Eric Arnett started off the 2009 draft for the NYCBL, as he was taken with the 26th Pick of the 1st round. Arnett would be the first of 11 players drafted from Glens Falls, while 4 players were drafted from Watertown, Saratoga and Allegany County. Geneva, Amsterdam and Hornell drafted 3 players. Brockport, Webster and Elmira drafted 1 player this year. A total of 41 NYCBL players were taken in this years draft.