The Top Five Forgotten MLB Rookie Of The Year Candidates(NL Version)

Matt 'Frostin' Foote

Correspondent Written on November 26, 2009

(0)

Previous Next

Slide 1 of 9

My stats are the basic triple crown ones and whatever stat they used to make eligibility, plus fielding percentage when I see fit, and Slugging, and OPS+ again when I see fit. I wil lindicate non triple crown stats by what they are.

I will use my own standards for chooseing a rookie season The criteria is the first season a player has one or more of the following: 60 games played or 130 At Bats. For pitchers: 25 games pitched in, or 100 Innings Pitched.

"Qualifications for a rookie: Not more than 130 at-bats or 50 innings pitched in the major leagues during a previous season or seasons, nor more than 45 days on a major-league roster during the 25-player roster limit."

These are higher per season, but allow multiple seasons part time seasons to be a rookie, but I believe that people that played the minimum amount of MLB levels have/had/ will have, no shot at winning a ROTY award. Only one player was affected by this, but, I believe I still placed him right if you took the stats from either year.

*Disclaimer, in no way am I saying that any of the following players deserved the Rookie Of The Year award. I am merley saying they had very solid campaigns and deserve some recognition. Also, don't say I am biased because there are two Cardinals on this list. Also, Cardinal fans don't get mad at me not putting in Rasmus. I do think he deserved more votes, but, I also believe that Duncan and McClellan had better years as Card's rookies. I tried to limit myself to one Cardinal because Duncan was on this list no matter what.

#6

Yea I said five, but I want to give my boy Yadier Molina some credit as he missed out on the list. Best deffensive catcher in MLB, getting up there in average. We salute you oh great defender of the plate.

2004: .267/2/15/.993(Fld%)

2004 Winner: Jason Bay

#5

Big papa Panda. Pablo was my number two choice after the guy you will see next of my list for Rookie Of The Year in 2009, applying to MLB standards, now on my standards he was a rookie in 2008.

Man this guy could be the next, well not Barry Bonds, but actuall Giants hitter. I think their team this year consisted of 4 brooms, a Panda, 2 five year olds, and Mario Mendoza himself.

2008: Games Played:41 At Bats:145 .345/3/24/.490(SLG)

2008 Winner: Geovony Soto

#4

Kyle McClellan lead the NL in holds at 30. 30 holds. Most of you are saying so what? It's holds. Well let me tell you, when a rookie leads a league in a positive stat, no matter if that's wins, homeruns, ERA or even holds, it is a pretty big thing.

Now Soto had just an incredible power season, so I still give him the award, but when you look back how many votes did McClellan get? Zero. Now it was a tough class going against Jay Bruce, Geovony Soto, and Joey Votto to name a few.

2008: Games Played:68 Innings Pitched:75,2 4.04/59/.269(BAA)/30HLD)

2008 Winner: Geovony Soto

#3

JA Happ had a bust out season and was a main contributer to get the Phillies to the World Series again. Steped up when Hamels, well, not to offend any Phillie fans, sucked.

2009:Games Played:35 Inning Pitched:166 2.93/12/119

2009 winner: Chirs Coughlin

#2

Edinson Volquez just desroyed hitted in '08. Him and Lincecum, were two very young pitchers who blew it up.

2008: Games Played:33 Innings Pitched:196 3.21/17/206/1.327(WHIP)
2008 Winner: Geovony Soto

#1

2006: Games Played: 90 At Bats: 280. .293/22/43/140(OPS+)

2006 Winner: Hanley Ramirez. Games Played:158 At Bats:633 .292/17/59/116(OPS+)

I believe those stats speak for themselves. AVG: Duncan, HR:Duncan, RBI:Ramirez, OPS+: Duncan.

Also, Duncan was one that helped us get to the World Series, and win it. ROTY recall? I think it is in order.

In Closing

I said earlier that I wasn't saying necessarily any of the following didn't get the win still in my mind, well Happ and Duncan do. Not Volquez or McClellan or Panda, but Happ and especially Duncan I think do.

http://armchairgm.wikia.com/2006_MLB_Rookie_of_the_Year

Man look how many votes Duncan got! Holy cow. Even with 22 homeruns he got... ABSOLUTELY ZERO? 22 homeruns. That's a season anyone in MLB would take.Along with a .290+ AVG? Seriously. This proved BBWAA incompetence to vote for awards. Hanley just didn't deserve the award.

Look at Howard, he was a middeason call up he hit 22 homers. Thats the same as Duncan. Also Howard played more games in the previous year then Duncan(18(2HR) v 9(1 HR)). This is pathetic. I'm sorry BBWAA, but this was just one of the many mistakes they have made. How many Cardinal players must be jacked out of awards they deserve before we finally torch BBWAA HQ?

In fact lets make a counter. Chris Duncan(ROTY), Mark McGwire(MVP), Adam Wainwright(CY YOUNG), Albert Pujols(MVP(2003)), Tony Larussa(MOTY(2006)), Tony Larussa (MOTY(2009)), Albert Pujols(MVP(2004)), Ken Boyer(HOF), Mark McGwire(HOF), Stan Musial(100% of the votes for HOF), and Whitey Herzog(HOF). Just to name a few.

