Settling the Ricky Romero/Troy Tulowitzki Draft Argument

Ian HunterCorrespondent IJuly 2, 2009

The day was June 7, 2005; a day that up until this year had haunted the members of Blue Jays management because it was the day that they let Troy Tulowitzki get away.

That was...until Ricky Romero skyrocketed his way through the minor leagues and onto the Blue Jays' 40-man roster.

Four years later, that decision to go with the pitcher from Cal State Fullerton rather than the shortstop from Long Beach State is looking more and more like the correct one.

With the recent success of Romero at the major league level, the die-hard J.P. Ricciardi naysayers have been forced to admit that, in hindsight, drafting Romero wasn't such a bad idea after all.

Just like in a fantasy baseball draft, the Blue Jays were probably criticized and turned a few heads by drafting a pitcher so high at the number six position...especially with a very talented young middle infielder like Tulowitzki still available.

But I'm sure there were many logical reasons why they chose Romero instead of Tulowitzki.

Although Blue Jays management was aware of the wide talent pool in the 2005 draft, I highly doubt that Tulowitzki was even on their radar.

If you take a look at the 2005 Blue Jays roster, they already had a young franchise player at shortstop in Aaron Hill. But interestingly enough, Hill was actually moved to the second base position the following season after the Blue Jays traded Orlando Hudson.

Barring that Hill didn't work out at shortstop, the Blue Jays contingency plan was to use Russ Adams as a future starting middle infielder.

Who's to say that even if the Blue Jays did draft Tulowitzki that he would put together similar numbers playing at home in the Rogers Centre?

Being at home in Colorado where fly balls sail for home runs probably helped contribute to Tulowitzki's numbers in 2007. Put Troy in a Blue Jays uniform and have him play 80 or so games inside the concrete cavern in Toronto and the numbers might not even be close.

Obviously the Blue Jays scouts saw something they liked in Romero, so that is why they chose him as the number six player in the 2005 MLB Draft. His success with the Cal State Fullerton Titans was instrumental in helping them win the 2005 College World Series and the Blue Jays took notice of this and signed him accordingly.

While Romero's path to the major leagues hasn't been as rapid or as glamorous as Tulowitzki's, that doesn't mean it was the wrong choice to draft Romero.

Although it's taken a few more years for Romero to settle in at the major league level, it has certainly been worth the wait.