In my mind, the move that fits the theme the most is the DDT. At one point in time, no one could kick out of a DDT. No one.
Jake Roberts would hit you with it and you wouldn't even notice the python crawling all over you because you'd be KNOCKED THE F* OUT!
Anymore, this move is used by Orton rather dramatically, but it never gets him a pinfall (does he even bother to pin them after hitting an opponent with it??).
Drew McIntyre uses a theatrical version as well, so it seems there's one out there who can still get the pinfall with it.
Generally anymore, the DDT is a mere counter, possibly one of the coolest looking counters out there and one meant to look rather devastating (I do still love seeing a tilt-a-whirl DDT counter).
Still, it's a counter, none the less, and never a finisher. Alas....