Begin Slideshow

View more great content on other channels:

News & Opinions

St Louis Cardinals

Cardinals on the Farm
Article of the Day

MLB

Fantasy Baseball 2010 Preview: A Look at the Sleepers
Guilty Pleasures

Top 10 Boxing WAGs

More: St Louis Cardinals | MLB

4 Comments

There are no comments yet. Get the conversation started by leaving the first comment

Loading more comments...

posted just now

Loading...
Nobody has liked this comment yet

Cancel

This comment and all replies have been deleted This comment has been deleted Undo delete

<form action="/accounts/create_from_facebook_comment" class="new_facebook_user" id="new_facebook_user" method="post">	<input id="facebook_user_facebook_id" name="facebook_user[facebook_id]" type="hidden" />
	<input id="facebook_user_proxied_email" name="facebook_user[proxied_email]" type="hidden" />
	<input id="facebook_user_profile_pic" name="facebook_user[profile_pic]" type="hidden" />
	<input id="facebook_user_profile_url" name="facebook_user[profile_url]" type="hidden" />
	<ul>
		<div id="facebook_questions">
			<li class="fb-question" id="facebook_full_name_container">
				<p class="question">
					<label for="facebook_user_use_full_name">Use your full name <strong class="full_name"></strong> on Bleacher Report?</label>
					<br />
				</p>
				<p class="options">
					<input name="facebook_user[use_full_name]" type="hidden" value="0" /><input checked="checked" id="facebook_user_use_full_name" name="facebook_user[use_full_name]" type="checkbox" value="1" />
					<label for="facebook_user_use_full_name">Yes</label>
				</p>
				<div class="input full-name-edit" style="display:none">
					<p>Edit your name for Bleacher Report:</p>
					<div class="fb-first-name">
						<label for="facebook_user_first_name">First Name <em>(required)</em></label>
						<input class="signup_text_input" id="facebook_user_first_name" name="facebook_user[first_name]" size="30" type="text" />
						
					</div>
	
					<div class="fb-last-name">
						<label for="facebook_user_last_name">Last Name <em>(required)</em></label>
						<input class="signup_text_input" id="facebook_user_last_name" name="facebook_user[last_name]" size="30" type="text" />
						
					</div>
				</div>
			</li>
			<li class="fb-question">
				<p class="question">
					<img src="/images/default-user-icon-medium.png" class="profile_pic" />
					<label for="facebook_user_use_profile_pic">Do you want to use your Facebook profile picture on Bleacher Report?</label>
				</p>
				<p class="options">
					<input name="facebook_user[use_profile_pic]" type="hidden" value="0" /><input checked="checked" id="facebook_user_use_profile_pic" name="facebook_user[use_profile_pic]" type="checkbox" value="1" />
					<label for="facebook_user_use_profile_pic">Yes</label>
					
				</p>
			</li>
			<li>
				<a id="facebook_connect_submit"><img src="/images/shared/submit.png" /></a>
			</li>
		</div>
	</ul>
</form>

104
reads

4
comments

0
likes

written on November 26, 2009 Opinion

<form action="/accounts/create_from_facebook" class="new_facebook_user" id="new_facebook_user" method="post">	<input id="facebook_user_proxied_email" name="facebook_user[proxied_email]" type="hidden" />
	<input id="facebook_user_profile_pic" name="facebook_user[profile_pic]" type="hidden" />
	<input id="facebook_user_facebook_id" name="facebook_user[facebook_id]" type="hidden" />
	<input id="facebook_user_profile_url" name="facebook_user[profile_url]" type="hidden" />
	<ul>
					<li class="fb-question">
				<div class="input">
											<div id="facebook_placebo_submit">
							<img src="/images/shared/submit.png" />
						</div>
										<div class="fb-first-name" id="fb-email">
						<p><strong>Email Address</strong></p>
						<input class="signup_text_input" id="facebook_user_email" name="facebook_user[email]" size="30" type="text" />
						<img alt="Small" id="facebook_email_indicator" src="http://assets2.bleacherreport.com/images/shared/spinners/small.gif?1265299081" style="display:none" />
						
					</div>
				</div>
				<div class="input" id="facebook_password_container" style="display:none">
					<div class="fb-first-name notice">
						<p>This email address matches an existing user profile. Please enter your password to connect your accounts.</p>
						<p><strong>Password</strong></p>
						<input class="signup_text_input" id="facebook_user_password" name="facebook_user[password]" size="30" type="password" />
						
					</div>
				</div>
			</li>
				<div id="facebook_questions" style="display:none">
			<li class="fb-question" id="facebook_full_name_container">
				<p class="question">
					<label for="facebook_user_use_full_name">Use your full name <strong class="full_name"></strong> on Bleacher Report?</label>
					<br />
				</p>
				<p class="options">
					<input name="facebook_user[use_full_name]" type="hidden" value="0" /><input checked="checked" id="facebook_user_use_full_name" name="facebook_user[use_full_name]" type="checkbox" value="1" />
					<label for="facebook_user_use_full_name">Yes</label>
				</p>
				<div class="input full-name-edit" style="display:none">
					<p>Edit your name for Bleacher Report:</p>
					<div class="fb-first-name">
						<label for="facebook_user_first_name">First Name <em>(required)</em></label>
						<input class="signup_text_input" id="facebook_user_first_name" name="facebook_user[first_name]" size="30" type="text" />
						
