Scouting Report: Mateusz Klich: Manchester United's Plan B to William Carvalho?

Allan JiangTransfers CorrespondentMarch 24, 2014

ZWOLLE, NETHERLANDS - DECEMBER 13:  Mateusz Klich of Zwolle in action during the Eredivisie match between PEC Zwolle and SC Heerenveen held at IJsseldelta Stadion on December 13, 2013 in Zwolle, Netherlands.  (Photo by Dean Mouhtaropoulos/Getty Images)
Dean Mouhtaropoulos/Getty Images

Manchester United have secured an agreement with Sporting Lisbon to sign 21-year-old Portuguese international William Carvalho for £37 million, per Steve Bates at the Mirror, but could PEC Zwolle central midfielder Mateusz Klich be plan B if William's transfer to United falls through?

To cover that scenario, here is a scouting report on Klich, a 23-year-old Polish international. 


Why William?

Full disclosure: With the exception of Benfica and Porto, Portuguese football is a blind spot in my scouting schedule this season. 

While it is fine to do a slide on William in a slideshow, it is unsuitable for me to do a scouting report on him right now since I have not watched enough of Sporting

So this section will be focusing on why William's transfer to United might go from seemingly a done deal to a transfer which collapses.

If you are a United supporter, you might be wondering: "Why William?"

According to Portuguese football expert Tom Kundert, William has "perfect positioning," is a big-game player and has been "outstanding over recent months" for Sporting, per

Bleacher Report world football tactics lead writer Sam Tighe said William "is one of the finest young defensive midfielders emerging in the game," per Bleacher Report

William's move to United makes sense from Sporting's point of view because the Portuguese club have a noted history of selling prospects to Premier League teams. 

  • Nani, 20, to Manchester United for £17.3 million in 2007, per Ken Ferris and Carlos Pontes at Reuters.
  • Cristiano Ronaldo, 18, to Manchester United for £12.24 million in 2003, per BBC Sport.
  • Hugo Viana, 19, to Newcastle United for £8.5 million in 2002, per BBC Sport.
  • Tiago Ilori, 20, to Liverpool for £7 million in 2013, per Andy Hunter at the Guardian.
  • Luis Boa Morte, 19, to Arsenal for £1.75 million in 1997, per BBC Sport.

The obstacle to United officially announcing William's signing could be his £37 million transfer valuation.

Former United manager Sir Alex Ferguson baulked at Sao Paulo's £37.7 [€45] million asking price for right forward Lucas Moura in 2012. 

"I find it quite amazing that a club can pay €45 million for a 19-year-old boy," Ferguson said, per ESPN FC. "When somebody's paying €45 million for a 19-year-old boy you have to say the game's gone mad."

If United management listened to Ferguson in appointing David Moyes as manager, Ferguson could be the dissenting voice in the boardroom, which sinks William's transfer to United. 

Going by that hypothetical situation, here is why United executive vice-chairman Ed Woodward must consider signing Klich of PEC Zwolle. 



Klich plays, moves and thinks like a central attacking midfielder.

However, he has been operating from a deeper role, predominantly in a central midfield position in manager Ron Jans' 4-3-3.


Jans' tough-loving helped Liverpool deep-lying forward Luis Suarez transition into European football at Groningen, per Duncan White at the Telegraph.

You would imagine Jans has taken the same approach to coaching Klich, who is being pushed to be more effective without possession.

This was on show when Klich intercepted six passes in a 1-1 draw against Ajax, the current Eredivisie league leaders. 


Klich has won back the ball 97 times (60 tackles and 37 interceptions) in 26 Eredivisie games, so his defending is headed in the right direction. 

But what makes him special is his playmaking. 

Klich's command of Zwolle's attack forecasts the possibility of him turning into a world-class midfielder. 

In Zwolle's 6-1 win over ADO Den Haag, Klich was poised in possession, showed extraordinary vision and passed flamboyantly. 

He anticipated Zwolle central midfielder Mustafa Saymak beating Den Haag's offside trap, who took Klich's flighted long pass in stride. 

Source: PEC Zwolle TV/

Around 16 minutes later, Saymak was the beneficiary of a lobbed through ball from Klich.

Source: PEC Zwolle TV/

Zwolle centre-forward Fred Benson sprinted on to Klich's remarkable incisive pass deep inside his own defensive half. 

Source: PEC Zwolle TV/

When advancing deep into Den Haag's defensive half, Klich made a No. 10-type pass to Benson. 

Source: PEC Zwolle TV/

NEC Nijmegen' defence was caught off-guard by Klich's audacious trivela pass to Zwolle centre-forward Guyon Fernandez.

Source: PEC Zwolle TV/

Against a stronger team in Vitesse, currently fourth (while Den Haag are 13th and NEC are 17th), Klich replicated his passing prowess with an instep pass to Zwolle impact sub Giovanni Gravenbeek and a key pass (pass that leads to a shot) to Fernandez. 

Source: PEC Zwolle TV/

Source: PEC Zwolle TV/

Klich completes 82.2 percent of his passes, so there is control in his game and he can mimic Michael Carrick in being a reliable passing outlet having registered a 90 pass-completion percentage four times in league play this season, per




The Eredivisie is an end-to-end, dynamic and offense-driven league catered to creative and technically skilled players such as Klich, so you expect him to flourish. 

Whether or not he can bring his A-game from the Eredivisie to the Premier League remains to be seen. 

Klich was not deemed good enough for Wolfsburg under Felix Magath, who has proven in the past he has time for diamonds in the rough, provided that they work hard and produce. 

Edin Dzeko (Teplice), Grafite (Le Mans) and Zvjezdan Misimovic (Nurnberg) were signed from modest clubs and formed the core of Magath's 2008-09 Bundesliga-winning Wolfsburg team.

Another concern is Klich being a flat-track bully because minus a goal against Feyenoord, he has scored twice and accumulated seven assists against teams that are ranked 10th or lower in the Eredivisie.



Bottom Line

Klich is an abnormally talented passer, who would be a smart plan B if United do not end up sealing the deal for William, a la the Ander Herrera transfer fiasco in the last summer transfer window, per Sid Lowe at the Guardian



Statistics via WhoScored


    Toronto FC Deal with Full Range of Emotions After CCL Final Heartbreak

    World Football logo
    World Football

    Toronto FC Deal with Full Range of Emotions After CCL Final Heartbreak

    Bayern Players Furious with Loss to 'Weak' Madrid

    World Football logo
    World Football

    Bayern Players Furious with Loss to 'Weak' Madrid

    Maja Hitij
    via Goal

    Man Utd's New Third Kit Leaked 🔥

    Manchester United logo
    Manchester United

    Man Utd's New Third Kit Leaked 🔥

    Footy Headlines
    via Footy Headlines

    Robben, Martinez and Boateng Injured in Defeat

    World Football logo
    World Football

    Robben, Martinez and Boateng Injured in Defeat

    Bavarian Football Works
    via Bavarian Football Works