Manchester United's Narrow FA Cup Win Offers Little Hope of Future Improvement

Paul Ansorge@@utdrantcastFeatured ColumnistJanuary 10, 2016

Louis van Gaal during Manchester United's win over Sheffield United
Louis van Gaal during Manchester United's win over Sheffield UnitedOLI SCARFF/Getty Images

OLD TRAFFORD, Manchester — Memphis Depay's arrival into Manchester United's third-round FA Cup win over Sheffield United changed the game.

Louis van Gaal may be able to take some credit for bringing his compatriot on to make an impact, but United's manager oversaw yet another drab, unconvincing performance which left fans scratching their heads over how he is still in a job.

When Sheffield United's supporters sang "you're getting sacked in the morning," it is easy to imagine many Manchester United fans thinking "if wishing made it so," and yet having seen out a four-game losing streak over Christmas, it seems that Van Gaal is entrenched in his position.

Which is, frankly, bad news for any fans of the beautiful game. Van Gaal has stripped United bare of invention and joie de vivre. He has made attending Old Trafford, something which people around the world dream of being able to do, into a chore.

For 94 minutes on Saturday evening, under the wintry rain, the Theatre of Dreams was not a happy place.

There was a moment in the second half unique in the memory of those in attendance. Shortly after Memphis had been brought on, he cut inside and unleashed a decent shot.

Almost to a person, Old Trafford stood to applaud, followed by an ironic cheer that rang out as loud as almost any noise the home fans made at any point at the game.

It was an audible outpouring of frustration. United had been so toothless, so lacking in ambition that seeing a player shoot seemed worthy of applause. The ironic cheer seemed to grow out of the collective realisation of just how poor the Red Devils had been.

Rooney celebrates his successful penalty
Rooney celebrates his successful penaltyJon Super/Associated Press

Perhaps Wayne Rooney's late penalty winner will represent some kind of turning point, a Mark Robins moment for a new generation.

At the moment, though, this seems a long shot. United came within a couple of minutes of their seventh 0-0 draw at home of the season, and they will count themselves lucky they avoided that fate.

Assuming Van Gaal keeps his job—and given he was not sacked after four defeats it seems unlikely he will go out after a win—it is hard to see significant enough changes coming to make the difference.

Van Gaal cited United's inability to move the ball quickly in the first half as being a big part of the side's problem. When asked by Bleacher Report why his side were not moving the ball quicker he replied:

"Because there are 10 men behind the ball, in the square 20 metres, then the goal is behind that square, 20 metres. It is for every team very difficult. When you see the results today you see that every lower team is making a good result. Because defending is more easy than attacking, and everybody knows that."

It is not exactly an answer as to why, after a season-and-a-half in charge, he has been unable to crack the code. Sheffield United played reasonably well, but theirs was not a backs-to-the-wall defensive performance for the ages.

Rather, with a bit of rudimentary defensive organisation they were able to completely negate United's attack for most of the game.

There are countless small changes that could be made to potentially impact United's attacking football. However, many of them have been tried. Combinations of Anthony Martial, Wayne Rooney, Juan Mata, Memphis and Ander Herrera have been used in a varying array of positions.

And for the most part, none of it has worked. The key to unlocking the deep and narrow-lying defences that United have come up against time and again has simply not been found.

The best football United have played under Van Gaal came following a fundamental shift in formation. Perhaps something along those lines will manifest itself in the weeks ahead.

If it does not, United fans will be forced to endure more long, relatively joyless afternoons and evenings at Old Trafford, as the attritional football on show under Van Gaal continues to grind the romance around the club into the dust.


Quotations obtained firsthand.


    Scholes Enjoyed Mourinho’s Remarkable Rant

    Manchester United logo
    Manchester United

    Scholes Enjoyed Mourinho’s Remarkable Rant

    Planet Football
    via Planet Football

    Neymar: 5 Months at PSG Have Felt Like 5 Years

    World Football logo
    World Football

    Neymar: 5 Months at PSG Have Felt Like 5 Years

    Tom Sunderland
    via Bleacher Report

    Klopp Compares Salah to Messi

    World Football logo
    World Football

    Klopp Compares Salah to Messi

    Joe Williams
    via Football365