McAdoo told reporters he'd consult with general manager Jerry Reese and team ownership before replacing Manning but that he hasn't yet reached that conclusion.
"It's a coaching decision, but it'd be something that if it ever would get to that point, I'd want to have a conversation with Jerry and ownership on it," McAdoo said, per NorthJersey.com's Art Stapleton. "But it's not to that point and I don't see that point coming. Ell's our quarterback. I have 100 percent confidence in Eli. We're gonna get a week away from it, and we're gonna come back fresh mind, fresh bodies and play better football."
Benching Manning would be an overreaction to what is undoubtedly a disappointing start to the season. The 36-year-old isn't responsible for a number of the problems plaguing the team.
According to Football Outsiders, the Giants are 22nd in defensive efficiency after ranking second in 2016. New York is also without its best playmaker. Odell Beckham Jr. had season-ending ankle surgery earlier this month.
Manning's numbers aren't even all that much worse than his career averages. He has 1,600 yards passing, 10 touchdowns and five interceptions. His 228.6 yards per game are only a few yards below his career mark (239.5 yards per game). According to Pro Football Reference, his interception rate (1.9 percent) is also on pace to be a career best.
Especially with Beckham out, throwing Davis Webb into the starting job would potentially be a disaster. DeShone Kizer's struggles—he leads the NFL with 11 interceptions—with the Cleveland Browns illustrates how elevating a rookie quarterback too early, especially on a losing team, can be detrimental to his development.
It's looking increasingly likely the Giants will miss the playoffs for the fifth time in six seasons. Despite that, McAdoo is smart to not even entertain the idea of demoting Manning.
🔥 Top Videos from Around B/R 🔥
'Last Chance U 'Star Getting His NFL Shot
Is 44-Year-Old T.O. Working Out for a Comeback?
Eagles Drafted a 6'8", 346-Lb Rugby Player 😳
Happy 4-Year Anniversary to the 2014 NFL WR Class
One-Handed LB Might Be Draft's Biggest Badass
Mayfield's Journey to the Draft Ends Thursday
Ball Fam Has Nothing on the St. Browns 😏
NFL Stars Spending Their Offseasons Giving Back
Derrius Guice Runs from Difficult Upbringing
Harold Landry Is Draft's Best Pure Pass-Rusher
Which Teams Are the Best Fit for Dez?
Johnny Football Is BACK!
Quavo's Mega-Celebrity Flag Football Game
Meet the NFL's Next Alshon Jeffery
Tremaine Edmunds Is NFL Draft No-Brainer
Grading the Rams' Deal with Suh
Meet the Undisputed Top CB in the NFL Draft
Grading Jordy Nelson's Deal with the Raiders
Grading the Kirk Cousins Contract
Grading the Allen Robinson Contract