Breaking Down San Francisco Giants' Key Position Battles

Zachary D. Rymer@zachrymerMLB Lead WriterMarch 6, 2014

Some managers will have to make some really tough decisions with really important roster spots this spring. 'Tis a beast, and this is its nature.

San Francisco Giants skipper Bruce Bochy, however, shouldn't be one of them. The Giants may have entered camp with three iffy situations for three important roles, but it would appear to be a stretch to say there's competition for said roles.

Left field could be an adventure in 2014, but Chris Haft of noted in February that the arrangement the Giants have in mind is for Mike Morse to be the regular starter and for Gregor Blanco to be an occasional platoon partner.

Ryan Vogelsong struggled last year, but assistant general manager Bobby Evans said last month in an interview on KNBR's Murph and Mac Show via ( that Vogelsong wasn't re-signed to compete for the fifth spot in the club's rotation. It's his job to lose, and he's helped himself by looking good early on this spring, according to Haft.

That would seem to leave Yusmeiro Petit in limbo. That, according to, he has a 27.00 ERA this spring would seem to put him even more in limbo. But at the same time, we know that:

  1. Spring training results mean little, and even less when they're early spring training results.
  2. Petit entered camp as the Giants' top rotation depth option after pitching to a 3.56 ERA in eight appearances (seven starts) down the stretch last year.
  3. Petit has plenty of experience pitching in relief in the majors and fits the description of a long reliever.
  4. As Andrew Baggarly of noted last month, Petit is out of options. 

With Petit looking like a hard man to budge from the Giants' 25-man roster on Opening Day, it's currently shaping up like this:

San Francisco Giants' Projected 25-Man Roster
CBuster Posey$11,277,778
1BBrandon Belt$2,900,000
2BMarco Scutaro$6,666,667
3BPablo Sandoval$8,250,000
SSBrandon Crawford$560,000
LFMike Morse$6,000,000
CFAngel Pagan$10,250,000
RFHunter Pence$16,000,000
Bench-OFGregor Blanco$2,525,000
Bench-INFJoaquin Arias$1,150,000
Bench-CHector Sanchez~$502,500
SPMatt Cain$20,833,333
SPMadison Bumgarner$3,950,000
SPTim Lincecum$17,000,000
SPTim Hudson$11,000,000
SPRyan Vogelsong$5,000,000
CL-RHPSergio Romo$5,500,000
RHPSantiago Casilla$4,500,000
LHPJeremy Affeldt$6,000,000
LHPJavier Lopez$4,000,000
Long-RHPYusmeiro Petit$845,000
Salaries: Cot's Baseball Contracts

If this is how it is, then all Bochy has to do is figure out two bench spots and two bullpen spots. And since, as Henry Schulman of the San Francisco Chronicle reported, Giants GM Brian Sabean wants to carry five outfielders this season, that means Bochy is specifically looking for a fifth outfielder, a utility infielder and two relievers.

Let's meet the contestants for these jobs.


Fifth Outfielder Candidates

The Giants entered camp with a half-dozen candidates to nab the fifth outfielder job. But according to Andrew Baggarly, two of those candidates were cut on Thursday: Mac Williamson and Javier Herrera.

That narrows it down to four candidates: Juan Perez, Roger Kieschnick and Gary Brown from the 40-man roster, and Tyler Colvin from the Giants' non-roster invitees.

Only Colvin has extensive major league service time. Brown has yet to crack the majors. As such, it's hard to introduce the four candidates with appropriate numbers. So this will have to do:

Giants 5th Outfielder Candidates
Tyler Colvin28L538411670.743-0.7
Roger Kieschnick27L138950.521-0.1
Juan Perez27R134970.6501.1
Gary Brown25R441419100.767N/A

Note: Brown's numbers encompass what he's done in the minors.

If it's experience and power Bochy is looking for, Colvin could be his man. He's logged far more time in the majors than any of his competitors and owns 47 career homers. That he can play all three outfield positions is another feather in his cap.

What doesn't work so well in Colvin's favor is that the Giants already have a lefty-hitting outfielder lined up for their bench in the person of Blanco. Also, Bochy told this to

Ideally, you'd take a guy who's versatile, with the bat and defense. ... A lot of it will be determined by who we're playing and the game situation. On the whole, we definitely need a guy who is going to give us some defense.

That last part is music to the ears of the other three, but more so for Perez and Brown than Kieschnick. He's only played the corners as a professional, and Defensive Runs Saved and UZR saw him as basically average in 189.2 innings' worth of work in left field last year.

Perez, on the other hand, tallied 10 Defensive Runs Saved and a 13.7 UZR across only 218 innings. We don't have metrics for Brown's defense, but he's typically been graded as a plus defender.

And while I'll re-note that spring training stats are largely useless, it does add to the intrigue to the situation that both Perez and Brown have been hitting well so far. Per, they're both carrying an OPS over 1.000.

The trouble is that this could be a two-edged sword where Brown is concerned. Rather than convince the Giants that he could handle a role as a reserve, it could convince them that Brown is a future starter after all. To prepare for a role like that, he'd be better off logging regular at-bats in the minors.

All we can do at this juncture is guess. But if you want my best one, it's that Perez is going to be the guy who breaks camp as the Giants' fifth outfielder.


Utility Infielder Candidates

The Giants entered camp with plenty of infielders. But strip away the first base/third base types, and they really only entered camp with five infield utility candidates.

And now that Joe Panik has been cut, the list is down to four: Tony Abreu, Ehire Adrianza and Nick Noonan from the 40-man roster, and Brandon Hicks from the non-roster invitees.

