Everton vs. Manchester United: Live Player Ratings for Toffees and Red Devils

Use your ← → (arrow) keys to browse more stories
Everton vs. Manchester United: Live Player Ratings for Toffees and Red Devils
Michael Regan/Getty Images

A hectic Sunday of Premier League football rounds off with Everton hosting Manchester United in the race for fourth place.

The Toffees must win all their remaining games if they want to steal the last Champions League berth from under Arsenal's noses, while the Red Devils are simply looking to restore some pride in a poor season.

The game represents David Moyes' return to Goodison Park after ending a decade-long tenure there in favour of the reigning champions. Expect fireworks.

Join us for live player ratings—updated at both half-time and full-time!—to see if you agree with our impressions.

Everton XI

Everton Player Ratings
Player Position H/T Rating F/T Rating
Howard GK 7 7
Coleman RB 8 8
Stones CB 8 8
Distin CB 7 7
Baines LB 7 7
McCarthy DM 7 7
Barry DM 6 6
Barkley LW 6 6
Mirallas RW 7 7
Naismith AMC 7 8
Lukaku ST 7 7
Alcaraz CB N/A 7
Osman LW N/A 7


Howard: A quiet day for the American international on the whole, but punched clear when needed.

Coleman: Bombed forward and caused Buttner fits. Unstoppable.

Stones: Showed good positional awareness and recovery ability.

Distin: Great aggression, disrupted play for United's No. 10s.

Baines: Converted the penalty, but didn't too much else offensively.

McCarthy: Got stuck in and made life difficult for United at all times.

Barry: Solid and dependable in midfield.

Lukaku: A handful for Man Utd's defence, moved nicely and winning headers.

Barkley: Showed flashes, but swiped at his chances in truth. Out of position.

Mirallas: Had a poor game offensive and defensively...until he slammed a shot home from a tight angle.

Naismith: Took up great positions and played off Lukaku brilliantly.

United XI

Man Utd Player Ratings
Player Position H/T Rating F/T Rating
De Gea GK 6 6
Jones RB 4 4
Smalling CB 6 5
Evans CB 6 7
Buttner LB 5 4
Carrick DM 6 5
Fletcher DM 6 5
Nani RW 5 4
Mata AMC 6 6
Kagawa LW 5 4
Rooney ST 5 3
Valencia RB N/A 6
Hernandez FWD N/A 6
Welbeck ST N/A


De Gea: Did very little, then picked the ball out of his net twice after great Everton moves.

Jones: Played the part of goalkeeper, saving Lukaku's shot with his arm. Messed up the line for Everton's second.

Smalling: Made good inroads from right-back, but no end-product whatsoever.

Evans: Didn't put a foot wrong; One of few United players to hold their heads high.

Buttner: Got destroyed by Coleman early on but bucked up a little later. Bad decision-making in the final third.

Carrick: Recycled possession well but did very little from a combative, impactful sense.

Fletcher: Sent Rooney through with a great through-ball early on but was largely ineffectual.

Nani: Positionally undisciplined and visibly frustrated with his teammates. Substituted early.

Mata: Moved the ball quickly and took up strong positions only to be ignored. Let down by teammates.

Kagawa: Ineffectual on the left; couldn't outmuscle a wasp.

Rooney: Poor touch up front, slow in linkup. An overall poor showing.

Follow B/R on Facebook

Premier League

Subscribe Now

By signing up for our newsletter, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.

Thanks for signing up.