NFL Draft Results 2014: Initial Round 1 Grades and Updated Selection Order

Scott Polacek@@ScottPolacekFeatured ColumnistMay 9, 2014

Only in the NFL could a night of the sport’s commissioner reading names from cue cards bring the type of excitement and drama that fans saw Thursday night. 

The first round of the NFL draft is officially in the books, and Jadeveon Clowney went No. 1 as expected, but it was Johnny Manziel’s slide that captured most of the headlines. The Cleveland Browns, after making approximately 455 trades, got him at No. 22, and the rest was history.

Here is a look at the early Round 1 grades for every single pick, and then we will dig into some detail on a few select choices:

2014 NFL Draft Round 1 Grades
1.TexansJadeveon ClowneyDE/OLBSouth CarolinaA: Draft's best player and will be beast with J.J. Watt
2.Rams (from WSH)Greg Robinson OTAuburnA-: Upside a bit higher than other tackles because of athleticism
3.JaguarsBlake BortlesQBUCFB-: Could have traded down and gotten QB later
4.Bills*Sammy WatkinsWRClemson A: Arguably draft's top playmaker, needed explosive option in passing game
5.RaidersKhalil Mack OLBBuffalo A+: Needed a pass-rusher and got the best one
6.FalconsJake MatthewsOTTexas A&M A: Perhaps best-suited player to come in and start from first day
7.BuccaneersMike Evans WRTexas A&M A: Now have one-two punch at wide receiver. Look out
8.Browns*Justin Gilbert CBOklahoma State B-: Such a deep corner draft, could have gotten comparable one later
9.Vikings*Anthony Barr OLBUCLA B: Not Mack or Clowney, but solid pick
10.LionsEric Ebron TENorth Carolina C: Just too many other needs to pick a TE here, although very talented
11.TitansTaylor Lewan OTMichigan C: Like Lions, had other needs that could have been addressed
12.GiantsOdell Beckham Jr.WRLSU B: Possibly fastest receiver in draft, solid pick
13.RamsAaron DonaldDTPittsburgh A: Good luck blocking this defensive line
14.BearsKyle Fuller CBVirginia Tech B+: Needed a corner, underrated versatility
15.SteelersRyan ShazierOLBOhio State B: Fastest linebacker in draft, only question is whether he can handle middle linebacker in NFL for 10-plus years
16.CowboysZack MartinOG/OTNotre Dame B-: Probably could have used help in the secondary here
17.RavensC.J. Mosley ILBAlabama B: Nothing flashy, all production
18.JetsCalvin Pryor FSLouisville A-: Needed help at the back end of the defense and got maybe best safety in draft
19.DolphinsJa'Wuan JamesOTTennessee B-: Were more talented tackles in this draft but fills a pressing need
20.Saints*Brandin Cooks WROregon State B+: Will put up serious numbers in that offense
21.PackersHa Ha Clinton-DixFSAlabama A: Packers need serious help in secondary, and he can start right away
22.Browns*Johnny Manziel QBTexas A&M A: How can you not love getting Johnny Manziel this late in the first round?
23.ChiefsDee Ford DE/OLBAuburn C: Had some other needs, doesn't make as much sense as others would have here
24.BengalsDarqueze Dennard CBMichigan State A: Great value pick this late in the draft
25.ChargersJason Verrett CBTCUB+: Don't get caught up in the height discussions, a true playmaker
26.Eagles* (from IND)Marcus Smith DE/OLBLouisville B-: Need a pass-rusher, but weren't there better ones available still?
27.Cardinals*Deone Bucannon SSWashington State B: Not a lot of name recognition but solid football player
28.PanthersKelvin Benjamin WRFlorida State B+: Needed a receiver in the worst possible way
29.PatriotsDominique Easley DTFlorida B-: Lots of upside but has to stay healthy
30.49ersJimmie Ward SSNorthern Illinois B-: Probably had more pressing needs than safety, but solid pick
31.BroncosBradley Roby CBOhio State B+: Immediate need and serious upside and speed
32.VikingsTeddy BridgewaterQBLouisvilleA-: Needed a quarterback and got a top-15 talent at the end of the first round. Great value
Grades are all personal opinion


WR Mike Evans, Tampa Bay Buccaneers 

Josh McCown enjoyed throwing to two elite targets in Chicago last year, and David Haugh of the Chicago Tribune pointed out that he may just get that privilege again in Tampa Bay after the Buccaneers selected Mike Evans to pair with Vincent Jackson:

Evans may not have the speed of a Sammy Watkins, but there is so much value in today’s NFL for someone who can go up and grab the ball at its highest point and outmuscle defenders.

