Pasadena Dreamin': BCS Probability Rankings

John Harkey by Correspondent Written on September 08, 2009

Slide 1 of 12

LOS ANGELES - SEPTEMBER 5:  San Jose State Spartans players walk out of the tunnel onto the field before the game with the USC Trojans on September 5, 2009 at the Los Angeles Coliseum in Los Angeles, California.   (Photo by Stephen Dunn/Getty Images)
Stephen Dunn/Getty Images

Throw the latest AP poll out the window, go ahead and toss the Coaches Poll in the trash and forget about the Heisman Trophy race.

At this point in the season, polls and rankings are nothing more than popularity contests. Come season’s end, the only system that matters is the final Week BCS Standings.

Love it or hate it, there is no denying the significance of the final BCS rankings. The top two teams in that final poll will make the trip to Pasadena in early January to battle for the National Championship with the outsider's watching comfortably from home.

It may be early in the season, but a few teams have already emerged as front-runners with an inside track on the path to Pasadena for the 2009 BCS Championship.

Whether it be superior talent, veteran experience or ease of schedule, each of the following teams is ranked by their overall probability or likelihood they will finish in the top two of the final BCS rankings on Dec. 6.

No. 1 Florida Gators

GAINESVILLE, FL - SEPTEMBER 05:  Tim Tebow #15 of the Florida Gators attempts a pass during the game against the Charleston Southern Buccaneers at Ben Hill Griffin Stadium on September 5, 2009 in Gainesville, Florida.  (Photo by Sam Greenwood/Getty Images

No surprise here.

The defending champion Florida Gators are returning a full squad of starters from last year’s championship team including senior leaders on both sides of the ball (Tebow and Spikes). The Gators are without a doubt the odds on favorites to not only make it to the BCS Championship, but win it as well.

After their complete domination of Charleston Southern in Week 1, we really don’t know much more about Florida than we did after their spring game. Their starters played well, but worked with a restricted playbook and saw very limited action before the second and third teams hit the field.

The Gators have a favorable schedule to make a strong run at their third title in the past four seasons. The expectations surrounding this program are the highest in school history and anything less than a BCS Title would be considered by many to be a monumental collapse.

Greatest Strength: Returning championship experience.
Biggest Hurdle: Tremendous expectations.
Potential Upset: @LSU

No. 2 Penn State Nittany Lions

STATE COLLEGE, PA - NOVEMBER 22:  Navorro Bowman #18 and Kevin Cousins #9 of the Penn State Nittany Lions celebrate after clinching the Big Ten title and advancing to the Rose Bowl after the game against the Michigan State Spartans on November 22, 2008 at

It absolutely pains me to rank any Big 10 team this high, but you simply can’t deny Penn State’s ease of schedule.

The Nittany Lions have the easiest schedule of any major BCS conference team in the nation, bar none. Penn State opens the season with non-conference games against Akron, Syracuse and Temple. Let’s not forget about Eastern Illinois in Week 6.

It’s important to keep in mind that these rankings are based purely on “probability” of finishing in the BCS top two. Any team with the nation’s easiest schedule logically presents itself with the best opportunity to run the table with a perfect season. For this reason alone, I would have to say that Penn State has an inside track in the race for BCS No. 2.

If Penn State can survive a marginal Big Ten schedule and hold off Ohio State in Happy Valley, the Nittany Lions may very well be in BCS Title Game come January. They may not be the most talented contender, but they will be there to represent in true Big Ten fashion…another embarrassing BCS loss.

Greatest Strength: Veteran squad of returning starters.
Biggest Hurdle: Getting passed from behind in BCS.
Potential Upset: @ Illinois

No. 3 BYU Cougars

ARLINGTON, TX - SEPTEMBER 05:  (L-R) Romney Fuga #98, Vic So'oto #37 and Manase Tonga #11 of the Brigham Young Cougars celebrate a 14-13 win against the Oklahoma Sooners at Cowboys Stadium on September 5, 2009 in Arlington, Texas.  (Photo by Ronald Martin

Goodbye, Oklahoma. Hello, Brigham Young.

Last week’s upset over Oklahoma was one small step in the season, but one giant leap for the Cougars shot at playing in the BCS Championship.

BYU did not beat Oklahoma just because Sam Bradford went down with an injured shoulder in the closing seconds of the first half. Even with a healthy Bradford, Oklahoma was not dominating that game by any stretch of the imagination. In fact, BYU seemed to be the team in control of the game at the time of Bradford’s injury.

The reason why BYU is so high in the “probability rankings” is due to the fact that they already have that quality win over a top-three program and still have a possibility of playing (and beating) three more ranked opponents.

Although I wouldn’t advise Cougar fans to start booking airfare to Pasadena just yet, I would suggest they show up in droves for the remaining home games against FSU, TCU and Utah. These three games will be key to their BCS dreams.

