I am sure that this a surprise to no one, as it is probably a favorite of yours as well.
This match was held last year at Wrestlemania 25, Shawn Michaels representing the good and Undertaker representing the evil. As shown in the picture.(Michaels wearing white, Taker wearing Black)
The fans were split right down the middle on this one, (I rooted for Michaels.) as the match started, but at the end everyone just thought it was a great match and there really wasn't rooting for either way.
The match started off slow pace, but the pace quickened. Exchanges of theire signature moves and submission holds, back and forth. It saw Michaels able to escape The Undertaker's signature chokehold, Hell's Gate and dodge multiple attempts at the chokeslam while his adversary, Undertaker blocked attempts at Michaels' superkick dubbed the Sweet Chin Music.
The action went to the outside of the ring with Michaels attempting a backflip from the top rope called the moonsault, only to have The Undertaker swat away the attempt; this was followed by The Undertaker climbing into the ring, obtaining a running-start, and jump straight over the top rope, only to have Michaels dodge the attack and pull the nearby cameraman (Sim Snuka) into harms way with The Undertaker hitting the cameraman with The Undertaker nearly landing on his head.
He remained on the floor of the arena with the referee checking to see if he was alright before he headed into the ring and proceeded to count; , but he managed to return to the ring by a count of nine.
The match continued with both men performing all of their respective finishing moves to with both men unable to win through these moves. The Undertaker finally won the match after Michaels ascended the top rope, attempting to perform another moonsault only to be caught in the midst of the move by his opponent to be dropped by his finishing maneuver, the Tombstone Piledriver, and pinning him.
All in all the match lived up to the hype and some more, earning a 2009 slammy. Which is why I think it is a mistake to have another match between them, why mess with perfection.