Finding the next great thing is always a fun endeavor.
With that in mind, let's look at a few non-closers who could excel in a closers role, if given a chance.
Merkin Valdez, San Francisco Giants
By now, Merkin Valdez was supposed to be the ace of the Giants' pitching staff and one of the better pitchers in the league.
Things haven't worked out as planned.
Valdez struggled to develop the breaking pitches needed to survive as a starter, and worse yet, he needed Tommy John surgery after the 2006 season.
The Giants still think highly of Valdez. They carried him on their opening day roster this year even though he didn't throw a single pitch at any level in 2007 while recovering from Tommy John surgery. The Giants either had to carry Valdez from the get-go this year or risk losing him through waivers.
They know he has an arm that's too good to give away, and so far Valdez has validated their confidence in him. In 15.2 innings, Valdez has allowed two runs on 12 hits. He's walked six and has struck out 13.
Valdez, 26, has retained his electric stuff. His fastball has averaged 95.8 MPH this year and there's more in the tank if need be. He's also mixed in a few change-ups and sliders.
Current Giants closer Brian Wilson isn't in any immediate danger of losing his job, but he hasn't been lights out either. He's blown two saves, has a 3.86 ERA, and a 1.570 WHIP.
Over the course of a season, those types of numbers won't provide a lot of job security on a team that figures to win few games to begin with.
If Wilson is ever yanked from the closers role, Giants manager Bruce Bochy suggested Valdez could be the guy to replace him.
"That's where I see him eventually, possibly sooner rather than later, the guy helping out in later innings," he told the San Francisco Chronicle, last month.
Hong-Chih Kuo, Los Angeles Dodgers
Kuo is a survivor. At 28, he's already had a pair of Tommy John surgeries. It hasn't had an ill-effect on his stuff as he's racked up 33 strikeouts in just 24.1 innings this season.
Kuo fits the mold of many closers. He brings the heat—mid-90s with ease—and has never been good enough to stick as a starter.
He's already been in and out of the rotation this season, but has been lethal out of the pen, including a three-and-two-thirds of an inning stint earlier this week, in which Kuo struck out eight of the 13 hitters he faced.
With his stuff and his penchant for striking hitters out (141 in 119 career big league innings), it's easy to see Kuo closing.
What's not easy is seeing him doing it for the Dodgers, who currently have 38-year-old Takashi Saito cemented in the role. Saito has converted 89.4 percent of his saves in his Dodger career and is in no danger of losing his job.
Since he's 38, Saito is on the tail end of his career, but it's assumed that Jonathan Broxton will take over for Saito when the day comes.
Broxton has been one of the National League's best eighth inning relievers over the past couple seasons, though he has blown 11 saves in his career while converting just five.
Edwin Jackson, Tampa Bay Rays
Jackson—like Valdez—was supposed to be fronting a major league rotation.
While Valdez battled injuries, Jackson has battled ineffectiveness. The 24-year-old has a 5.57 ERA in over 300 major league innings. This year is no different as Jackson has had a mix of great starts and clunkers and it has added up to a 4.98 ERA and a 1.490 WHIP.
With his chances at excelling in the rotation looking increasingly slim, why not try him in the bullpen with the goal of grooming him to replace 39-year-old Troy Percival in a year or two?
The Rays lack a closer in waiting, and they have several top pitching prospects to find room for in the next few seasons. There's only so many rotation spots to fill, especially with Scott Kazmir, James Shields, and Matt Garza entrenched in theirs.
Jackson has two pitches—a mid 90s fastball and a wicked slider. If he's able to stop worrying about developing a better third offering, he can focus on the two good ones he already has.
If he can improve his control, he has the stuff to be a good closer.
These three pitchers all have the important intangibles that are required to be a stand-out closer at the major league level. Only time will tell if that's what they become.
comments (8) write a comment »
write a new comment
5 months ago
I think it is fair to say Valdez has a algiht chance to be a closer, but with Wilson being young and pretty effective, I'd almost rather see him moved back as a starter.
5 months ago
I'm not sure if
A) They want to put Valdez back in the rotation since he's proving effective in relief
and
B) If they want to put him back in the rotation at the potential risk of another injury.
Wilson's been OK, but he's not a guy I'd have a ton of faith in if I was a Giants fan.
5 months ago
Edwin Jackson has the ability to stay in the rotation in Tampa. They have a good club there and a lot of it depends on their better than average starting pitching.
Merkin Valdez has been lights out, but has nowhere near the amount of Major League experience to become a closer. I know that Wilson didn't have years of experience either, but his fearlessness and effectiveness has shown that he's bringing consistency to the closer position that hasn't been in SF for a few years.
Brian Wilson is just the kind of pitcher to have as a closer. He's a character through and through, but once he steps in between the lines, he's all business. And he has the closer facial hair that every one needs, be it Rod Beck's mustache, Robb Nen's goatee, or Eric Gagne's yellow glasses.
5 months ago
Yeah, I wasn't suggesting Valdez should be the closer now. But rather, that he could be a good one if given the chance down the line. And Wilson just isn't someone I completely would trust - yet.
Tampa does have a good team - one of the better young ones in all of the majors. That franchise is clearly on the upswing. But Jackson is just a guy I could see closing for them, especially if Niemann, Price, McGee and Davis push for starting jobs in the next year or so.
5 months ago
Great idea with Jackson, I like the guy as well and good point. But if he does put it together, Tampa will have a nails rotation and a closer can be found elsewhere. You need starters more than you need a closer in my opinion.
5 months ago
How much major league experience did Adam Wainwright have steeping in as a closer in 2006? He turned out alright...
Troy Percival has had 2 great years in a row - i see no reason to shake things up in the tampa pen.
I have to agree on Brian Wilson he may be out of a job relatively soon if this guy's dealing in the pen.
5 months ago
Percival has been good, but he's also 39. He can't go on forever. Percival (300+ saves) would be a good mentor to Jackson. I wasn't suggesting replacing Percival now - more groom Jackson to be his eventual replacement.
5 months ago
Jackson shouldn't be in the bullpen period. He's like Daniel Cabrera, he gets to a certain point where he couldnt find the strike zone with a map.
write a new comment