Erick Blasco's Top 30 NBA Centers

(Photo by Chris Graythen/Getty Images)

As players who are generally in premium scoring position offensively and are a team’s final fortresses defensively, NBA centers have colossal impacts on their team’s successes, or lack thereof.

This list does not take into account a player’s future prospects or past salad days. The criteria is simple: Which NBA center would be best suited to winning a championship with a random collection of starting-level talent? For example, if Pau Gasol, Al Thornton, Joe Johnson, and Beno Udrih are your teammates, who would you want as your center?

Due to the way some lineups are presently constructed, a handful of teams have two potential centers in their starting lineup. For this reason, Troy Murphy, Antonio McDyess, Pau Gasol, and Anderson Varejao are listed as power forwards as they will likely play power forward in their team's starting lineup.

Other teams lack a true center. This is why, David Lee, Andrea Bargnani, Al Horford, and Al Jefferson are listed as centers.

No rookies made the list as neither you nor I have seen them play in meaningful games against meaningful competition to know where they should be ranked.

Yao Ming will be treated as if he’d play sometime this season.

With that said, the list.

1) Dwight Howard—Orlando Magic

Howard’s still a work in progress—his post moves are still too crude and lack appropriate finesse or counters, he’s still only average in his defensive awareness, he still has a bad habit of bringing the ball down into stripping position when he attacks the basket, and he has trouble defending players who can face and go.

He’s still the league’s premier big man, though.

Howard’s been the best rebounder in the game since he first suited up in 2004. He’s also evolved into a game-changing shot blocker on the defensive end.

Offensively, his screens eliminate defenders, and he’s the most effective dive-cutter in the game because of his sheer athleticism, strength, and quick hops.

If his offensive repertoire is limited to simple sweeping hooks with either hand, against the majority of too-slow, too-small, or too-dumb defenders, it’s still enough to produce points, fouls, or both. And he’s durable to boot.

Plus, while his performance against the Lakers revealed early symptoms of choke-itis, throughout the playoffs Howard showed the ability to be able to hit his free throws with some degree of consistency.

With how defenses are forced to foul him, imagine the production he could put up if he managed to convert just 70 percent of his freebies!

Because of Howard’s improving ability to create his own shot and understand opposing offenses, he’s wrestled the title of best NBA center away from Yao Ming. Now, the onus is on him to continue to improve his repertoire, his awareness, and his mechanics to become an all-time force, because his talent, on its own, is first ballot Hall of Fame material.

2) Tim Duncan—San Antonio Spurs

All pretense aside, Duncan is a center. He played center last year with power forward Matt Bonner, and he’ll play center this year with power forward Antonio McDyess.

It’s true, age has started to catch up to Duncan. Nagging injuries sap away at him, one sore muscle at a time.

He’s lost a touch of his explosion around the basket, and a smidgeon of lateral agility on defense.

That doesn’t mean Duncan isn’t the best post scorer and passer in the game. No other player has the array of hooks, spins, counters, turnarounds, drives, and jumpers that Duncan possesses.

He’s also one of the smartest players in the game, if not the smartest, understanding every offensive and defensive scenario and what needs to be done in any given situation.

However, Duncan’s days of single-handedly willing the Spurs' offense to success against elite opponents are few and far between. He’s also become simply above-average at defending his man one-on-one, and he isn’t the shot blocker he used to be. Those are the reasons I list him below Howard on my center list. But he’s still a comfortable second.

3) Yao Ming—Houston Rockets

After Duncan, Ming is the most accomplished offensive center around. Because of his towering height—a cool 7'6"—Yao’s turnaround jumpers from the left box are automatic.

Yao also has great touch around the hoop, is a great rebounder when he doesn’t have to track the ball, is a very smart help defender, and is excellent at defending the post.

However, Yao is one of the least athletic players in the league, which hinders him against smart, athletic defenses. He also has trouble reading double teams, defending screens, defending players who can turn and face, and not turning the ball over.

Yao’s biggest problem, though, is his injury struggles.

Before last season, he had missed at least 25 games a year three continuous seasons. While he was relatively injury-free last year, he was forced to miss the final four games of the Western Conference semifinals, and he’s likely to miss the entire 2009-10 season due to a broken bone in his left foot.

The injuries are a shame, because Yao’s one of the most skilled players in the game. More importantly, he’s one of the best people the sport has to offer.

4) Shaquille O’Neal—Cleveland Cavaliers

While Shaq isn’t anywhere close to the player he used to be, he still commands double teams, still punishes opponents in the low block, and is still one of the best passing big men in the game.

Aside from Duncan and Ming, Shaq has the most complete post game of any center, and he’s so massive, he’s a decent rebounder and space-eating defender just by standing up.

Of course, Shaq can’t defend players who can turn and face, can’t defend screens, can’t defend explosive post scorers, is too slow to provide adequate help defense, isn’t a great rebounder, and can’t play anywhere outwards of six feet from the hoop.

But post players who can draw doubles and make good decisions when doubled are extremely rare and valuable, which is why, at the ripe old age of 37 and a sliver of his former self, Shaq himself remains extremely valuable.

