Baseball Draft 2014: Table of Day 1 Results and Grades for Major League Teams

Use your ← → (arrow) keys to browse more stories
Baseball Draft 2014: Table of Day 1 Results and Grades for Major League Teams
Phil Sears/Associated Press
The Blue Jays were one team to receive good value in Max Pentecost.

Day 1 of the 2014 MLB draft saw 74 prospective big-leaguers taken, leaving teams with plenty of upside and intrigue. With compensation and competitive-balance rounds thrown in, many organizations have infused their farm systems with some of the most exciting young talent in the game.

While not everyone selected on Thursday night will turn into a star, a few teams may have secured important building blocks to shape the next era of their team. The baseball draft is more difficult to predict than any other sport, so for now these grades and evaluations are based strictly on value.

With that, let's take a look at how each team fared through the first two rounds while also looking at a few of the most noteworthy teams from Day 1's action.

Round 1 Picks and Grades
Pick Team Player Position School Grade
1 Houston Astros Brady Aiken LHP Cathedral Catholic HS A
2 Miami Marlins Tyler Kolek RHP Shepherd HS B+
3 Chicago White Sox Carlos Rodon LHP N.C. State A
4 Chicago Cubs Kyle Schwarber C Indiana B
5 Minnesota Twins Nick Gordon SS Olympia HS B+
6 Seattle Mariners Alex Jackson C/OF Rancho Bernardo HS A
7 Philadelphia Phillies Aaron Nola RHP LSU A
8 Colorado Rockies Kyle Freeland LHP Evansville A-
9 Toronto Blue Jays Jeff Hoffman RHP East Carolina A-
10 New York Mets Michael Conforto OF Oregon State A
11 Toronto Blue Jays Max Pentecost C Kennesaw State A-
12 Milwaukee Brewers Kodi Medeiros LHP Waiakea HS B
13 San Diego Padres Trea Turner SS N.C. State B+
14 San Francisco Giants Tyler Beede RHP Vanderbilt B
15 Los Angeles Angels Sean Newcomb LHP Hartford B+
16 Arizona Diamondbacks Touki Toussaint RHP Coral Springs Christian Academy A-
17 Kansas City Royals Brandon Finnegan LHP TCU B+
18 Washington Nationals Erick Fedde RHP UNLV B
19 Cincinnati Reds Nick Howard RHP Virginia A-
20 Tampa Bay Rays Casey Gillaspie 1B Wichita State A-
21 Cleveland Indians Bradley Zimmer OF San Francisco A-
22 Los Angeles Dodgers Grant Holmes RHP Conway HS B+
23 Detroit Tigers Derek Hill OF Elk Grove HS A
24 Pittsburgh Pirates Cole Tucker SS Mountain Pointe HS B-
25 Oakland Athletics Matt Chapman 3B Cal State Fullerton B
26 Boston Red Sox Michael Chavis SS Sprayberry HS A-
27 St. Louis Cardinals Luke Weaver RHP Florida State B
28 Kansas City Royals Foster Griffin LHP The First Academy B
29 Cincinnati Reds Alex Blandino SS Stanford A
30 Texas Rangers Luis Ortiz RHP Sanger HS A-
31 Cleveland Indians Justus Sheffield LHP Tullahoma HS B
32 Atlanta Braves Braxton Davidson OF T.C. Roberson HS A
33 Boston Red Sox Michael Kopech RHP Pleasant HS B
34 St. Louis Cardinals Jack Flaherty RHP Harvard-Westlake HS B-
35 Colorado Rockies Forrest Wall 2B Orangewood Christian HS A
36 Miami Marlins Blake Anderson C West Lauderdale HS B+
37 Houston Astros Derek Fisher OF Virginia A
38 Cleveland Indians Mike Papi OF Virginia A-
39 Pittsburgh Pirates Connor Joe OF San Diego C+
40 Kansas City Royals Chase Vallot C St. Thomas More HS A-
41 Milwaukee Brewers Jacob Gatewood SS Clovis HS B+

