Now, he's leading the NFL in tackles and becoming one of the NFL's next dominant linebackers.
Every NFL team had a number of chances to select the former Arizona State All-American, but nobody pulled the trigger because of "character concerns." These issues were widely documented by every print publication, website, radio station and television program out there.
In case you've forgotten, here's a quick rundown of the good, bad and ugly of Burfict's stock plummeting before the 2012 draft.
Just after the 2011 season ended, Todd McShay of Scouts Inc. (via ESPN's Ted Miller) moved Burfict from No. 15 to No. 21 on his big board.
Questions about Burfict's on-field maturity and mental makeup have hurt his stock, but he's a physically gifted player with the tools of a top-10 prospect. He has the power to deliver heavy blows and solid range and awareness in underneath coverage.
At that point, McShay still considered Burfict a first-round pick, but it was the next few months leading up to the draft where things really started to fall apart.
"I talked to some teams, and I told them I had smoked marijuana before," Burfict told NFL.com. "It's not like I'm the only person that has ever done that."
This was a red flag for teams, as the whole "everyone else is doing it" excuse indicated there was a lack of accountability for his decisions and actions.
The coaches (at Arizona State) kind of messed me up, like, I didn't know if I was going to start a game, I didn't know if I was going to be benched. So, it hurt me at times, but I tried to fight through it.
Coaches don't look fondly on players who throw others under the bus.
Combined with a poor showing at the combine and unfavorable reviews from a recently fired Arizona State coaching staff, Burfict was seen as a player without a future in the NFL.
According to ESPN's Alyssa Roenigk, it was Burfict's mother, Lisa Williams, who reached out to him after his disastrous combine performance and encouraged him to keep going, saying, "You can't quit now."
Burfict spoke confidently days before the draft that he'd make a difference for an NFL team, telling Aaron Wilson of Scout.com (via Fox Sports Arizona):
The team that drafts me will see that my work ethic isn't questionable at all. I realize how much I really want this for my life. If teams pass on me, they're going to have to face me for the next 10 years. If they don't want me, they're going to miss out.
Players will often say things like that, but very rarely can he look at the entire league and say, "Told you so."
Burfict has been fantastic for the Bengals over the past two seasons, but he's only in this position for two reasons: He worked his tail off and was given an opportunity.
Whether that opportunity would ever come was a big question when Burfict went undrafted, but it was Bengals coach Marvin Lewis who gave him a chance.
Speaking before the Bengals rookie minicamp in 2012, Lewis laid it out there for Burfict, via Joe Reedy of Cincinnati.com:
You weren't in shape your last season at Arizona State. Get rid of the selfishness in your play. Learn how to bend your knees. Let us coach you and let’s see if you are what people thought you could have been. Because I have no idea who you are and so you’re starting from scratch here.
"Starting from scratch" must have been a relief for Burfict. There was so much made of his issues during his final season at Arizona State that he needed to feel like he could get past it, and Lewis gave him that chance.
Lewis acknowledged that he saw something special in Burfict:
What he does now from this point forward is going to determine whether or not he can be a NFL player. I think he has some ability. When you watch the tape there are a lot of things he didn’t do very well. But he does some things I can’t coach that he can do.
Sometimes when coaches take a chance on a player, they're rewarded for that decision. Burfict has not only contributed to the Bengals defense, but he's one of the unquestioned leaders of the No. 5-ranked scoring unit in the NFL.
According to Pro Football Focus (subscription required), Burfict is the No. 3-ranked outside linebacker in the NFL, trailing only the Denver Broncos' Von Miller and Tampa Bay Buccaneers' Lavonte David.
|Leading Tacklers (Week 13)|
|Vontaze Burfict||Cincinnati Bengals||131|
|Kiko Alonso||Buffalo Bills||125|
|Paul Posluszny||Jacksonville Jaguars||113|
|NaVorro Bowman||San Francisco 49ers||111|
|Lavonte David||Tampa Bay Buccaneers||108|
There's a whole lot more than your basic tackling statistics on PFF, and one of the most important stats they track for defensive players is "tackling efficiency."
