NCAA: Don't Cut Slack to Those Not Deserving

Shaun Ahmad by Senior Analyst Written on June 30, 2008
123_feature
(Page 2 of 2)

So in return for playing 25 games or so a year (basketball players), you get a free education which is as much of a lock as any to a promising future.  If things don’t work out in the league, you have a Bachelor's Degree from the University of Your Choice to fall back on. 

A free education is like someone giving you a $50,000 interest free loan.  Think about that.

But no—according to Stephen A., the players aren’t getting a good deal: 

"You may think a college scholarship is compensation enough.  And in a perfect world, it might be.  But a scholarship is not a guarantee of anything…"

Really?  The average college graduate with a bachelor’s degree earns $52,200 a year, while the average high school graduate earns $30,400 a year.  According to the U.S. Census Bureau, “A person with a Bachelor’s degree will earn, on average, almost twice as much as workers with a high school diploma over a lifetime ($2.1 million compared to $1.2 million)."

So please, spare me the “scholarship is not a guarantee of anything” speech. 

A lot of us have seen the treatment players also receive on campus in addition to their free ride.  I had class with Marcus Vick among other football players (Jimmy Williams, Vince Hall, etc).  Whereas I had to go to class to make sure I didn’t miss the numerous pop quizzes, those players never came. 

Yet the following semester, I saw them in the next level of the course.  Was I shocked?  Absolutely not.  Even the most naïve of us know that college players who are well known get a free pass from teachers. 

So let’s catch up here.  Athlete plays sport, gets free education with biased grades that work in his favor, all of which translates to a secure future.  I’m supposed to feel sorry for that guy?  I’m supposed to not care if he’s getting extra Benjamins on the side?  I must be missing something.

Smith also fails to mention that everything he’s saying we should not care about is against the rules.

I say, we should absolutely care.  In fact, we should be infuriated. 

If you’re a USC guy, ask yourself this: Was one year of having O.J. Mayo worth it if the NCAA comes down with penalties that hinder your team’s success for the next five years?  I certainly don’t think it is. 

The reason we should care is because these college athletes already have it made.  We shouldn’t allow them and their growing greed to affect our Universities in a negative way.

Sure, they bring in a lot of attention and press, but they are also compensated for it if they choose to accept the gift—that being a full ride education, with “benefits.”

Is it fair that thousands of bright kids don’t get to attend college because their parents are broke and working three jobs? 

No.  But life isn’t fair. 

That doesn’t mean we start feeling sorry for those who have already been blessed with a good deal.  They are the last people we should feel sorry for, contrary to what any writer says.

I understand that there will always be opportunities for guys to get benefits on the side, without the university even knowing.  That has always happened.  It will continue that way. 

However, it is irresponsible to write an article excusing this behavior just to come off as the “cool reporter” who’s down with the youth of today.

You, me, and the guy in your class or office has to go by certain rules—rules that if we break, we face consequences for.  College athletes should be no different just because they can drop 22 a game or throw for 30 touchdowns.   

Smith closes his article with the following:

"As long as today's kids know they're working for a multibillion-dollar industry for free, they're not about to fail to ask, 'Where's mine?'"

Free?  Where’s mine?  It’s right there on the document you signed.  See it?  Below the words FULL SCHOLARSHIP, a.k.a. Fifty G’s, a.k.a. lifetime free of poverty.  That’s where.    

(0)
...
Share This  
Crop_45x45
or to post this comment

0 Comments

There are no comments yet. Get the conversation started by leaving the first comment

Loading more comments...
posted just now
  • Loading...
  • Nobody has liked this comment yet
Cancel

This comment and all replies have been deleted This comment has been deleted Undo delete

412
reads

0
comments

written on June 30, 2008 Opinion

The best newsletter on the web

Subscribe Now

We will never share your email address


CBS Sports Official Partner
Certain photos copyright © 2009 by Getty Images.
Any commercial use or distribution without the express written consent of Getty Images is strictly prohibited.