Order via

Round 2 Picks and Grades
Pick Team Player Position School Grade
42 Houston Astros A.J. Reed 1B Kentucky A
43 Miami Marlins Justin Twine SS Falls City HS B-
44 Chicago White Sox Spencer Adams RHP White County HS A-
45 Chicago Cubs Jake Stinnett RHP Maryland A-
46 Minnesota Twins Nick Burdi RHP Louisville A-
47 Philadelphia Phillies Matt Imhof LHP Cal Poly-San Luis Obispo B
48 Colorado Rockies Ryan Castellani RHP Brophy Jesuit Prep School B+
49 Toronto Blue Jays Sean Reid-Foley RHP Sandalwood HS A
50 Milwaukee Brewers Monte Harrison OF Lee's Summit West HS B+
51 San Diego Padres Michael Gettys OF Gainesville HS A-
52 San Francisco Giants Aramis Garcia C Florida International B+
53 Los Angeles Angels Joe Gatto RHP St. Augustine Prep C+
54 Arizona Diamondbacks Cody Reed LHP Ardmore HS A-
55 New York Yankees Jacob Lindgren LHP Mississippi State B
56 Kansas City Royals Scott Blewett RHP Baker HS B-
57 Washington Nationals Andrew Suarez LHP Miami B
58 Cincinnati Reds Taylor Sparks 3B UC Irvine B-
59 Texas Rangers Tiquan Forbes SS Columbia HS A-
60 Tampa Bay Rays Cameron Varga RHP Cincinnati Hills Christian Academy B
61 Cleveland Indians Grant Hockin RHP Damien HS C+
62 Los Angeles Dodgers Alex Verdugo OF Sahuaruo HS B+
63 Detroit Tigers Spencer Turnbull RHP Alabama B
64 Pittsburgh Pirates Mitch Keller RHP Xavier HS A-
65 Oakland Athletics Daniel Gossett RHP Clemson B+
66 Atlanta Braves Garrett Fulenchek RHP Howe HS B+
67 Boston Red Sox Sam Travis 1B Indiana B+
68 St. Louis Cardinals Ronnie Williams RHP American Senior HS B+
69 Arizona Diamondbacks Marcus Wilson OF Junipero Serra HS B
70 Arizona Diamondbacks Isan Diaz SS Springfield Central HS B-
71 St. Louis Cardinals Andrew Morales RHP UC Irvine B-
72 Tampa Bay Rays Brent Honeywell RHP Walters State CC B-
73 Pittsburgh Pirates Trey Supak RHP La Grange HS B
74 Seattle Mariners Gareth Morgan OF Blyth Academy B

Order via

Houston Astros

Holding the top overall pick for the third consecutive season, the Astros added one of the highest-upside arms in recent years in prep school lefty Brady Aiken. It was not entirely surprising to see the Astros opt for Aiken, who many scouts see as one of the surest things in the draft, per ESPN's Jayson Stark:

Indeed, despite the shaky reputation that dogs high school prospects (especially arms), Aiken is far from the typical type of prospect. As ESPN's Tim Keown relays, amateur scouts are more comfortable with Aiken not only because of his makeup but because he has already been on the radar for several years:

'Teams have probably seen him 100 times,' said John Manuel, who has covered amateur baseball for Baseball America for 17 years. 'They've had national crosscheckers and area scouts and even international scouts on him. There's an extensive track record, more in line with a college player.'

Apart from the first overall pick, Houston also received excellent value with the next two picks, a pair of bats in Derek Fisher and A.J. Reed. Fisher, a prep school prospect, broke his hamate bone after a hot start to his season, but he returned to post a .281/.340/.415 slash line. Reed led all Division I hitters with 23 home runs while at Kentucky, and he could eventually join George Springer and Jonathan Singleton to form a powerful middle of the order in Houston.

Seattle Mariners

Alex Jackson falling to No. 6 was a dream scenario for the Mariners, who continue their perpetual search for power bats. Interestingly, Bud Selig announced the class' top prep bat as an outfielder rather than a catcher, a distinction that could move his ETA up a year or two if it sticks.

Regardless, while Seattle's farm system is chock-full of high-upside arms, the Mariners do not have much in the way of future power potential apart from Austin Wilson and D.J. Peterson. Therefore, according to the Seattle Times' Larry Stone, Mariners general manager Jack Zduriencik believes Jackson's right-handed upside is an invaluable commodity:

Yeah, you’ve noticed. It’s difficult. It really is. Especially a right-handed bat. We’ve talked about that a lot. We’re talking about it now. It’s funny, I remember years ago it was left-handed bats, trying to find a really good left-handed hitter. Now it just seems it’s the right-handed bat that’s at a premium.

Seattle's second-round pick is not as well-rounded or projectable a hitter as Jackson, but he offers even more power potential than the sixth overall pick, per Greg Johns of

Gareth Morgan has the profile to project as a right fielder at some point, so Jackson's versatility could come in handy if both picks work out. Morgan possesses one of the top power bats in the draft, so he represents excellent value in the competitive-balance stages of the second round.

Toronto Blue Jays

Arguably no team received better Day 1 value than the surprise AL East leaders, who continue the early summer's good vibes.

The Blue Jays' first selection, Jeff Hoffman, will need a year off due to Tommy John surgery. Using the ninth overall pick on such a prospect naturally carries risk, but as ESPN's Christopher Crawford opines (subscription required), Toronto may have received a top-four talent:

If Hoffman were healthy, he would have been a lock for the top four, as some compared him to a poor man's Adam Wainwright. Taking a pitcher who won't be able to throw for your organization for close to a year is a risk, but the Blue Jays have been known to take chances such as this, as seen in the fact that they didn't sign two of their top three first-round picks. 

Even if Hoffman does not pan out as expected, the Blue Jays backed up their top pick with two more high-upside prospects:

Max Pentecost is arguably the best pure catcher in this class, as his eye-popping .423/.483/.631 batting line carried Kennesaw State into the NCAA tournament. With above-average tools across the board, Pentecost has a good chance to develop into a major league regular at a scarce position.

At the beginning of the second round, the Jays received first-round talent in Sandalwood's Sean Reid-Foley. The tall righty was one of the most polished prep pitchers available, as his four-pitch arsenal and advanced feel suggest a high-floor prospect.

Hoffman and Reid-Foley could soon join Aaron Sanchez and Marcus Stroman to form a quartet of intriguing rotation arms.

Follow B/R on Facebook


Subscribe Now

By signing up for our newsletter, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.

Thanks for signing up.