Greatest Strength: Quality opponents.
Biggest Hurdle: Finishing the season as strong as they started.
Potential Upset: FSU, TCU, Utah

No. 4 Texas Longhorns

AUSTIN, TX - SEPTEMBER 5:  Defensive end Eddie Jones #31 of the Texas Longhorns leads the team onto the field for their first game, a game against the Louisiana Monroe Warhawks, on September 5, 2009 at Darrell K Royal-Texas Memorial Stadium in Austin, Tex

Everyone knows what happened to Texas last season. They got caught up in a twisted Big 12 tiebreaker and ended up drawing the shortest straw, missing out on the Big 12 Title Game and BCS Championship Game by the narrowest of margins.

To say that Texas will play with a chip on their shoulder this season is a complete understatement. Colt McCoy is likely to have another Heisman-type year, but the Longhorns will not roll through most opponents on their schedule.

Say what???

You heard me. The Longhorns will be tested early and often, starting with Texas Tech in Week 3. Need I remind anyone of last year’s Tech game? I didn’t think so.

Oklahoma, Oklahoma State, Baylor and Texas A&M are all formidable opponents regardless of their rankings, and have the potential be play spoiler in a season when Texas wants to prove they belong more than any other team in the nation.

If Texas survives that schedule, there is no team in the nation that will keep them out of the BCS title game this season.

Greatest Strength: The Colt McCoy-Jordan Shipley connection.
Biggest Hurdle: Tough schedule.
Potential Upset: Oklahoma State, Kansas, @Baylor

No. 5 Boise State Broncos

BOISE, ID - SEPTEMBER 3:  Kellen Moore #11 of the Boise State throws a pass under pressure by T.J. Ward #2 of the Oregon Ducks in second quarter of the game on September 3, 2009 at Broncos Stadium in Boise, Idaho. Boise State won the game 19-8. (Photo by

Heading into the season, the Blue Broncos had to win one game in order to make it into a BCS bowl. Mission Accomplished.

The victory over Oregon left Bronco Nation riding high on the horse...until BYU upstaged them with a monumental upset of their own.

Despite the successes or failures of other teams, Boise State remains a virtual lock to finish the regular season undefeated and make it back to another BCS Bowl. Quite simply, there are no contenders left on the schedule to challenge the Blue Broncos.

All Boise State has left to do is just cruise control through the remainder of the season, practice their gimmicky offense to perfection and hope and pray that a few of the BCS big dogs above them falter down the stretch.

Greatest Strength: Virtual lock for undefeated regular season.
Biggest Hurdle: Weak strength of schedule.
Potential Upset: Close eyes and point…eeny, meeny, miny…Fresno State?

No. 6 Ohio State Buckeyes

COLUMBUS, OH - SEPTEMBER 05:  Quarterback Terrelle Pryor #2 of the Ohio State Buckeyes tries to elude the tackle of Blake Carter #1 of the Navy Midshipmen at Ohio Stadium on September 5, 2009 in Columbus, Ohio.  Pryor ran for one touchdown and threw for o

The Buckeyes looked very shaky in their game versus Navy this week which only proves my point about the lack of strength in the Big 10 this season. And, we will find out relatively quickly whether or not the Buckeyes are contenders or pretenders.

Ohio State is essentially in the same position as Penn State, except they sprinkled in a bit of Southern California spice into their bland schedule. This is a boom or bust game for the Buckeyes.

There is no doubt that Terrelle Pryor is an elite athlete. Now it’s time for Pryor to prove that he’s more than just a mobile arm. Pryor will be challenged by a solid USC defense to make quick decisions, execute plays and prove that the Buckeyes are a championship-caliber team.

If Ohio State can beat USC at home, they will vault in the rankings and take an inside track on the road to Pasadena. If not, they will still have a shot at Pasadena…only in the Rose Bowl, not the national championship.

Greatest Strength: Terrelle Pryor’s athleticism.
Biggest Hurdle: Terrelle Pryor’s decision-making.
Potential Upset: @ Penn State, Illinois

No. 7 Notre Dame

LOS ANGELES, CA - NOVEMBER 29:  Quarterback Jimmy Clausen #7 of the Notre Dame Fighting Irish walks out with teammates Robert Hughes #33 and Sergio Brown #31 before the game against the USC Trojans at Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum on November 29, 2008 in

The past few seasons in South Bend have been about as cold as Jimmy Clausen's frosted tips...

This season will be different for the Irish. Charlie Weis’s prized recruiting classes are finally starting to come to fruition. His players are experienced, battle-tested, seasoned and primed for a breakout year.

We’ve heard similar words quite a few times over the past few seasons, haven't we? Well, this is the first time that I actually believe that these statement may be true.

The Notre Dame offense should be productive this season with the return of starting quarterback Jimmy Clausen, leading rusher Armando Allen, and top wideouts Golden Tate and Michael Floyd. The Irish defense will be the key to pulling off an upset over USC in South Bend and carrying the squad to a BCS bowl.