Look for the Buccaneers passing attack to be much better next season. 

They ranked an abysmal 32nd in the league in average passing yards per game, and with Evans now in the fold, they have two potential premier playmakers on the outside. All McCown will need to do is avoid costly turnovers, and the Tampa offense will be much more formidable immediately.

It will also open up the running game, as defenses will not be able to load the box with so much talent on the outside.


CB Kyle Fuller, Chicago Bears

The Chicago Bears have Charles Tillman in tow, but he is past his prime and missed most of last season because of injury.

They needed more depth at the corner position, and that is exactly what they got with Kyle Fuller. His versatility and athleticism allow him to guard virtually any type of receiver, from the speedy slot guys to the physical outside flankers. In addition, he is an elite special teams player, which is something the Bears put a lot of pride into every year.

General manager Phil Emery discussed Fuller, via the team’s official Twitter page:

As Emery said, Fuller could play right away, be it in on special teams or as an extra corner. There are so many elite wide receivers in the NFC North that the Bears will need him.


CB Darqueze Dennard, Cincinnati Bengals

As long as we are talking cornerbacks, the Cincinnati Bengals landed arguably the best press cornerback in the draft in Darqueze Dennard from Michigan State.

The AFC North features Josh Gordon, among other wide receivers, and the Bengals have serious concerns in the age and health departments when it comes to cornerbacks. Dennard could slide right in alongside Leon Hall and make it an All-Big Ten starting lineup at the position. 

He isn’t the fastest corner in the draft, but he is probably the most physical one. That, along with his ball-hawking skills, will lead to a successful NFL career in the Queen City.


Updated Round 2 Selection Order

Now it is time to look ahead to Round 2. Notable prospects like Derek Carr and Carlos Hyde are still on the board and sure to hear their names picked on Friday. Here is a look at the updated selection order for the entire second round:

2014 NFL Draft Selection Order, Round 2
1Houston Texans
2Washington Redskins
3Cleveland Browns
4Oakland Raiders
5Atlanta Falcons
6Tampa Bay Buccaneers
7Jacksonville Jaguars
8Seattle Seahawks
9Buffalo Bills
10Tennessee Titans
11New York Giants
12St. Louis Rams
13Detroit Lions
14Pittsburgh Steelers
15Dallas Cowboys
16Baltimore Ravens
17New York Jets
18Miami Dolphins
19Chicago Bears
20Arizona Cardinals
21Green Bay Packers
22Philadelphia Eagles
23Cincinnati Bengals
24San Francisco 49ers
25San Diego Chargers
26New Orleans Saints
27Indianapolis Colts
28Carolina Panthers
29San Francisco 49ers
30New England Patriots
31Denver Broncos
32Seattle Seahawks

Make sure to tune in Friday.


Follow me on Twitter:


    Source: NFL Is 'F--king Terrified' of Trump

    NFL logo

    Source: NFL Is 'F--king Terrified' of Trump

    Mike Freeman
    via Bleacher Report

    NFL Decides on Anthem Rules

    NFL logo

    NFL Decides on Anthem Rules

    Mike Chiari
    via Bleacher Report

    49ers LB Foster DV Charges Dropped, Cleared to Return

    NFL logo

    49ers LB Foster DV Charges Dropped, Cleared to Return

    Joseph Zucker
    via Bleacher Report

    Long Rips New Anthem Rules: 'This Is Not Patriotism'

    NFL logo

    Long Rips New Anthem Rules: 'This Is Not Patriotism'

    Rob Goldberg
    via Bleacher Report