It calculates how many missed tackles a player has in relation to the total number of tackles he attempts. In that category, Burfict leads all 4-3 outside linebackers by averaging a missed tackle per every 20.5 attempts.
|4-3 Outside Linebackers (Tackling Efficiency)|
|1||Vontaze Burfict||Cincinnati Bengals||20.5|
|2||Jacquian Williams||New York Giants||13.3|
|3||Dont'a Hightower||New England Patriots||13.0|
|4||Zach Brown||Tennessee Titans||11.8|
|5||James Anderson||Chicago Bears||11.3|
|Pro Football Focus|
Only including outside linebackers who have seen at least 75 percent of their teams' defensive snaps this season, Burfict has the fewest missed tackles with six. He has the most tackles in the NFL and also happens to miss the fewest.
We'll start with instincts.
On this play against the San Diego Chargers, you'll see his instincts on the field.
The Chargers called an inside zone run with running back Ryan Mathews. The center was supposed to be able to peel off the block on the defensive tackle and get to Burfict, but he never got there.
Once Mathews had the ball, he had a clear lane up the middle of the field. Burfict recognized that from his linebacking position and headed toward that lane.
The two down defensive tackles did a great job of closing the lane off by fighting through their blocks. Mathews saw the cutback lane open up and planted his right foot to cut back toward the "new" free lane.
Burfict could have seen his initial lane and went full steam ahead toward closing what was a big hole for Mathews. Instead, he played under control, saw the play develop and used his instincts to know what Mathews was going to do.
Mathews cut back, and Burfict was there waiting for him.
Many times you'll see the linebacker over-pursue that play and allow the running back a cutback lane. Based on the initial lane Mathews saw when he got the ball, which the linebacker would see too, it's easy to see why linebackers would react that way.
This is an example of great linebacking play and overall team defense. The defensive linemen were able close off the lane initially.
Here's another inside zone run, but this time it's against the Detroit Lions.
Burfict met the left guard, Rob Sims, head-on as he pulled around to block for running back Reggie Bush.
Here's the collision at the second level of the defense.
Burfict was able to get off the block and make the tackle for a minimal gain.
There's no way to play linebacker at the NFL level without being extremely physical, and we've seen examples of Burfict's instincts and physicality inside the box against the run.
But what about when he's singled out in space against a ball-carrier?
Here's another play against the Chargers.
There's under two minutes left in the first half, and the Chargers had the ball at midfield. It was 2nd-and-15, and quarterback Philip Rivers dumped it off in the flat to Mathews.
Once Mathews caught the ball and turned upfield, you can see it's just the two of them one-on-one out in space.
There was plenty of room for Mathews if Burfict wasn't able to make the tackle. The red circles are the closest Bengals defenders.
Burfict was able to make the tackle behind the line of scrimmage. The Chargers weren't able to convert on 3rd-and-long and were forced to punt, and the play by Burfict could have saved the Bengals some points.
There's no denying what Burfict means to the Bengals defense right now, especially after losing Geno Atkins and Leon Hall for the season. Those two playmakers being out forced other guys to step up, and Burfict responded.
He was named the AFC Defensive Player of the Week on Nov. 20 after his 15-tackle performance against the Cleveland Browns in Week 12.
Back when people were questioning Burfict's future in the NFL, Lewis said "he had no idea" what kind of guy Burfict was, most likely because he hadn't been around him much.
Things are very different now, as he told USA Today's Jarrett Bell: "He's been such a joy to coach. Where he got the reputation that he has, I don't know where he got it. But he's got charisma, leadership, everything."
His instincts, physicality and athletic ability are what separates him from other NFL linebackers. He's a special talent realizing his potential, and that's a fun thing to watch for any football fan.