The Irish have an almost identical schedule to Ohio State, playing their fair share of weak opposition before the USC train comes rolling into South Bend at midseason. Perhaps a BCS Championship appearance is a bit of wishful thinking, but this team is no worse than anything coming out of the Big 10.

Essentially, Notre Dame’s season boils down to winning the games they are supposed to win and pulling off one big upset.

It's also worth noting that the Irish also have the full support of Gator Nation behind them, with Gator fans across the world cheering rabidly for Weis to put together a BCS bowl season and keep Urban Meyer as far from South Bend as possible.

Greatest Strength: Battle-tested (although failed more often than not).
Biggest Hurdle: USC.
Potential Upset: Boston College, @Michigan

No. 8 Alabama Crimson Tide

ATLANTA - SEPTEMBER 05:  Running back Mark Ingram #22 of the Alabama Crimson Tide rushes upfield against the Virginia Tech Hokies during the Chick-fil-A Kickoff Game at Georgia Dome on September 5, 2009 in Atlanta, Georgia.  (Photo by Kevin C. Cox/Getty I

Despite losing many key impact players from last season’s team, Alabama has all the makings of a great team in 2009.

The defense looks stout and even more talented than last season. The offense returns super-sophomore playmakers Julio Jones and Mark Ingram. And, the special teams unit will be as dangerous as ever with elite return man Javier Arenas returning for his senior season.

So, why in the world is Alabama so low in the “probability rankings”?

The Crimson Tide play a brutal SEC regular season schedule. And, if they are fortunate enough to make it to the SEC Championship game, they will likely face the likes of the Florida Gators.

Alabama has a shot, but when it boils down to probability, they aren’t near the top of the list.

Greatest Strength: Outstanding defense.
Biggest Hurdle: Brutal schedule.
Potential Upset: @Ole Miss, LSU, Tennessee, @Auburn

No. 9 Oklahoma State Cowboys

STILLWATER, OK - SEPTEMBER 5:  Runningback Brandon Boykin #2 of the Georgia Bulldogs dives for the ball for the ball as Dez Bryant #1 of the Oklahoma State Cowboys cannot make the pass during the third quarter of the game at Boone Pickens Stadium on Septe

Oklahoma State isn't necessarily a dark horse this season, but they can play the role of spoiler and actually have a decent shot at playing for the Big 12 Title. If this happens, the sky is the limit as to where they could play in January.

The biggest challenge for Oklahoma State will be surviving amongst the fittest of the Big 12. The regular season schedule is about as tough as it comes. After outlasting a formidable SEC opponent in Georgia, the Cowboys now turn toward a "soft" few games before facing the heart of the Big 12 South schedule.

The Cowboy offense is loaded with veteran, NFL-caliber playmakers and their chances of playing for a Big 12 title this season are just as good as any other team in the competitive South division.

The Cowboys should be undefeated when Texas comes rolling into town on Oct. 31, setting the stage for a de facto Big 12 Championship Title Game. Can you say spoiler?

Greatest Strength: Outstanding offense.
Biggest Hurdle: Tough schedule.
Potential Upset: @Baylor, Texas Tech, Iowa State

No. 10 Southern California Trojans

LOS ANGELES, CA - SEPTEMBER 05:  Quarterback Matt Barkley #7 of the USC Trojans laughs on the sidelines during the game against the San Jose State Spartans on September 5, 2009 at the Los Angeles Coliseum in Los Angeles, California.  The Trojans won 56-3.

USC is the wild card in this year’s BCS equation. The Trojans have a formidable Pac-10 schedule and tough road games in Columbus and South Bend.

In recent years, USC has made a habit out of winning the big games, but tripping up and losing to inferior opponents down the stretch. Although loaded with talent, this year could yet again be much of the same.

The Trojans are putting all their faith in the arm of a 19-year old, Matt Barkley. The baby-faced, true freshman quarterback is not much more than a few months removed from his high school diapers, but is already being called upon to lead the Trojans to the promised land.

I’m not much of a betting man, but if I were, I would bet that the 19-year old Barkley is bound to make a mistake or two somewhere along the way that will cost USC a game. And, one loss this season is all it will take to ruin a title shot. For this reason, USC barely holds on to the No. 10 spot in the “BCS Probability Rankings."

Greatest Strength: Talent and depth.
Biggest Hurdle: Zach Morris...I mean, Matt Barkley.
Potential Upset: @Notre Dame, @Ohio State, @Cal, @Oregon

(2)
...
Share This  
Crop_45x45
or to post this comment

12 Comments

There are no comments yet. Get the conversation started by leaving the first comment

Loading more comments...
posted just now
  • Loading...
  • Nobody has liked this comment yet
Cancel

This comment and all replies have been deleted This comment has been deleted Undo delete

418
reads

12
comments

written on September 08, 2009 Rankings/List

The best newsletter on the web

Subscribe Now

We will never share your email address


CBS Sports Official Partner
Certain photos copyright © 2009 by Getty Images.
Any commercial use or distribution without the express written consent of Getty Images is strictly prohibited.