Formula 1: Monaco Grand Prix: Are McLaren on a Comeback in Round 6?

Ben Auty gives his thoughts on the Formula One season so far.

by Ben Auty (Columnist)

6 comments

525 reads

May 14, 2008

Share this Story

  • Email to a friend
  • Print this article
  • Send to Facebook
  • Send to Digg

Currently UnEdited

This article has not been edited yet.

Formula One, Lewis Hamilton, Felipe Massa, Kimi Raikkonen, Ferrari, McLaren-Mercedes, Grand Prix, Heikki Kovalainen, Preview/Prediction

So into Round Six we go. The season is certainly spicing up now, as I’m sure you will all agree.

Ferrari have looked very strong in both Bahrain and Barcelona, finishing one-two in each. This has given them a welcome boost in the Constructor Championships points tally.

But something was different last weekend. Those boys at McLaren—usually consistent, conservative, and clinical guys—were forced into a three-stop strategy. Certainly this was not the norm for a track like Istanbul, but the Bridgestone representative had concerns about those trusty Potenza's.

Their worry was that on the softer compound tires—especially around turn eight, the famous four-apex corner—the Bridgestones where overheating and a blowout was an almost certain risk, just like the previous year.

So McLaren had to push on the harder compound tires, and adopt the three-stop strategy, using the softs for as little time as possible.

Most teams would certainly make a hash of a situation like this and end up way down the pecking order. However, McLaren managed to score not only a podium finish, but it a second-place one at that. And not only that—Lewis Hamilton in that MP4-23 at one point even overtook Felipe Massa in his Ferrari on the 24th lap to lead the race, then proceeded to extend a nearly eight-second lead at the front of the pack.

This was something that would prove to be crucial come his next pit stop, as it would bring him back out marginally in front of reigning champion and current points leader Kimi Raikkonen. Even after spending the last stint of the race under the intense pressure of Raikkonen's Ferrari, Lewis was able to hold on to second place behind Massa.

Massa notched his second Grand Prix win of the season, and his third in a row in Istanbul—although a convincing win it was not.

Hamilton's driving in this race was compared by many critics to that of the late, great Ayrton Senna—very gung ho, to the point, precise and very fast. Hamilton was like a man possessed, all over the back of that Ferrari—and once he was past it he knew he had a job to do.

The best race of his career so far? Many think so—even Mr. Hamilton himself.

He was quoted as saying that he had done absolutely everything right on race day, pushed the car, and got as much out of the MP4-23 as he possibly could. That was a sign to him that this was a great race.

Could the outcome have been any different? Yes, it certainly could have, for numerous reasons:

  • Lewis Hamilton chose the hard tires for qualifying. If he had chosen the softs, would he had clinched the pole? I think on this occasion, maybe not. Felipe Massa and Kimi Raikkonen experienced a very quick weekend in both practice and qualifying. And the only time Lewis looked set to mount a challenger was in Q1 whilst on the soft option—which we all know didn’t really work for him in the second sector of the track—plus, the durability wasn’t there.
  • If Raikkonen didn’t tag Kovalainen on that first corner, would Kimi have had the extra speed to mount more of a challenge to not only Hamilton, but Massa too? I think, maybe yes. Kimi had a problem with his front wing. In the dirty air of Hamilton and Robert Kubica, he struggled to keep down force to a maximum. This was proven when everybody else pitted before him—with a clean track, zero traffic, and good air to plough through, Kimi managed to achieve the fastest lap of the race. Maybe with a fully balanced car,    this kind of pace could have been maintained?
  • In the same breath, would Heikki Kovalainen have been able to hold off Raikkonen had he not suffered the early puncture? Maybe not, but in terms of a points-scoring position I think it would have been almost inevitable that the Constructors' total for McLaren would have been a little healthier after the race.

A lot of people are writing Kovalainen off,  deeming him inexperienced and saying that it was a bad move for McLaren to bring him in. They claim he wont live up to past greats such as Fernando Alonso, Mika Hakkinen, and Senna.

Looking at the evidence, I think he is shaping up to be a pretty consistent driver. His record since the beginning of the season has been 4-6-4-DNF-12. While this doesn't make great reading, considering his recent run of bad luck 4-6-4 isn't too bad—especially in terms of points finishing, and certainly considering the other cars were the two Ferraris and his teammate.

Kovalainen is very quick on the track. He has won two DHL Fastest lap awards in five races this year. He is a great qualifier, and I believe that he could be a top-four driver come the end of the season, with some consistency and a bit of luck. I don’t think Lewis has got it as easy as he may like at the top of the McLaren tree. The Ferraris certainly still need to keep an eye in their especially wide mirrors for a grinning Fin in his McLaren.

What does all this mean? Has the Ice man started to melt? Is Felipe letting silly mistakes creep in while trying to beat his teammate? Are Ferrari struggling with problems like they had last week in Istanbul on the soft tires due to lack of heat?

Is it a combination of all three? Or is it simply that McLaren are finding their feet and are about to enter a new phase of the season?

