Why Don't Baltimore Orioles Fans Hate Tony Fernandez?

Matthew TaylorContributor IJuly 15, 2009

28 Jun 2001:  Tony Fernandez #1 of theToronto Blue Jays starts to head to first base after hitting the ball while at bat during the game against the Baltimore Orioles at The Skydome in Toronto, Ontario, Canada. The Orioles defeated the Blue Jays 5-0. Mandatory Credit: Rick Stewart  /Allsport

Orioles fans don't hate Tony Fernandez, although given the history, it seems there are some worthwhile reasons that they should.

Fernandez played only one season with the Yankees in 1995, and he never appeared in a Red Sox uniform. Even though he's never truly been a part of the division's Evil Empires, Fernandez has twice helped block the Orioles from postseason glory. That should be worth some hatred, right?

In 1997, the Cleveland Indians' clutch-hitting second baseman stroked an agonizing 11th-inning home run off Armando Benitez to clinch the ALCS. Fernandez also was a member of the 1989 Toronto Blue Jays who edged the 87-win Orioles for the A.L. East title during the non-Wild Card era.

Nevertheless, O's fans are more likely to hate a kid who turned a sure out into a home run ball during an ALCS Game One than they are to hate the player who swatted a series-ending home run during an ALCS Game Six. Even if Fernandez didn't cheat to win, he still plunged the final dagger into our warm postseason hearts.

Two factors seem to explain the lack of hatred for Fernandez in Baltimore:

1. Fernandez's extra-innings clout in the '97 ALCS came for the underdog Indians, so there was no inferiority complex at work. The Wire-to-Wire O's finished 98-64. Cleveland finished 86-75.

It's fair to say that O's fans held somewhat generous feelings toward the Indians for knocking the Yankees out of the playoffs, even as the teams squared off in the ALCS. Also, there was a widely held sentiment entering Game Six that the Birds would come back to win the series.

The reaction at Camden Yards to Fernandez's home run that October day was more shock than hatred (though we shouldn't have been surprised given that Benitez was on the mound). In fact, Orioles fans gave the Indians a standing ovation—a good old-fashioned tip of the cap—as they piled up on the mound after the game. I'm not sure we would've done the same thing for the Yankees.

Fernandez batted .357 during the '97 ALCS with a .438 on-base percentage.

2. While Fernandez was an All Star, a Gold Glove winner, and an MVP candidate in 1989, he didn't really perform well that season against the Orioles.

In 13 games against Baltimore Fernandez batted .235 with a .259 on-base percentage, no home runs, 7 RBI, and one stolen base. His .235 batting average against the O's was among a handful of his worst numbers against any one team.

Meanwhile, in the Jays' division-clinching win in Toronto on Sept. 30, 1989, Fernandez went 0-for-4 including an eighth-inning ground out with two runners on.

Why hate a guy who's not producing?

So it seems that one season with the Yankees, a dramatic, series-clinching home run for the Indians, and being part of a team that eked out a division title over the Orioles to end the fairly tale 1989 season have not been enough to produce hatred for Tony Fernandez among the Orange and Black fan base.

Still, the question that served as an unofficial team motto in 1989 is also worth considering in relation to the lack of hatred for Fernandez: Why Not?