Alabama Crimson Tide Football

Re-Evaluating Crimson Tide's 2011 Recruiting Class

Christopher WalshCollege Football National ColumnistJune 16, 2014

Re-Evaluating Crimson Tide's 2011 Recruiting Class

1 of 8

    Safety Vinnie Sunseri, shown celebrating the first of his two national championships, turned out to be the surprise of Alabama's 2011 signing class.
    Safety Vinnie Sunseri, shown celebrating the first of his two national championships, turned out to be the surprise of Alabama's 2011 signing class.Dave Martin/Associated Press

    When the University of Alabama football program celebrated national signing day in 2011, safety Vinnie Sunseri enjoyed seeing it from both sides for once, as he had already enrolled.

    His joy was obvious. Sunseri's dad was part of Nick Saban's coaching staff, and everything had fallen just right so that the father and son could be together with the same team.

    "Growing up I didn't get to see him too often because he was always out recruiting, always talking to other kids and stuff and I grew up envious of that," Sunseri told reporters that day. "Actually being able to be with him 24/7 is something that I'll remember the rest of my life. He is my hero."

    While 2011 will always be remembered for the Crimson Tide winning the national championship after the devastating April tornadoes that went through the state, including Tuscaloosa, Alabama first won another recruiting title.

    Even before offensive lineman Cyrus Kouandjio flipped from Auburn (three after signing day), Alabama was No. 1, according to 247Sports and Rivals, while ESPN and Scout gave the nod to Florida State.

    "Recruiting is a big part of football," linebacker Trey DePriest said after enrolling early as well. "It makes your program what it is.

    "We have a great class. I can't wait until they all get here in the fall."

    With Kouandjio's addition, Alabama signed three 5-star recruits and 15 4-star recruits in 2011. Those who were incoming freshmen would now be seniors (juniors if redshirted), but five players from the class are already in the National Football League, including two who were junior college transfers.

    The two things in particular that coaches coveted were leadership and more athletic defensive linemen, which on paper the Crimson Tide appeared to add.

    "I think we have a lot of good players in this class. I think Trey (DePriest) and Vinnie (Sunseri) both, and maybe because they've been here so they were involved on a couple of recruiting weekends, you're talking about guys who are everything you could wish for if your children grew up to be like them," head coach Nick Saban said during his signing day press conference. "They have a lot of ability, they are hard workers, they are very committed, but they're very personable and caring for other people and can put somebody else ahead of themselves in terms of what they're doing and what their commitment is. Those two guys have been very impressive to me as well."

    He added about the defensive line: "Even though we had some good players last year and I was pleased with the progress our defense made throughout the course of the year, so I'm not in any way trying to be critical, we weren't quite as athletic, we didn't have as many good pass-rushers."

    Here's a look back at the Class of 2011. Rankings are the composite listings by 247Sports, nationally, position and by state. Positions are where the player was initially recruited:

Quarterbacks

2 of 8

    Quarterback Phillip Ely's career never really got going with the Crimson Tide, and he transferred to Toledo.
    Quarterback Phillip Ely's career never really got going with the Crimson Tide, and he transferred to Toledo.USA TODAY Sports

    Who signed?

    Pro-style quarterback Phillip Ely (3-star, No. 589 nationally, No. 17 position, No. 85 Florida).

     

    Re-evaluation: After redshirting, Ely played in six games in 2012, completing 3 of 4 passes for 42 yards and one touchdown in mop-up duty. With six scholarship quarterbacks and walk-on Luke Del Rio on the roster in 2013, he transferred to Toledo.

     

    Grade: C

Running Backs

3 of 8

    Dee Hart's determination was never in doubt with the Crimson Tide.
    Dee Hart's determination was never in doubt with the Crimson Tide.Kevin C. Cox/Getty Images

    Who signed?

    All-purpose running back Dee Hart (4-star, No. 38 nationally, No. 3 position, No. 12 Florida).

     

    Re-evaluation

    Hart's Crimson Tide career was sadly set back by two ACL injuries that required season-ending surgeries. He had 43 carries for 166 yards and was an outstanding special teams player but left the team after last season. In February, he was arrested for possession of marijuana and giving police false information.

     

    Grade: C+

Wide Receivers/Tight Ends

4 of 8

    Marvin Shinn never seemed to grasp how good he really was at Alabama and transferred.
    Marvin Shinn never seemed to grasp how good he really was at Alabama and transferred.USA TODAY Sports

    Who signed?

    Wide receiver Marvin Shinn (4-star, No. 62 nationally, No. 8 position. No. 1 Alabama); WR Bradley Sylve (4-star, No. 106, No. 5, No 6 Louisiana); WR Danny Woodson (4-star, No. 176, No. 28, No. 6 Alabama); Tight end Malcolm Faciane (4-star, No. 190, No. 10, No. 5 Mississippi); WR Duron Carter (3-star, No. 25 junior college, No. 5, No. 7 Kansas); WR Ronald Carswell (3-star, NA, No. 179, No. 100 Georgia).

     

    Re-evaluation

    No one panned out at a wide receiver, with Sylve the lone holdover at cornerback, where he's competing to start. Shinn and Woodson transferred to South Alabama. Carswell transferred to West Virginia and was kicked off the team last year. Carter never played a down for Alabama but is enjoying a successful CFL career with the Montreal Alouettes. Faciane has played sparingly, but so far, his only headline was for serving a 30-day suspension for violation of team rules last year.

