Adam Bettcher/Getty Images
Kicker: Caleb Sturgis, Miami Dolphins (11 Votes)
Given that he's the only rookie kicker to play significant snaps this season, Sturgis is essentially the lead pony in a one-horse race.
With that said, though, Sturgis has at least been serviceable for the Dolphins, hitting on 26 of 34 attempts this year and ranking 11th among place-kickers, according to Pro Football Focus.
Punter: Sam Martin, Detroit Lions (12 Votes)
The small-school star from Appalachian State has quieted the doubters who giggled when the Lions used a fifth-round pick on him in 2013, ranking among the top 10 punters in the NFL in both gross and net yards per kick.
Kick Returner: Cordarrelle Patterson, Minnesota Vikings (12 Votes)
Patterson didn't make the cut as a wide receiver, but when it comes to kick returns, it's easy to see why the panel chose to include the lanky speedster.
The 1,300-plus return yards, two scores and top ranking among return men at Pro Football Focus might have had something to do with it.
Punt Returner: Tavon Austin, St. Louis Rams (12 Votes)
By most measuring sticks, Austin's rookie season was a disappointment, whether due to his struggling to acclimate as an NFL receiver or the Rams trying to find ways to get him the ball in space.
While he was returning punts, though, we got a glimpse of the Tavon Austin who was so dangerous at West Virginia.
Austin managed fewer than 10 yards per return in 2013, but if he saw daylight, good night. He found the end zone on punt returns twice in 2013, which tied Dexter McCluster for the NFL lead.