					</div>
	
					<div class="fb-last-name">
						<label for="facebook_user_last_name">Last Name <em>(required)</em></label>
						<input class="signup_text_input" id="facebook_user_last_name" name="facebook_user[last_name]" size="30" type="text" />
						
					</div>
				</div>
			</li>
			<li class="fb-question">
				<p class="question">
					<img src="/images/default-user-icon-medium.png" class="profile_pic" />
					<label for="facebook_user_use_profile_pic">Do you want to use your Facebook profile picture on Bleacher Report?</label>
				</p>
				<p class="options">
					<input name="facebook_user[use_profile_pic]" type="hidden" value="0" /><input checked="checked" id="facebook_user_use_profile_pic" name="facebook_user[use_profile_pic]" type="checkbox" value="1" />
					<label for="facebook_user_use_profile_pic">Yes</label>
					
				</p>
			</li>
			<li class="fb-question" id="facebook_interested_in_writing_container">
				<p class="question"><label for="facebook_user_interested_in_writing">Are you interested in covering your favorite teams and sports?</label></p>
				<p class="options">
					<input name="facebook_user[interested_in_writing]" type="hidden" value="0" /><input id="facebook_user_interested_in_writing" name="facebook_user[interested_in_writing]" type="checkbox" value="1" />
					<label for="facebook_user_interested_in_writing">Yes</label>
					
				</p>
			</li>
			<li class="fb-question">
				<p class="question"><label for="facebook_user_share_activity">Do you want to share your Bleacher Report activity in your Facebook activity feed?</label></p>
				<p class="options">
					<input name="facebook_user[share_activity]" type="hidden" value="0" /><input checked="checked" id="facebook_user_share_activity" name="facebook_user[share_activity]" type="checkbox" value="1" />
					<label for="facebook_user_share_activity">Yes</label>
					
					<br />
					<a href="#" id="share_facebook_activity_advanced_link">Advanced Sharing Options</a>
				</p>
				<p id="share_facebook_activity_advanced" style="display:none">
					<input name="facebook_user[share_activity_article_writing]" type="hidden" value="0" /><input checked="checked" id="facebook_user_share_activity_article_writing" name="facebook_user[share_activity_article_writing]" type="checkbox" value="1" />
					<label for="facebook_user_share_activity_article_writing">When I write a new article</label>
					<br /><input name="facebook_user[share_activity_comment]" type="hidden" value="0" /><input checked="checked" id="facebook_user_share_activity_comment" name="facebook_user[share_activity_comment]" type="checkbox" value="1" />
					<label for="facebook_user_share_activity_comment">When I post a comment</label>
					<br /><input name="facebook_user[share_activity_like]" type="hidden" value="0" /><input checked="checked" id="facebook_user_share_activity_like" name="facebook_user[share_activity_like]" type="checkbox" value="1" />
					<label for="facebook_user_share_activity_like">When I like an article</label>
					<br /><input name="facebook_user[share_activity_poll_vote]" type="hidden" value="0" /><input checked="checked" id="facebook_user_share_activity_poll_vote" name="facebook_user[share_activity_poll_vote]" type="checkbox" value="1" />
					<label for="facebook_user_share_activity_poll_vote">When I vote on a poll</label>
					<br /><input name="facebook_user[share_activity_fan]" type="hidden" value="0" /><input checked="checked" id="facebook_user_share_activity_fan" name="facebook_user[share_activity_fan]" type="checkbox" value="1" />
					<label for="facebook_user_share_activity_fan">When I become a fan of another member</label>
				</p>
			</li>
			<li class="fb-question">
				<p class="question"><label for="facebook_user_fan_friends">Become fans of your Facebook friends connected to Bleacher Report?</label></p>
				<p class="options">			
					<input name="facebook_user[fan_friends]" type="hidden" value="0" /><input checked="checked" id="facebook_user_fan_friends" name="facebook_user[fan_friends]" type="checkbox" value="1" />
					<label for="facebook_user_fan_friends">Yes</label>
					
				</p>
			</li>
			<li>
				<a id="facebook_connect_submit"><img src="/images/shared/submit.png" /></a>
			</li>
		</div>
	</ul>
</form>

Sign up for Bleacher Report

Already have an account? Log in now » As a member you can get the latest on your favorite teams, post comments, write your own articles, and much more.

Join Bleacher Report

You must register in order for that functionality to work!

Sign up through Facebook

Follow your Facebook friends on Bleacher Report
Share your articles, comments, and more with friends

Great, , you're signed up!

i.e. San Francisco Giants, SEC Football, NFL, Golf

Selected Tags:

Yes, I'd like to receive an email newsletter for the topics I selected.

Bleacher Report: Houston

The Top Five Forgotten MLB Rookie Of The Year Candidates(NL Version)

Matt 'Frostin' Foote

#6

#5

#4

#3

#2

#1