NL All-Stars 2014: Full List of Selections and Snubs After Voting Results

Sean ODonnellContributor IIIJuly 7, 2014

Los Angeles Dodgers' Yasiel Puig reacts after striking out to end the top of the fifth inning of a baseball game as Arizona Diamondbacks catcher Tuffy Gosewisch heads to the dugout on Saturday, May 17, 2014, in Phoenix. (AP Photo/Matt York)
Matt York/Associated Press

The National League's best players are now set to take the field during the Midsummer Classic after a long period of voting by MLB fans—or are they?

While the All-Star Game always features a bevy of talent each year, it can certainly be considered a popularity contest that has more to do with name recognition rather than on-field performances.

With the starting lineups finally revealed, we can now ask ourselves one question: Did the voters get it right?

Well, here's a look at the NL's starting lineup, courtesy of MLB:

Here's a look at potential starters to take the mound for the NL, but we'll have to wait to see who will ultimately be selected:

Although, not every pitcher on the list will be eligible to play, according to MLB:

Before we dive into the game's biggest potential snubs, let's take a look at the team's entire roster:

2014 NL All-Star Roster
CatcherYadier MolinaSt. Louis Cardinals
CatcherJonathan LucroyMilwaukee Brewers
CatcherDevin MesoracoCincinnati Reds
First BasePaul GoldschmidtArizona Diamondbacks
First BaseFreddie FreemanAtlanta Braves
Second BaseChase UtleyPhiladelphia Phillies
Second BaseDee GordonLos Angeles Dodgers
Second BaseDaniel MurphyNew York Mets
ShortstopTroy TulowitzkiColorado Rockies
ShortstopStarlin CastroChicago Cubs
Third BaseAramis RamirezMilwaukee Brewers
Third BaseTodd FrazierCincinnati Reds
Third BaseMatt CarpenterSt. Louis Cardinals
OutfieldAndrew McCutchenPittsburgh Pirates
OutfieldCarlos GomezMilwaukee Brewers
OutfieldYasiel PuigLos Angeles Dodgers
IF/OFJosh HarrisonPittsburgh Pirates
OutfieldCharlie BlackmonColorado Rockies
OutfieldHunter PenceSan Francisco Giants
OutfieldGiancarlo StantonMiami Marlins
RHPJohnny CuetoCincinnati Reds
LHPClayton KershawLos Angeles Dodgers
RHPZack GreinkeLos Angeles Dodgers
LHPMadison BumgarnerSan Francisco Giants
RHPAdam WainwrightSt. Louis Cardinals
RHPTyson RossSan Diego Padres
RHPJordan ZimmermannWashington Nationals
RHPJulio TeheranAtlanta Braves
RHPCraig KimbrelAtlanta Braves
LHPAroldis ChapmanCincinnati Reds
RHPFrancisco RodriguezMilwaukee Brewers
LHPTony WatsonPittsburgh Pirates
RHPPat NeshekSt. Louis Cardinals Highlighted

So, now with the roster intact, which players have been unreasonably left on the outside looking in?

Every year we see plenty of roster snubs, but it never fails to surprise. Here's a look at a handful of this year's biggest NL roster snubs.


Anthony Rendon, 3B, Washington Nationals

Anthony Rendon's exclusion from the NL's roster just doesn't make much sense at all. He's completely upped his game at the plate this year, batting .286 with 94 hits, 21 doubles, five triples, 12 home runs and 50 RBI.

Even his fielding percentage increased at third base from .868 in 2013 to .956 this season.

Jeff Passan of Yahoo Sports summed it up nicely with this tweet:


Anthony Rizzo, 1B, Chicago Cubs

Since Passan mentioned him in the previous tweet, we may as well get right to the snub of Anthony Rizzo.

He's been a great bat on a lackluster team this year, with a batting average of .274 including 84 hits, 13 doubles, one triple, 17 home runs and 45 RBI. He's holding his own defensively as well, with a fielding percentage of .992.

Those numbers may not warrant a start, but certainly deserve a place on the roster.


Casey McGehee, 3B, Miami Marlins

Casey McGehee may not be a power hitter, but he can sure manufacture runs.

Always steady at the plate, McGehee boasts a .317 batting average this season, including 106 hits, 20 doubles, one triple and one home run for 52 RBI. No slouch on defense, he's holding a fielding percentage of .983 and has only committed three errors this season.

All-Star Giancarlo Stanton had this to say about McGehee's snub, via Clark Spencer of the Miami Herald:

"I'm pretty mad. It still doesn't make any sense. I know people get gypped every year from it. But this is my first case of being together and seeing the dominance that [McGehee] has been."


Ryan Braun, OF, Milwaukee Brewers

Even though Ryan Braun has been dealing with a bout of back spasms recently, he's played well enough to warrant a spot on the NL's roster.

Batting .288 for the season with 79 hits, 17 doubles, five triples, 11 home runs and 49 RBI—not to mention a perfect fielding percentage—makes him the epitome of a snub. His numbers may be slightly down this season, but he's still one of the NL's top threats at the plate.


Buster Posey, C, San Francisco Giants

This is a rather close one due to the great play of Devin Mesoraco this season.

Buster Posey has been stellar on both offense and defense this season. He's batting .286 with 81 hits, 15 doubles, nine home runs and 41 RBI. Defensively, he boasts a .994 fielding percentage, has caught 14 baserunners and has only allowed three passed balls.

Those numbers just simply look All-Star worthy.


    Lindor Doesn't Want to Get Yoked 🚫💪

    MLB logo

    Lindor Doesn't Want to Get Yoked 🚫💪

    Scott Miller
    via Bleacher Report

    Yankees' Gardner: 'Red Sox Are the Team to Beat'

    MLB logo

    Yankees' Gardner: 'Red Sox Are the Team to Beat'

    Why 2018 Could Be Monumental for Trout

    MLB logo

    Why 2018 Could Be Monumental for Trout

    Sam Miller

    Prospects Most Likely to Break Out in 2018

    MLB logo

    Prospects Most Likely to Break Out in 2018

    Jacob Shafer
    via Bleacher Report