Santino Marella did an open challenge and Beth Phoenix defeated him. (WTF #4) Santino then went on to lose to D'Lo Brown. (WTF #5, D'Lo Brown had the feud then left WWE! Good going, WWE)
Then he and Beth Phoenix started dating, and they called themselves Glamarella. They went on to face Kofi Kingston and Mickie James, where Kofi's IC and Mickie's Women's titles were on the line. Beth pinned Mickie James and won the titles for them.
Marella went on to lose against Honky Tonk Man (WTF #6), and later to the Royal Rumble was eliminated by Kane in 1.9 seconds, breaking the previous record. (WTF #7) Phoenix and Marella broke up eventually.
He then went on to win a "Miss Wrestlemania" 25-diva battle royal contest under the gimmick of "Santina Marella", Santino's twin sister. (WTF #8, #9) Then on Raw, he lost the "Miss Wrestlemania" title to Vickie Guerrero, but then later went on to win it back against Vickie and Chavo. Donald Trump, the then GM of Raw, fired Santino. (WTF #10)