Johnny Manziel's Combine Solidifies Stock as Top-5 Pick

Tim KeeneyContributor IFebruary 25, 2014

Texas A&M quarterback Johnny Manziel runs a drill at the NFL football scouting combine in Indianapolis, Sunday, Feb. 23, 2014. (AP Photo/Nam Y. Huh)
Nam Y. Huh/Associated Press

Johnny Manziel is polarizing. 

Some can't help but be enamored by the former Texas A&M quarterback's dual-threat ability, elusiveness and creativity while under pressure, or his record-setting production in college. Others, however, are put off by his perceived lack of maturity, off-the-field question marks and propensity to sometimes force the issue on the gridiron.

The latter group has undoubtedly made itself heard.

"If you want to win, you don't draft (Johnny) Manziel," said an anonymous NFL quarterback, via's Glenn Moore. "You draft (Blake) Bortles."

Woah, woah, woah, Mr. Anonymous NFL Quarterback.

If you prefer Bortles over Manziel, that's perfectly fine.

In fact, when comparing the top three quarterbacks against each other, there is no right answer in my mind. Whether or not you like Manziel, Bortles or Teddy Bridgewater really comes down to a matter of preference, as each QB presents a different set of attributes and would fit different offensive schemes to varying degrees of success. 

But to say an NFL team isn't going to be winning games with Johnny Football at the helm is pure poppycock.

During the combine, Manziel solidified his rank as the most athletic quarterback in this class. Not only did he run the fastest 40 (4.56), but his short shuttle time of 4.03 was the second fastest since 2006, according to Rotoworld's Josh Norris:

That athleticism and elite lateral quickness is what makes Manziel able to do some truly amazing things on the football field.'s Sigmund Bloom called him "the best quarterback I've ever evaluated" in terms of escapability inside the pocket and elusiveness outside of it. 

Not only is that kind of playmaking ability on another level, but Manziel is an underrated thrower. His mechanics sometimes leave a little bit to be desired, but he can be deadly accurate—both from the pocket and on the run—to all areas of the field. 

In his game-changing ability to elude pressure, extend plays and make phenomenal throws, Manziel is reminiscent of Russell Wilson. Go ahead and ask anyone from Seattle—once they stop swooning—how he's working out.'s Mike Mayock, via NBC's Newy Scruggs, put it simply:

The one thing always holding Manziel back has been maturity concerns, but at the combine, that's where he truly excelled. 

The Jacksonville Jaguars had a 15-minute session with the electrifying quarterback. According to Sports Illustrated's Peter King, they came away impressed. He met with the Oakland Raiders. According to NFL Radio, via's Gregg Rosenthal, they were also impressed.

One scout, via Tampa Bay Buccaneers insider Jenna Laine, said Manziel "knocked it out of the park" during an interview:

Wrong sports reference, but more praise nonetheless. 

While Manziel undoubtedly has the talent, intangibles and poise on the field, he's now beginning to win teams over off of it, and the work ethic to continually get better is evident. 

“That’s how I am. You can tell me ‘no’ all you want, but at the end of the day I’m going to win," Manziel said, via King. "I’m going to be successful.”

Manziel may never shake his large group of critics. But as he continues to gain admiration across the league, that's not going to matter.