friday night’s game between the Royals and A’s, Coco Crisp led off the game with a hot smash down the right field line which umpire Larry Vanover, jumping out of the way, initially called foul.

However, after the call had been made, Vanover saw that the foul line chalk past first base had been marked by the ball, so he convened the other umpires and after a lengthy discussion, reversed the original call and awarded Crisp second base. 

Crew chief Jeff Kellogg was quoted as saying after the game, “What we (the umpires) want to do is get the call right.”

I agree that umpires do, indeed, want to get the call right. However, they are also extremely unwilling to change their calls unless they see some hard evidence that they are wrong.

This is because listening to a team’s complaints and changing the call invites more disputes between players, managers, and umpires, both on that play and in the future.

Since the umpires can already reverse their own calls in order to “get the call right," there is simply no reason not to give each team a certain number of challenges to fair-foul and safe-out calls by instant replay each season. 

The current regime gives umpires sole discretion on when to reconsider a call, and for the reasons stated above, they are not disposed to do so unless they see hard evidence. Instant replay takes ego and other considerations entirely out of the equation.

Blown calls give fans a reason to be put off by the game. If obviously blown calls can be made right, there is no good reason for not doing so.

The regime I have suggested previously is to give each team at the start of the season 40 or 50 opportunities to challenge disputed calls by replay.

A team would not be allowed to use more than 10 challenges a month, three to five challenges a week or more than two per game. If the call is reversed, the challenge is not counted against the team’s remaining challenges.

Such a regime would prevent constant, time-consuming challenges, and would allow teams ample opportunity to correct some wrong calls.

On a final note, baseball has a huge advantage in officiating over basketball or football, where the nature of the action is that fouls are largely in the mind of the individual official. 

What I mean is that we’ve all seen phantom holding calls in the NFL, or obvious holds not called. In the NBA, Kobe Bryant and Michael Jordon regularly are (or were) awarded trips to the free throw line for “fouls” that many other players would not get.

The NFL has had great success introducing the instant replay and creating a regime that punishes injudicious use of the instant replay privilege. There’s no good reason MLB can’t do the same.


    He's the Nats' Next Harper, Even If Harper Stays

    MLB logo

    He's the Nats' Next Harper, Even If Harper Stays

    Danny Knobler
    via Bleacher Report

    Welcome to the New Era of Bullpens

    MLB logo

    Welcome to the New Era of Bullpens

    Beyond the Box Score
    via Beyond the Box Score

    Astros Promote GM Jeff Luhnow

    MLB logo

    Astros Promote GM Jeff Luhnow

    ABC13 Houston
    via ABC13 Houston

    Ranking the Top 50 Players for 2018

    NFL logo

    Ranking the Top 50 Players for 2018