5) Al Jefferson—Minnesota Timberwolves

Jefferson is a professional scorer. He’s a dreadnaught in the low box, has an improving jumper, can blow by slower defenders, and will rebound capably. Unfortunately, that’s about all he can do.

Sure, defensively he’ll block an occasional shot, but he’s a slow and unaware defender who can’t pass, can’t understand double teams, and can’t do anything when the ball isn’t in his hands.

While he’s touted as one of the game’s finest young players, AJ still has work to do to become more than just a numbers-compiler on bad teams.

6) Kendrick Perkins—Boston Celtics

While he still fouls a bit too much, Perkins has already proven himself to be a championship-caliber defender. Few centers in the league have Perkins’ combination of strength, smarts, athleticism, and malevolence, which allows him to get under the skin of most opponents.

Offensively, Perkins has a developing right hook, finishes forcefully around the hoop, and creates earthquakes when his screens make contact. While Perkins’ high ranking is a product of the dearth of well-rounded centers in the league more than a testament to his own talents, every team would love to have the defensive backbone Perkins provides.

7) Amar’e Stoudemire—Phoenix Suns

Wondrously talented and insecure, Stoudemire is less than the sum of his talents. What can he do? Pretty much anything he wants, which is why he’s become a scoring machine (Who doesn’t want the glory of being a great scorer?).

In the post, off the dribble, on dive cuts or weak-side duck-ins, on mid-range jumpers, even curling around screens, no place inside the three-point line is spared Stoudemire’s fantastic ability to create points.

Of course, Stoudemire may be the worst defensive big man in the entire game. Making mistakes, missing rotations, playing without focus, getting routinely undressed by his own defender, Stoudemire is an opposing big man’s personal birthday present.

His own unwillingness to play defense (along with Steve Nash and Grant Hill) was the main reason why Terry Porter was fired and the Suns’ season was such an abomination. It’s also why Phoenix’s seasons always end in disappointment.

Plus, when a team makes a concerted effort to playing Stoudemire aggressively on defense, he often shuts himself down instead of arousing himself to the occasion.

Stoudemire’s on-court play and attitude show a need to feel loved and an unwillingness to take the responsibility needed to become a championship-caliber player.

There are more tell-tale signs. After suffering a preseason partially torn iris requiring goggles to protect his eye, he decided to irresponsibly discard his protective goggles after seven games because they didn’t feel “comfortable.”

He lashed out at Terry Porter last season for not having enough touches, despite leading the Suns in shot attempts.

He’s never been shy about proclaiming how talented he is.

He also had this to say about the difference between Terry Porter and Alvin Gentry:

“You want a coach that you can really hug and hold and high five and really have fun with. That makes it fun play. You can high five and hug your teammates. You don't want to have fear of your coach. You want to be respectable with him but you also want to be a friend with him.”

He added, “I think guys bought into the system somewhat as much as possible. We didn't quite make the playoffs but we stuck together, we stayed a team, and that's what's most important.”

Stoudemire doesn’t want responsibility, and doesn‘t want to compete. He wants to be hugged.

Until he develops a killer instinct, Stoudemire will always fold when he has to lead his team against opponents that play focused, disciplined—championship—basketball.

8) Andrew Bynum—Los Angeles Lakers

Bynum is an up-and-coming star, but injuries and attitude problems have curtailed his development.

While he struggled during the playoffs last season, it was clear that his knees had no explosion in them. Should those knees heal properly, Bynum is one of the most fluid big men in the game, though serious knee injuries in back-to-back seasons do raise some concern.

His attitude is a different story. He frequently criticizes Phil Jackson for not giving him enough touches, even though the Lakers are in the business of winning championships with bushels of talent at other positions.

Bynum is frequently confused defensively and his offensive game hasn’t taken off yet.

Still, the sky is the limit for Bynum, and one hopes with experience will come the wisdom for Bynum to get the most out of his phenomenal talents.

9) Nene—Denver Nuggets

For the first time in an eternity, Nene was healthy for an entire season last year and he showed the league why he was such an exciting prospect when first drafted.

His spin moves are tight and explosive, often leaving defenders coughing in his dust. It’s not a stretch to say that he could be a big-time post presence with more practice and touches.

He’s a decent defender and rebounder, but loses focus and has a nasty habit of not running back in transition or hustling if a play doesn’t involve him. The talent is there though, and if he improves upon his 2008-09 campaign, he can begin to blossom into the star he might become.

10) Tyson Chandler—Charlotte Bobcats

A defensive game changer, Chandler may be the most athletic center in the NBA. This gives him a unique ability to contest shots at the basket, while also defending screens and jump shots along the perimeter.

Not only is Chandler technically sound, but he plays with exuberance, giving his teams an emotional spark when he’s on the court.

His offensive skills are limited to dunks, put backs, and tip ins, but because of his athleticism, Chandler’s one of the league’s premier centers at filling lanes, dive cutting, and outsprinting opposing bigs to the basket and dunking in lobs.

None of the defensive-minded centers below him on the list bring the athleticism, versatility, and intensity Chandler plays with, and the offensive or balanced centers below him are all limited in major areas.

You're currently logged into Facebook

Do you want to share your Bleacher Report activity on Facebook?