Alex Rodriguez: Tragic and Triumphant

I’ve got this penchant about books. When I was in grade school, they opened a library near our school and I was always checking out mysteries for my mother and taking home an armful of airplane and war books for me.

I read some of them. Others I just looked at the pictures. No way was I going to read all of them in one night, or even one week, but somehow I thought it looked cool to have four books under my arm.

Who was I fooling?

But the habit persists. I buy or borrow books by the dozen and read them simultaneously. I am not a speed-reader, but I am a prolific note taker.

I took a lot of notes when I read Selena Roberts’ excellent book "A-Rod, The Many Lives of Alex Rodriquez." She thoroughly researched this superstar—even the snarky details about drugs, lying, and cheating in school that I had refused to believe.

Roberts revelas things like Rodriguez's use of steroids in high school, possibly as early as between his sophomore and junior years in Miami.

High school coaches can make or break young athletes

Following a dismal sophomore year where he hit only .256, Rodriguez's high school coach told him: “Next year everyone will get to know you, and in 12th grade you’ll be the No. 1 pick in the country.”

The summer between his sophomore and junior years was crucial for Rodriguez. Roberts said he ”morphed into a diamond-cut man-child.”

She references steroid purchases from a dog trainer, Steve Caruso, and his later relationship with Jose Conseco. He developed so rapidly from a gangly kid who could barely put one foot before the other into this daunting baseball player that “suddenly, no one could throw a fastball past him.”

His junior year, he batted .477 with 52 runs scored, 42 stolen bases, and six home runs. He got so big and strong he could bench 310 pounds and hit a ball 400 feet.

I first thought Roberts had it in for A-Rod

Not so. She wrote an excellent book that was balanced and well-referenced. She always tried to verify what she wrote by interviewing many people. She captures A-Rod as a tragic man.

The part of the book about “pitch tipping” really bothers me. That’s where A-Rod allegedly, while playing shortstop for Seattle and Texas, had friends on opposing teams at bat to whom he would flash or tip signals. He denies it, but again, Roberts does her homework and fairly nails down this allegation found on pages 119-121.

If Yankee position players like Derek Jeter, Jorge Posada, Robinson Cano and others don’t think that much of A-Rod, can you imagine how Yankee pitchers must feel?

An even better question is: Can the Yankees win a World Series with A-Rod, and how much better, or worse, would the Bronx Bombers be without him?

Turnaround

When Alex was at the plate, he supposedly received signals on pitches from the opposing shortstop. If true, this is an indictment about baseball as much as it is against A-Rod.

He denies it, of course.

Roberts' sources tell her that it may have only amounted to five or six extra hits a season, but that’s enough to bring up his average and ruin a pitcher’s performance.

You be The Judge

Here's the big thing: This is baseball, not Vegas. If caught, it’s enough to ban A-Rod or anyone else from the game for life, and I can’t understand how someone so intent about the game of baseball as Rodriquez would stoop to this.

You must read the book to understand this man’s feelings of inferiority turned into extreme egoism—growing up without a dad, wanting to be the best, and willing to do whatever it takes, which is both good and bad.

Despite the negative, the best thing I took away from the book was a positive on A-Rod

Baseball has always been his thing. He set high goals early and went after them. He is a super baseball player, and didn’t need to cheat. He exercises more than most players to stay thin. He gives millions away to charities.

Rodriguez had a great h