4 College Football Teams Who Jumped onto the Playoff Committee's Radar in Week 1

Use your ← → (arrow) keys to browse more stories
4 College Football Teams Who Jumped onto the Playoff Committee's Radar in Week 1
Grant Halverson/Getty Images

Week 1 of the 2014 college football season isn't even over yet and already the College Football Playoff picture has been picked up and given a good shake. 

That just goes to show that preseason rankings weren't 100 percent accurate.

Who knew, right?

Some of the usual teams are still very much at the forefront of the playoff conversation. Matt Hayes of the Sporting News, for example, has Oklahoma, Florida State, Oregon and Michigan State as his top four. 

But other teams are starting to open some eyes. Big victories by Texas A&M and Georgia have put the Aggies and Bulldogs in the discussion for Hayes. 

By comparison, ESPN college football analyst Kirk Herbstreit has both A&M and Georgia in his first top four of the regular season: 

Which teams jumped onto the selection committee's radar after this weekend's action? Here are four that either recorded big wins over Top 25 teams or showed up big despite off-field concerns and should be considered. 

 

Texas A&M (1-0)

Much like Texas A&M in 2012 in the team's inaugural SEC season, the '14 Aggies caught just about everyone (outside College Station) by surprise.

Rainier Ehrhardt/Associated Press

A 52-28 win over No. 9 South Carolina in Columbia was as convincing a victory as any team could claim in Week 1. If anything, it showed that head coach Kevin Sumlin's hurry-up, no-huddle offense didn't need the most electrifying quarterback in college football, Johnny Manziel, to run it. 

A young but talented defense led by defensive end Myles Garrett and defensive back Armani Watts still has room to improve. But if A&M's offense runs that smoothly every week, the defense won't need to be a shutdown unit. 

A&M's nonconference schedule should be a breeze, but the heart of SEC play will determine whether the Aggies really have what it takes to be one of the four best teams in the country. If South Carolina can right the ship and turn in a good-to-great season, it's only going to help A&M's resume. 

After Thursday's win, though, Sumlin's team should have everyone's attention. 

 

Georgia (1-0)

Piggybacking off of South Carolina's loss, fellow SEC East member Georgia had the next-most convincing win. The Bulldogs ran away from Clemson in a 45-21 pile-on. 

If nothing else, Georgia appears to have one of the most talented and deepest running back rotations in the country in Todd Gurley, Nick Chubb, Sony Michel and Keith Marshall. 

"Gurley was obviously as good as it gets," Clemson coach Dabo Swinney said via Paul Newberry of The Associated Press (h/t The Atlanta Journal-Constitution). "Gurley, and all their backs, were special tonight."

As it so happens, Georgia plays South Carolina in two weeks following a bye. Winning the SEC East or the SEC isn't necessarily a prerequisite for getting into the playoff, but the Sept. 13 game remains important all the same. 

For one, South Carolina can get back into the SEC East discussion with a win over the Bulldogs. Similarly, the Bulldogs have a couple more high-profile games down the stretch against Missouri, Auburn and Florida. Beating the Gamecocks would be another notch on the resume. 

 

USC (1-0)

Mark J. Terrill/Associated Press

Scoff at Fresno State if you must, but the Trojans rarely, if ever, looked this good under former coach Lane Kiffin. In a 52-13 win over the Bulldogs, USC ran a blazing 105 offensive plays for 701 yards. 

What's more is that head coach Steve Sarkisian had his team running like a machine despite the separate situations with cornerback Josh Shaw and running back Anthony Brown, who quit the team and took to social media, calling Sarkisian a racist.

The Pac-12 is deep enough that the Trojans can't afford to overlook anyone, especially given their depth concerns. USC will be tested right out of the gate at Stanford in Week 2, and back-to-back games against Arizona State and Arizona in early October could be tricky. UCLA and Notre Dame present tough challenges at the end of the schedule at a time when injuries can pile up. 

Still, the Bruins' struggles against Virginia on Saturday, a 28-20 escape, opened some eyes. Meanwhile, UCLA's offensive line has a lot of work to do, which raises legitimate concerns about whether star quarterback Brett Hundley can stay healthy for the duration of the year. 

If the Trojans offense can come close to replicating the explosiveness and production it had during Week 1, this team will be in the playoff conversation late in the season. 

 

Notre Dame (1-0)

For one week at least, the academic suspensions involving five Notre Dame players didn't seem to hurt the Irish on the field. 

Notre Dame had no problem handling Rice in a 48-17 win. It may "just" be Rice—though the Owls won 10 games last season—but handling your business in the wake of suspensions so close to the season is a good sign. Furthermore, quarterback Everett Golson, making his first start back from his own academic suspension that cost him the 2013 season, looked sharp. 

The schedule gets tougher for Notre Dame, which faces Michigan, Stanford, Florida State, Arizona State and USC, among others, over the next few months. That will indicate whether Notre Dame is actually a playoff contender. 

The talent is there in South Bend to win a lot of games, but this team also showed it could stay together and play well despite a distraction. 

 

Ben Kercheval is a lead writer for college football. All quotes cited unless obtained firsthand. 

Load More Stories

Follow B/R on Facebook

Out of Bounds

College Football

Subscribe Now

We will never share your email address

Thanks for signing up.