Well, I personally think it is the latter. McLaren are finding their feet, and are going to enter a new groove. I believe that all the problems they were experiencing have now been ironed out in the Barcelona testing session.

In this session, extensive work was done on the MP4-23, tweaking the aerodynamics of the car along with other numerous aspects. It would appear that it has been a success, as the car is now challenging the Ferrari on not only high-end, straight-line speed—and to be perfectly honest, it now seems to be superior in cornering to the Ferrari.

Now we have a competition on our hands! You would be a fool to write off Lewis and Heikki at this early stage in the season.

My prediction for Monaco would be to say that this will be primarily a good weekend for both of the top constructors. I think that Ferrari may come out on top of the qualifying, but it's not a one lap race. Looking after tires, hitting the apexes (quite literally), and a good race strategy may mean that a McLaren one-two is a very real possibility,

Will the Ferrari team be left checking their data and wondering what went wrong? Historically, McLaren have taken it up a gear in Monaco, and they could certainly mount a challenge to Ferrari. I am going to predict the following;

1st– Lewis Hamilton (McLaren Mercedes)

2nd- Kimi Raikkonen (Scuderia Ferrari)

3rd- Heikki Kovalainen (McLaren Mercedes)

4th- Felipe Massa (Scuderia Ferrari)

5th- Robert Kubica (BMW Sauber)

On a final note, it is sad to see the demise of any F1 team, but special sympathies go to all of the former team of Super Aguri. Good luck to you all. Hope to see Takuma Sato and Anthony Davidson back in an F1 car in the not too distant future.

Ben, over and out.

comments (6) write a comment »

  1. Superb article, really enjoyed reading it! Some great points and analysis.
    I think it is one of his best races by far, and definitely this season. Lewis really shone in Turkey, h worked the car well, and that overtaking move was fantastic. Not only did hamilton do well but the Mclaren boys worked well, even when there strategy changed to a 3-stopper.

    I'm hoping for a Mclaren 1-2 next week, just to prove that ferrari aren't so dominant!

    1. Thanks for the feedback Ryan, appreciate it ...

      I agree with you ... The 3 stopper really proved that Team McLaren really can turn it on and churn out a result in those kinds of conditions ... What great versatility !

      I am hoping the same for the result ... Fingers crossed hey !

  2. I think Hamilton did put in the best drive of his young career at this event, but I am not sure it is time to herald the return to the top for McLaren just yet.

    Kimi's first few turns lost him positions and cost him time. If not for that, it is a fairly safe Ferrari one-two finish. Clearly he made mistakes on his approach to turn 1, and Hamilton took full advantage of that, but Kimi's race otherwise was fairly well ran, and he proved he might have been a factor in the win with the fastest lap. I think it is therefore appropriate to conclude that Ferrari still has a mechanical and aero advantage over the McLarens. Lewis having a faster lap than Massa doesn’t mean that the McLarens have returned to form. It likely it indicates that Massa wasn’t threatened during most of the race.

    That said, if there is a race where the McLarens can take the fight to the Ferraris, it is Monaco. Without the ability to pass on track or the ability to run terribly close due to loss of down force, the McLarens can create more openings to attack the red cars. I expect good results from both Hamilton and Heikki Kovalainen if one of them can get on the front row and keep the Ferrari's close.

  3. Great comment Eric, thanks for that ... I know exactly where you are coming from ... Monaco WILL be incredibly exciting and anything can definately happen the best outcome could be some busted suspensions for the Ferraris and BMWs and then a 1-2 McLaren ... I am thinking you may be a Ferrari fan from your pic so you would disagree but in all honesty mate I wouldnt wish that on any team so I am sorry for that comment, no offence, this race will be a superb show of just what each team can do ... Think it could possibly be won and lost in qualifying ?

    1. No offense taken, and sorry for slow response, I am still learning my way about this site. While I will admit some partially, I enjoy good racing and a good show, and I have loved McLaren's approach to this sport for years. I think they are exceptionally professional and a class act on the whole, and I do enjoy watching the silver cars win, even if I am not as ecstatic as I might be for a Ferrari. One thing I am trying to strive for with my articles and comments are some measure of impartiality. No formula one fan can totally remove themselves from the sport to comment on it in a totally subjective manner, but I want to make rational and balanced discussions and talking points whenever possible. As such I thought it only fair to point out that McLaren is on the rise, but I wanted to reiterate your point that there is still work to be done.

    2. Couldnt agree more ... I am going for exactly the same thing, its incredibly difficult when you have loyalties to the teams that you have followed since childhood ... I feel like I always have a good argument and I am as fair to everyone as I am for McLaren ... Credit where credit is due in every case, if someone or a team does something exceptional then I will flag it and say ... Yes, well done, but the hardest thing of all is trying not to laugh when Ferrari get a bloody nose, ha ha ... I just love to see them fail ! Anyway ... Thanks for the response mate and dont worry about time getting back to me, aint no rush !

write a new comment


Edit this Article Article History

A partner of