     

    Grade: D+

Offensive Line

5 of 8

    When it came to Cyrus Kouandjio, it was more an issue of when he would take over at left tackle, not if.
    When it came to Cyrus Kouandjio, it was more an issue of when he would take over at left tackle, not if.USA TODAY Sports

    Who signed?

    Tackle Cyrus Kouandjio (5-star, No. 2 nationally, No. 1 position, No. 1 Maryland); Center Ryan Kelly (4-star, No. 237, No. 2, No. 12 Ohio); T Aaron Douglas (4-star, No. 12 junior college, No. 1, No. 2 Arizona); Guard Isaac Luatua (3-star, No. 391, No. 17, No. 40 California).

     

    Re-evaluation

    After sustaining a season-ending knee injury as a freshman, Kouandjio started at left tackle for two years and after leaving early was a second-round draft pick by Buffalo. Kelly won the starting job at center last year. Douglas tragically died in 2011. Size has been an issue for Luatua, as most of Alabama's other guards are big enough to play tackle.

     

    Grade: B

Defensive Line

6 of 8

    Alabama  was hopeful that Jeoffrey Pagan would make a big impact when he signed with the Crimson Tide in 2011.
    Alabama was hopeful that Jeoffrey Pagan would make a big impact when he signed with the Crimson Tide in 2011.Kevin C. Cox/Getty Images

    Who signed?

    Strong defensive end Xzavier Dickson (4-star, No. 34 nationally, No. 4 position, No. 5 Georgia); SDE Jeoffrey Pagan (4-star, No. 68, No. 6, No. 2 North Carolina); Defensive tackle Jesse Williams (4-star, No. 3 junior college, No. 2, No. 1 Arizona); Weakside defensive end D.J. Pettway (4-star, No. 206, No. 9, No. 38 Florida); DT LaMichael Fanning (4-star, No. 213, No. 19, No. 15 Georgia); DT Quinton Dial (4-star, No. 13 junior college, No. 6, No. 2 Mississippi). 

     

    Re-evaluation:

    Pagan left Alabama early and was recently drafted by the Houston Texans. Williams, a two-year starter on the line, is now with the Seattle Seahawks while Dial is with the San Francisco 49ers. Pettway was kicked out of school last year but has worked his way back. Dickson has played in 25 games, with six starts, but as a linebacker. Fanning, who was a bit of a recruiting gamble with tremendous upside, transferred to Jacksonville State last year.

     

    Grade: A-

Linebackers

7 of 8

    Inside linebacker Trey DePriest is entering his third season as an Alabama starter.
    Inside linebacker Trey DePriest is entering his third season as an Alabama starter.Kevin C. Cox/Getty Images

    Who signed?

    Interior linebacker Trey DePriest (5-star, No. 29 nationally, No. 3 position, No. 1 Ohio); Outside linebacker Brent Calloway (4-star, No. 74, No. 4, No. 3 Alabama); ILB Vinnie Sunseri (3-star, No. 630, No. 32, No. 20 Alabama).

     

    Re-evaluation

    Sunseri defied the odds by becoming a starting safety and then again after a season-ending knee injury when he left school a year early and was drafted by the New Orleans Saints. DePriest has played in 40 games with 26 starts and is expected to be the leader and signal-caller for this year's defense. Calloway bounced around between running back, tight end and linebacker only to be kicked off the team last year. He headed to Arizona Western College to try and resurrect his career but left the program before the end of last season.

     

    Grade: B+

Defensive Backs

8 of 8

    Safety Ha Ha Clinton-Dix was initially thought to be Alabama's best addition in the Class of 2011 and lived up to the billing.
    Safety Ha Ha Clinton-Dix was initially thought to be Alabama's best addition in the Class of 2011 and lived up to the billing.Craig Ruttle/Associated Press/Associated Press

    Who signed?

    Safety Ha Ha Clinton-Dix (5-star, No. 7 nationally, No. 2 position, No. 2 Florida); Athlete Jabriel Washington (4-star, No. 285, No. 15, No. 3 Tennessee); Cornerback Christion Jones (3-star, No. 365, No. 31, No. 10 Alabama).

     

    Re-evaluation

    Even with a two-game suspension, Clinton-Dix was arguably the best free safety in college football last season and was subsequently selected in the first round of the draft by Green Bay. Jones moved to wide receiver, where he became the starter in the slot, and on special teams had three returns for touchdowns last season. This will be an important fall camp for Washington at safety.

     

    Grade: A-

     

    Christopher Walsh is the lead Alabama football writer for Bleacher Report. All quotes and information were obtained firsthand unless otherwise noted. 

    Follow @CrimsonWalsh

Where can I comment?

Stay on your game

Latest news, insights, and forecasts on your teams across leagues.

Choose Teams
Get it on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

Real-time news for your teams right on your mobile device.

Download
Copyright © 2017 Bleacher Report, Inc. Turner Broadcasting System, Inc. All Rights Reserved. BleacherReport.com is part of Bleacher Report – Turner Sports Network, part of the Turner Sports and Entertainment Network. Certain photos copyright © 2017 Getty Images. Any commercial use or distribution without the express written consent of Getty Images is strictly prohibited. AdChoices