The wild and chaotic nature of Extreme Rules has made for one of the more entertaining and anticipated events of the year. In recent years, it has proceeded WrestleMania and featured some outstanding rematches of the show's top bouts.
While the show is almost always one of the more enjoyable on the event calendar, there have been a few editions of Extreme Rules that failed to live up to their expectations. That is not to say they were bad. There have been some outstanding matches in the event's history that will appear on this list.
Unfortunately, these shows as a whole failed to make an impression, and as a result, they significantly pale in comparison to past and future events.
In hopes that the May 4 Extreme Rules show headlined by The Shield vs. Evolution does not wind up on a revised version of this list in the future, here is a look back at the worst cards in the relatively short history of the fan-favorite event.