Super Bowl 2016: Panthers vs. Broncos Box Score Predictions, Stat Comparisons

Jared Johnson@@jaredtjohnson21Featured ColumnistJanuary 26, 2016

Carolina Panthers' Cam Newton celebrates after the NFL football NFC Championship game against the Arizona Cardinals, Sunday, Jan. 24, 2016, in Charlotte, N.C. The Panthers won 49-15 to advance to the Super Bowl. (AP Photo/Chuck Burton)
Chuck Burton/Associated Press

It's always great to see a matchup between the best NFL teams on opposite sides of the ball. It's even better when it happens in the Super Bowl.

The Carolina Panthers scored a league-leading 500 points during the regular season, while the Denver Broncos allowed a league-low 283.1 yards per game. Both squads grabbed the No. 1 seed in their respective conferences, and now they get to do battle on the huge stage of Super Bowl 50.

With a look at the below table, we can get a pretty good idea of what each team's strengths and weaknesses are. With that in mind, let's predict what the game's final box score might look like. We'll focus on offensive performance both through the air and on the ground, as well as what sort of big plays each defense will cause.

Panthers vs. Broncos: Statistical Comparison
Passing Yardage Per Game (Rank)224.3 (24)248.1 (14)
Rushing Yardage Per Game (Rank)142.6 (2)107.4 (17)
Opponent Passing Yardage (Rank)234.5 (11)199.6 (1)
Opponent Rushing Yardage (Rank)88.4 (4)83.6 (3)
Turnover Differential (Rank)+20 (1)-4 (19)
Third-Down Conversion Percentage (Rank)42.4 (7)35.3 (25)



In one of the very rare moments of the past 17 years, Peyton Manning is actually at a large disadvantage in the quarterback matchup. Cam Newton deserves the MVP award this year for his work with the Panthers, and the Broncos are just hoping Manning can manage the game effectively with short, accurate throws.

In this game, Newton does face the tougher defense, but not by that much. The Broncos' specialty is their pass rush, often not even needing a blitz to get pressure on opposing quarterbacks. Carolina's strong offensive line will have its hands full keeping the likes of DeMarcus Ware and Von Miller out of the backfield.

Peyton Manning must keep the turnovers to a minimum if the Broncos want a shot at winning the game.
Peyton Manning must keep the turnovers to a minimum if the Broncos want a shot at winning the game.Charlie Riedel/Associated Press

However, Newton's scrambling ability will come in handy here. His speed to get to the edge will force a lot of different looks from the Denver defense compared to when the unit faced the pocket-bound Tom Brady in the AFC Championship Game.

Manning's return to the field for the past three Broncos games has been a success, as the 39-year-old's play has been a factor in wins against the San Diego Chargers, Pittsburgh Steelers and New England Patriots.

Now, he faces a Panthers pass defense that is much stronger than all of those three teams' units. All three of those squads ranked 13th or worse in opponent passer rating, while Carolina had the best mark in the league.

With the Broncos offense a bit overmatched, Manning may get his share of yardage with Denver trying to get back in the game in the second half. An interception both before and after the intermission for Manning will also be tough for his team to overcome.

Predicted Quarterback Box Score
Cam NewtonPeyton Manning
Passing Completions18/2922/40
Passing Yards246216
Passing Touchdowns/Interceptions1/01/2
Rushing Yards/Touchdowns58/1-2/0
Predictions belong to author


Running Backs

Jonathan Stewart has been a force toting the ball in the playoffs against two tough defenses. Against the Seattle Seahawks and Arizona Cardinals, he combined for 189 rushing yards and two touchdowns.

He faces another stiff challenge in the Broncos' tough front seven, but the threat of Newton's passing and running ability will open him up for a few nice runs. Fullback Mike Tolbert should also come in to rush during a few short-yardage situations, with mixed results.

Jonathan Stewart helps take pressure off of Cam Newton, and Newton does the same for him.
Jonathan Stewart helps take pressure off of Cam Newton, and Newton does the same for him.Bob Leverone/Associated Press/Associated Press

C.J. Anderson and Ronnie Hillman have split carries pretty evenly in the backfield this season, but Anderson has been hotter in recent weeks and is my pick to get the heavier workload during the Super Bowl. Carolina can play more men in the box because of Manning's lack of arm strength at this point in his career, so that does decrease the likelihood of the Broncos' running game having a big day.

Predicted Running Back Box Score
Jonathan StewartC.J. Anderson
Rushing Attempts1813
Rushing Yards7146
Rushing Touchdowns10
Receiving Yards/Touchdowns12/020/0
Predictions belong to author


Wide Receivers/Tight Ends

Tight end Greg Olsen should play a huge role in this game as a safety valve for Newton when the Broncos force him to rush his throws. He has a serious argument as the best player at his position not named Rob Gronkowski, and he helps cover up the fact that the Panthers don't have a true No. 1 wide receiver.

Ted Ginn Jr., though, is the closest thing Carolina has to a stud wideout, and his speed makes him a strong candidate to rip off a couple of big plays to take the top off the Broncos defense.

Can Demaryius Thomas shake off a poor AFC Championship Game performance to be a factor in the Super Bowl?
Can Demaryius Thomas shake off a poor AFC Championship Game performance to be a factor in the Super Bowl?David Zalubowski/Associated Press/Associated Press

For Denver, No. 1 receiver Demaryius Thomas will get the Josh Norman treatment for much of the game. Norman is an elite cornerback and Thomas has been off the past couple of games (six receptions and 52 yards on 13 total targets), so his statistics may not jump off the page 

The Broncos' No. 2 wideout, Emmanuel Sanders, is the guy Manning will have to force some passes to, and a receiving touchdown for the 28-year-old is likely.

Predicted Wide Receiver/Tight End Box Score
Greg OlsenTed Ginn Jr.Emmanuel SandersDemaryius Thomas
Receiving Yards97616955
Receiving Touchdowns1010
Predictions belong to author


Defense/Special Teams

The Panthers' defense is very, very good. We already discussed their league-low opponent passer rating, but they were also fourth in rushing yards allowed. They had 39 takeaways, the most in the NFL.

The unit will get a boost if linebacker Thomas Davis can play. Per ESPN's David Newton, Davis broke his arm in the NFC Championship Game and had surgery on it Monday but still plans to play in the Super Bowl.

As good as Carolina's defense is, Denver's point-preventing brigade is even better. It had a magnificent showing against the Patriots in the AFC Championship Game, with defensive coordinator Wade Phillips continuing to add wrinkles from their dream season on that side of the ball.

The reality is, though, the Panthers get a sizable advantage here by virtue of the offense they are facing. Although Denver's defense is amazing, Carolina's is somewhat close. You can't say the some on the other end, where Cam Newton and Co. have been more explosive than the Broncos all season long.

Predicted Defense Box Score (Big Plays)
Panthers DefenseBroncos Defense
Forced Fumbles/Fumble Recoveries1/02/1
Predictions belong to author



    Gronk to Return for 2018 Season

    NFL logo

    Gronk to Return for 2018 Season

    Rob Goldberg
    via Bleacher Report

    Simms' Final NFL Draft Predictions

    NFL logo

    Simms' Final NFL Draft Predictions

    Chris Simms
    via Bleacher Report

    Rosen: I'll Be Last Man Standing from Draft

    NFL logo

    Rosen: I'll Be Last Man Standing from Draft

    Alec Nathan
    via Bleacher Report

    Cook Set to Regain Workhorse Form After ACL Tear

    NFL logo

    Cook Set to Regain Workhorse Form After ACL Tear

    Rob Goldberg
    via Bleacher Report