Will Michigan or Ohio State Finish with Better 2014 Recruiting Class?

Alex SimsCorrespondent IIIFebruary 4, 2014

Getty Images

The Big Ten Conference is set to expand to 14 teams in 2014, and the Ohio State Buckeyes and the Michigan Wolverines are on the recruiting trail to make sure they will continue to compete for league titles.

In fact, both programs have attracted the type of prospects that will have them in competition for a berth in the College Football Playoff, also set to begin next season.

Michigan will welcome the highest-rated recruit in the entire league, but OSU has drawn in a long list of blue-chip athletes as well.

So which of the Big Ten rivals pulled in the best class? Scroll on for breakdowns of each class and the final ruling on which will win the battle for the premier group in the conference. 


Note: All player and team rankings based on the 247Sports Composite ratings, unless otherwise noted. All rankings pre-signing day.



Michigan 2014 Class


Class rank: National: 16, Big Ten: 2

Commits: 16

5-stars: 1

4-stars: 8

Michigan's 2014 class isn't as strong as it once promised to be, but it will still end up among the best groups in the nation.

The Wolverines pulled in one of the most highly anticipated prospects in the class, 5-star and No. 1 athlete Jabrill Peppers. He projects as a defensive back, but his returning and playmaking skills could have him playing in all three phases in Ann Arbor.

He's the lone 5-star and will be joined by several promising 4-star and 3-star recruits.

Several of UM's top recruits, including 4-star receiver Drake Harris and 4-star defensive tackle Bryan Mone, enrolled early.


Remaining Targets

The only remaining question mark for this class for Michigan is 5-star defensive end Malik McDowell.

The Southfield, Mich., native has had quite the recruiting saga. It seemed as though he was beginning to lean toward joining the vaunted Michigan State defense, but just two days before signing day, Joe Rexrode of the Detroit Free Press reported that his parents don't want him to become a Spartan.

While his mother said she would be content with him heading to Michigan, both of his parents would prefer him to go out of state, per Rexrode:

Greg McDowell told 247Sports.com of his son’s recruitment and MSU: “You have to be somewhere you have less distractions and be around people that do what you do, go to class, be football players, be a student-athlete. That’s the environment I want him to be around, and not be in close proximity to his friends. I want him out of Michigan. I don’t care if that’s Ohio State or Florida State.”

(Malik's mother Joya) Crowe said she would be OK with her son choosing U-M but agreed that “I think it’s best he leaves the state.”

McDowell would be a tremendous late addition and more than a consolation prize for missing out on top strong-side defensive end Da'Shawn Hand.


Ohio State 2014 Class

Class rank: National: 2, Big Ten: 1

Commits: 22

5-stars: 1

4-stars: 15

Ohio State's 2014 class is highlighted by 5-star linebacker Raekwon McMillan. The No. 1 inside linebacker in the country, McMillan is already enrolled at OSU and could provide an immediate replacement for All-American Ryan Shazier, who headed off to the NFL.

The Buckeyes brought in seven early enrollees, including McMillan, two touted offensive linemen and 4-star receivers Curtis Samuel and Johnnie Dixon.

With McMillan as the headliner, OSU addressed major needs on the defensive side, particularly in the secondary. After finishing 11th in the Big Ten in pass defense, the Buckeyes added a skilled trio of defensive backs: 4-star corners Damon Webb and Marshon Lattimore and 4-star safety Erick Smith.

A pair of 4-stars, Dante Booker and Kyle Berger, will join McMillan in the LB corps, while 4-star end Jalyn Holmes will anchor the defensive front.

This class might not have the flash of a player like Peppers, but it is one of the deepest groups in the nation.


Remaining Targets

Ohio State is close to having its class finalized, but there are a few recruits left on the board.

At the top is McDowell, whose aforementioned decision will come Wednesday. Other remaining targets include 4-star defensive tackle Derrick Nnadi and 4-star offensive tackle Roderick Johnson.

However, the big one is undoubtedly McDowell.



Michigan has a strong class, highlighted by the top recruit in the entire conference: Peppers.

However, even the No. 3 overall prospect in the nation isn't enough for the Wolverines' recruiting class to compare to that of the Buckeyes.

OSU has a 5-star of its own and nearly double the number of 4-star commits heading into national signing day.

The Buckeyes stocked up on both sides of the ball, adding several key defenders and offensive skill players. As a result, they have the Big Ten's best class by a wide margin.


    Luke Falk Opens Up on Hilinski's Death

    College Football logo
    College Football

    Luke Falk Opens Up on Hilinski's Death

    Stefanie Loh
    via The Seattle Times

    Details Emerge About Events Leading Up to Hilinski's Death

    College Football logo
    College Football

    Details Emerge About Events Leading Up to Hilinski's Death

    Joseph Zucker
    via Bleacher Report

    Police Won't Release Hilinski's Suicide Note

    College Football logo
    College Football

    Police Won't Release Hilinski's Suicide Note

    NCAA College Football
    via NCAA College Football

    Report: Grier (Hand) Cleared to Begin Throwing Again

    College Football logo
    College Football

    Report: Grier (Hand) Cleared to Begin Throwing Again

    via Diehards