Manchester United

Scouting Report: Sebastian Rudy Manchester United's Plan B to William Carvalho?

Germany's Sebastian Rudy plays the ball during a friendly soccer match between Germany and Poland in Hamburg, Germany, Tuesday, May 13, 2014. The match ended in a 0-0 draw. (AP Photo/Michael Sohn)
Michael Sohn/Associated Press
Allan JiangTransfers CorrespondentJuly 3, 2014

Sporting Lisbon will only sell William Carvalho to Manchester United for €46.6/£37 million, per Sporting TV (h/t Sky Sports), so could Hoffenheim central midfielder Sebastian Rudy be a summer transfer window alternative?

To address that hypothetical scenario, here is a scouting report on Rudy, a 24-year-old, 5'10", 161-pound German international. 

 

Positives

Kicker.de

Able to play as a defensive midfielder via a holding role in a 4-2-3-1 or as a central midfielder via a shuttler role in a 4-4-2 diamond, Rudy is well-versed in orchestrating midfield proceedings. 

Rudy is a hard-worker, tallying 87 tackles and 45 interceptions in 27 Bundesliga games. 

League OnlyTackles Per GameFouls Per GameTackles Per FoulInterceptions Per Game
Darren Fletcher0.70.32.71.3
Marouane Fellaini2.82.11.31.9
Michael Carrick2.10.45.12.8
Sebastian Rudy3.21.91.71.7
Tom Cleverley2.20.73.01.5

On the ball, Rudy has shown snippets of brilliance. 

When Hannover 96 goalkeeper Ron-Robert Zieler went walk-about, he was punished by an audacious long-range shot from Rudy. 

Bundesliga.com

Rudy pierced Wolfsburg's defence with a lofted through-ball to create a goal for Hoffenheim centre-forward Anthony Modeste.

Bundesliga.com

Registering six assists in league play last season, Rudy's output was better than every single United central midfielder. 

League OnlyAssistsKey Passes Per GamePass Completion %Passes Per Game
Darren Fletcher00.689.155.8
Marouane Fellaini10.388.550.5
Michael Carrick01.088.670.7
Sebastian Rudy61.378.239.1
Tom Cleverley00.589.651.7

Against Borussia MonchengladbachRudy dominated midfield, spraying the ball around to complete 74 of 81 passes (91.4 pass completion percentage; per FourFourTwo).

FourFourTwo.com

Being a nifty dribbler is another trait Rudy is good at. 

Squawka.com

 

Negatives

PETAH TIQWA, ISRAEL - JUNE 06: Christian Clemens, Bernd Leno, Oliver Sorg and Sebastian Rudy (R-L) of Germany react after the UEFA European Under 21 Championship match between Netherlands and Germany at Ha Moshava Stadium on June 6, 2013 in Petah Tiqwa, I
Alex Grimm/Getty Images

A red flag in Rudy's game is his short attention span.  

Rudy failed to close down and apply pressure on Wolfsburg right-back Christian Trasch, who delivered a low cross into Hoffenheim's penalty box. 

Bundesliga.com

While staring at Bayern Munich left winger Franck Ribery's pirouette pass, Rudy forgot to mark Bayern right winger Thomas Mueller, who poached what turned out to be the winning goal. 

Bundesliga.com

Despite covering the post, Rudy did not block Gladbach centre-back Tony Jantschke's header. 

Bundesliga.com

Rudy was a step behind Hannover central midfielder Leon Andreasen

Bundesliga.com

Rudy excels at making rudimentary defensive stops, but lacks fundamental defensive positioning. 

He also needs to work on his passing accuracy.

While he is an incisive passer, his 78.2 pass completion percentage is below the United average (84.4).

 

Bottom Line

Kicker.de

German national team manager Joachim Low gave Rudy a run against Poland in what was a Die Mannschaft B team.  

Rudy was not Low's first-choice and he may not be United's preferred midfield target, but he could be a viable plan B to Carvalho, whose inflated €46.6/£37 million transfer valuation could become a barrier. 

With the potential to develop into an all-round midfielder, Rudy can grow under United manager Louis van Gaal

 

@allanjianga

Statistics via WhoScored.com

Where can I comment?

Stay on your game

Latest news, insights, and forecasts on your teams across leagues.

Choose Teams
Get it on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

Real-time news for your teams right on your mobile device.

Download
Copyright © 2017 Bleacher Report, Inc. Turner Broadcasting System, Inc. All Rights Reserved. BleacherReport.com is part of Bleacher Report – Turner Sports Network, part of the Turner Sports and Entertainment Network. Certain photos copyright © 2017 Getty Images. Any commercial use or distribution without the express written consent of Getty Images is strictly prohibited. AdChoices