Villanova vs. Seton Hall: Score, Recap and Analysis

R. Cory SmithSenior Writer IMarch 13, 2014

USA Today

Villanova came into the Big East tournament with hopes of clinching a No. 1 seed in the 2014 NCAA tournament and taking the conference crown. After a cold-blooded shot from Sterling Gibbs of Seton Hall in the quarterfinals, the Wildcats will come away with neither as the Pirates downed the No. 1 seed, 64-63, in Madison Square Garden on Thursday.

ESPN College Basketball provides a look at the final score from the Big East tournament:

The Wildcats led 63-62 with just seconds remaining in the second half. That was when Gibbs went into full-blown hero mode for Seton Hall to pull off the stunning upset.

Chris Littman of provides a look at the huge shot from Gibbs on Vine:

The win isn't the first upset of the tournament after DePaul defeated Georgetown during the opening round, but it was certainly the biggest.  

Nova came in with just two losses in Big East play and hadn't lost a game since Feb. 16 against Creighton. In the two games played during the regular season between the two teams, Villanova won by an average of 16.5 points.

The loss not only knocks the Wildcats out of the Big East tournament, but it also ruins any hopes of taking a No. 1 overall seed in March Madness.

Gary Parrish of CBS talked about just that following the game:

Jay Williams of ESPN also had a knee-jerk reaction to the outcome:

To say that Gibbs was an unlikely hero is a bit of an understatement. The former Texas point guard is in his first season with the Pirates after sitting out last season.

Gibbs was coming off the bench during the game and was one of only eight players to tally minutes for Seton Hall. Though he only finished 4-of-10 with 10 points and six assists, he made one of the most memorable shots in recent memory for the Pirates.

The sophomore transfer spoke about the victory and his team's confidence following the win, per Adam Zagoria of

Villanova head coach Jay Wright also chimed in about his disappointment with the loss, according to Zagoria:

While the loss means the Wildcats won't be a No. 1 seed in the NCAA tournament, they are still a contender when the competition officially gets underway.

Regardless of whether they are ultimately a No. 2 or 3 seed, Wright will have his team ready to play. But after not being able to shut down a team in the doldrums of a depleted Big East conference (after the 2012-13 season, the conference went from 15 teams to 10 due to realignment), it's unlikely that they will be advancing very far in the NCAA field either.


What's Next?

Mar 13, 2014; New York, NY, USA; Seton Hall Pirates guard Sterling Gibbs (4) controls the ball against Villanova Wildcats forward JayVaughn Pinkston (22) during the second half of a game in the second round of the Big East college basketball tournament at
Brad Penner-USA TODAY Sports

The step-back jumper thrusts Seton Hall into the semifinals of the Big East tournament for the first time since 2001.

Following the win, Seton Hall will now have to wait to find out who it will play in the semifinals. Providence and St. John's, two programs with NCAA tournament hopes of their own, are playing each other for the right to take on the suddenly surging Seton Hall.

With the huge win in hand and the swagger that Gibbs referred to during his press conference, the Pirates might have a chance to continue shocking the country all the way into the NCAA tournament.


Follow R. Cory Smith on Twitter: