Justin Gilbert NFL Draft 2014: Scouting Report Breakdown for Cleveland Browns CB

Ian Wharton@NFLFilmStudyContributor IMay 5, 2014

After intercepting the ball from Missouri quarterback James Franklin, Oklahoma State cornerback Justin Gilbert (4) gets past Missouri running back Henry Josey (20) during the first half of the Cotton Bowl NCAA college football game on Friday, Jan. 3, 2014, in Arlington, Texas. (AP Photo/Brandon Wade)
Brandon Wade

Justin Gilbert, CB, Oklahoma State (HT: 6’0⅛”; WT: 202 lbs)

Cleveland Browns (Browns trade ninth and 145th picks to Vikings for eighth pick)

First Round: Eighth Pick 

NFL Comparison: Johnathan Joseph, CB, Houston Texans 



Combine Weigh-In
Combine Results
40-yard dash10-yd splitVertBroad3-ConeShuttle


Overall Strengths

+ Excellent size and arm length force difficult throws

+ Great linear speed with translatable skills for the position

+ Excels in man coverage, rarely needing safety help

+ Played his best against top competition

+ Excellent returner throughout his career

+ Experience playing boundary corner will help him contribute immediately 


Overall Weaknesses

- Heavy feet cause him to waste movement on comeback and curl routes

- Doesn’t give any effort in run support

- Performs poorly in zone coverage due to instincts and recognition skills



Gilbert is a good athlete with impressive top-end speed, acceleration and length. He has experience returning punts and kickoffs, showing great vision with the ball in his hands. He displays an impressive vertical jump when making plays on the ball in the air.

Ian Wharton



Gilbert has only one minor incident on his resume, which occurred when he was ejected for throwing a punch at a West Virginia player in 2013. Gilbert spent his first few seasons in and out of the coaches’ doghouse but matured as a junior and senior to earn consistent playing time.


At Oklahoma State, Gilbert lined up at both boundary cornerback positions almost evenly. He played mostly off-man coverage (also called catch-man), but did line up directly over his assignment as well. He’s at his most comfortable playing off-man, where he was able to react quickly to underneath routes and read the quarterback’s eyes.

His click-and-close ability in press man coverage was exploited against more agile opponents such as Oklahoma’s Jalen Saunders.

Gilbert has great leaping ability
Gilbert has great leaping abilityIan Wharton


Ball Skills

Ian Wharton

Gilbert reads and reacts quickly to route combinations, leading to opportunities for interceptions. His ability to locate the ball in midair is very good, and he has the necessary athleticism to contest most passes. His vertical leaping ability allows him to contest the catch at its highest point, a skill that translates well to the NFL. He was second in the NCAA with seven interceptions in 2013.


Against the Run/Tackling 

Gilbert is an effective tackler in open space, but he is passive in attacking the line of scrimmage to make a play. Many of his tackles come well downfield because he does not work hard to shed blocks or waits until the ball-carrier reaches him. He seems to prefer to let his teammates make the tackle instead of finishing the play himself.


Man Coverage 

Between Gilbert’s solid change-of-direction skills and excellent recovery speed, he has potential to become a great man-coverage cornerback. He needs to improve his initial punch while playing press, because he does not currently win at the line of scrimmage. When he doesn’t disrupt the receiver at the line of scrimmage, he is susceptible to comeback routes because he has heavy feet, causing him to waste steps in his trigger down.  


Zone Coverage

An inexperienced zone player, Gilbert struggles to identify where receivers are and tends to wander. He doesn’t anticipate where the ball is going, so he’s essentially playing without direction. If he’s assigned to covering the sideline, which Cover 3 dictates, he can excel because of his ability to locate the ball and run with receivers.



Gilbert is at his best in off-man coverage, where his backpedal is clean and efficient. He has a tendency to open his hips early while in press coverage, causing him to waste movement in his throttle down and leaving him susceptible to quick cut routes. He is rarely burned on routes due to his excellent speed and good closing burst. His ability to always be around the ball shows that he has room to improve once his technique is refined.

Gilbert's heavy feet cost him positioning
Gilbert's heavy feet cost him positioningIan Wharton


Future Role/Scheme Versatility 

Gilbert enters the NFL with little versatility, but he excels in off-man coverage and has considerable upside in press coverage due to his strength and arm length. Since there is great value in those abilities, Gilbert should be able to play early in his career as a boundary cornerback and be a contributor. He will also be an impact return man, as he has great vision and speed to make big plays happen.



    Browns Should Sign Pacman for CB Depth

    Cleveland Browns logo
    Cleveland Browns

    Browns Should Sign Pacman for CB Depth

    Chris Roling
    via Bleacher Report

    Report: Raiders Keeping Marshawn

    NFL logo

    Report: Raiders Keeping Marshawn

    Kyle Newport
    via Bleacher Report

    Report: Bucs, Vinny Curry Agree to 3-Yr/$27M Deal

    NFL logo

    Report: Bucs, Vinny Curry Agree to 3-Yr/$27M Deal

    Rob Goldberg
    via Bleacher Report

    Report: OBJ Misidentified in Club Fight Video

    NFL logo

    Report: OBJ Misidentified in Club Fight Video

    Timothy Rapp
    via Bleacher Report