Federer vs Del Potro: Barclay's ATP Final's Clueless Commentators

TennisMasta1Contributor INovember 27, 2009

LONDON, ENGLAND - NOVEMBER 26:  Roger Federer of Switzerland returns the ball during the men's singles round robin match against Juan Martin Del Potro of Argentina during the Barclays ATP World Tour Finals at the O2 Arena on November 26, 2009 in London, England  (Photo by Julian Finney/Getty Images)
Julian Finney/Getty Images

One would think that the paid commentators Jason Goodall and Robby Koenig at least understand the ATP rules. Otherwise how could ATP justify $84.95 per year from viewers like me to listen to them on TennisTV.com?

Today is another example of how uninformed these two are and how they mislead their viewers through the year.

At 2-2 in the third set of Roger/Delpo match, Koenig assures the viewers that Roger had at that point qualified for the semis. That is incorrect. The fact is Roger could have lost the set 0-6 and still qualified because his games won ratio of 50.62% would have been higher than Murray's 50.57%. That is, as soon as Roger won the second set he qualified for the semis. Clearly Koenig was misleading.

Then it was Goodall's turn. When Roger was serving 3-4 in the same third set, Goodall says that if Roger holds his serve he would advance to the semis (another incorrect statement contradicting Koenig's earlier incorrect pronoucement). Promptly Roger drops his serve and Delpo serves out the match. Goodall then quickly says that Delpo and Roger advance reversing himself from just a few minutes ago without any explanation whatsoever? Which of his statements is a viewer without a calculator to believe?

Related

    'I won't rule anything out' - Murray says he could miss Wimbledon

    Tennis logo
    Tennis

    'I won't rule anything out' - Murray says he could miss Wimbledon

    BBC Sport
    via BBC Sport

    Andy Murray shakes off racket rust in promising Queen’s Club comeback | Andy Bull

    Tennis logo
    Tennis

    Andy Murray shakes off racket rust in promising Queen’s Club comeback | Andy Bull

    Andy Bull
    via the Guardian

    Queen's 2018: Andy Murray loses to Nick Kyrgios on return from injury

    Tennis logo
    Tennis

    Queen's 2018: Andy Murray loses to Nick Kyrgios on return from injury

    BBC Sport
    via BBC Sport

    Andy Murray loses on return after Nick Kyrgios comeback at Queen’s Club

    Tennis logo
    Tennis

    Andy Murray loses on return after Nick Kyrgios comeback at Queen’s Club

    Press Association
    via the Guardian