Behold what they've done in the majors:

Giants Utility Infielder Candidates
Tony Abreu29S52216110.6610.5
Brandon Hicks28R355980.4930.0
Nick Noonan24L1621110.4990.2
Ehire Adrianza24S19200.7080.1

It looks good on Abreu that he has edges in both experience and production. And while both he and Adrianza are switch-hitters, Abreu has the edge in versatility. He has major league experience at second, third and short, where Adrianza has only played short in both the minors and majors.

However, Adrianza is working on that this spring. As noted by Henry Schulman, Adrianza has been working at second base in hopes that he can win Bochy over.

Between that and Adrianza's 1.125 spring OPS, his mission is going pretty well. According to Schulman, Bochy called Adrianza "the most impressive guy in camp so far" earlier this week.

Since Abreu and Adrianza both offer versatility at the plate and in the field, it's going to be tough for either Hicks or Noonan to gain an edge. The two of them are versatile defensively, but they can't switch hit and haven't helped themselves with their production at the big league level.

Because he's the safe pick for the job, Abreu looks like the man to beat in my mind. But given what Adrianza's up to this spring, this is one of those "stay tuned" situations.


Bullpen Candidates

Fair warning: This is where things get really messy. 

As most teams do, the Giants entered camp with something like 147,943 pitchers to sift through. That number has since gotten smaller with the cuts of six hurlers on Thursday, but the list of relief types trying to get into Bochy's Opening Day pen is still long.

Ready for it? OK, here it is:

Giants Bullpen Candidates
Kameron Loe32R9322569.04.491.441.9
Juan Gutierrez30R5203222.24.651.412.2
Jason Berken30R4110248.25.361.651.8
George Kontos28R3103105.03.511.252.9
Dan Runzler28L48972.13.861.511.8
David Huff29L569323.05.321.501.8
Jean Machi32R25959.22.871.114.2
Jake Dunning25R12925.12.841.221.5
Mike Kickham25L11228.110.161.982.9
Heath Hembree25R197.20.000.786.0
Mason Tobin26R145.16.751.880.0
Mitch Lively28R7252439.23.481.262.2
Adam Reifer27R6229245.13.451.282.2
Erik Cordier28R8166573.14.291.521.4
Brett Bochy26R3121148.22.780.974.3
Hunter Strickland25R6115388.03.801.283.2
Derek Law23R393140.02.571.065.1
Jose De Paula26L689401.03.821.263.6

Note: Once again, the highlighted figures are minor league figures.

If it's conceivable candidates to crack the Giants bullpen we're talking about, the list includes all of the above. But if it's realistic candidates we're looking for, we can narrow it down.

As Chris Haft noted, two of the lefties have been impressive this spring: Jose De Paula and Dan Runzler. They've combined for 4.2 innings, allowing no earned runs with four strikeouts and no walks.

The challenge facing them and fellow southpaws Mike Kickham and David Huff, however, is that the Giants already have two really good lefties locked into jobs in Jeremy Affeldt and Javier Lopez. It's therefore not surprising that Bochy told Haft that the Giants aren't committed to carrying a third lefty.

Further complicating Huff's situation is that he profiles more as a long reliever than as a situational guy. Having both him and Petit in the bullpen makes little sense. It's possible that Huff's lefty arm will look better and better if Petit continues to struggle this spring, but for now it's probably going to take an injury for him to crack the Opening Day roster.

Regarding the right-handers, meanwhile, there are four guys in particular who stand out as favorites: Jean Machi, George Kontos, Heath Hembree and Derek Law. The first two have the experience, and the other two have the upside.

Machi's the best bet to earn one of the two open spots. As noted by Haft, the veteran righty is out of options. He also backed up a 2.38 ERA in 2013 with a 2.29 FIP and 2.78 xFIP, and he was able to avoid a scary platoon split by holding lefty batters to a .642 OPS (that's Machi's splitter at work). 

As far as the other three, that Kontos was so up and down in 2013 (4.39 ERA and 4.08 FIP) helps Hembree and Law. That Hembree was as impressive as he was in his big league cameo last year certainly helps him.

But don't think that Law can't edge Hembree. The young righty has only advanced as far as High-A, but all he did at that level was notch 45 strikeouts and one walk in 22 outings. And with a funky delivery, mid-90s heat and a dangerous slider, he has the usual trappings of a shutdown reliever.

I'd put the smart money on Machi and Hembree earning the last two bullpen spots. But if anybody's going to crash the party, it's going to be Law.


Note: Stats courtesy of unless otherwise noted/linked. Salaries courtesy of Cot's Baseball Contracts.


If you want to talk baseball, hit me up on Twitter.

Follow zachrymer on Twitter


    Report: Nike to Take Over Under Armour's MLB Uniform Deal

    MLB logo

    Report: Nike to Take Over Under Armour's MLB Uniform Deal

    via Yahoo

    Projecting MLB's Top 20 OFs of the Future

    San Francisco Giants logo
    San Francisco Giants

    Projecting MLB's Top 20 OFs of the Future

    Joel Reuter
    via Bleacher Report

    Bundy Fans 14, Tosses 2-Hitter to Lead O's Past Chisox

    MLB logo

    Bundy Fans 14, Tosses 2-Hitter to Lead O's Past Chisox

    A Little Love for Wotus — Brandon Belt

    San Francisco Giants logo
    San Francisco Giants

    A Little Love for Wotus — Brandon Belt

    SF Giants
    via Splash Hits