Browns Quarterback Watch: Week 14 Ranking for Top 2014 Draft QB Prospects

Use your ← → (arrow) keys to browse more stories
Browns Quarterback Watch: Week 14 Ranking for Top 2014 Draft QB Prospects
Rick Osentoski-USA TODAY Sports

Cleveland's 2013 quarterback nightmare continues heading into Sunday as a starter has still not been named by head coach Rob Chudzinski.

However, draft options for the Browns' next franchise QB also got cloudier as injuries, poor performances and a player returning to school added up this past week.

The top nine NFL draft quarterback prospects, according to CBS Sports, will be ranked weekly here on Bleacher Report to determine who would best fit this Browns organization. A 10th "wild card" option is added in as a potential later-round developmental project for Cleveland. 

NCAA Quarterback Week 14 Results
Name & Ranking School Passing Touchdowns Interceptions Passing Yards Rushing Yards Completion Percentage
1. Teddy Bridgewater Louisville No Game No Game No Game No Game No Game
2. Derek Carr Fresno State 6 1 519 32 76.0
3. Johnny Manziel Texas A&M 1 0 195 21 68.6
4. Brett Hundley UCLA 0 0 208 80 66.7
5. Zach Mettenberger (injured) LSU 0 1 156 -27 63.6
6. Tajh Boyd Clemson 0 2 225 16 70.4
7. A.J. McCarron Alabama 3 0 277 16 58.6
8. Jimmy Garoppolo Eastern Illinois No Game No Game No Game No Game No Game
9. Aaron Murray (injured) Georgia DNP (Did Not Participate) DNP DNP DNP DNP
11. David Fales (wild card) San Jose State 6 0 547 33 82.2

Stats by and ranking by

Wild Card: David Fales

One game doesn't make a career, but David Fales came to play on Nov. 29, when he outdueled rising star, and this report's top-ranked Browns' quarterback prospect, Derek Carr, in San Jose State's wild 62-52 victory over Fresno State.

The San Jose State senior exchanged touchdowns with Carr, with each tossing six apiece, though Fales did not throw an interception. Fales' magical night saw him complete over 82 percent of his passes and put up 547 yards through the air.

Although the Spartans finished the season with a .500 regular-season record, the win demonstrated that he can rise to the occasion in a high-profile matchup.

In 2013, Fales threw 33 touchdowns to just 13 interceptions. He racked up 4,189 passing yards and had a rating of 153.3. Despite the prodigious numbers, his overall production actually slipped from that of his 2012 season, including a dip in completion percentage and passer rating. And he turned the ball over four more times in 2013 than he did a year ago.

However, in the last four contests Fales continuously improved in all passing categories and posted a touchdown-to-interception ratio of 15-to-3. 

A projected fourth- or fifth-round pick by CBS Sports, the signal-caller is versatile and has had success working in the shotgun and pistol formations as well as from under center. He can scramble when needed, but he also displays toughness and a willingness to stay in the pocket.

Fales' footwork, snap delivery, work ethic and ability to read defenses are his core strengths. Areas for concern include an inability to drive the ball effectively over 15 yards, which leads to high, floating passes on deep throws.

Power Rankings: Week 14

The below power rankings are based on which quarterback's skill set and most recent statistics would be most suitable for Cleveland's desired game plan to aggressively push the ball downfield.

Ideal qualifications include an accurate arm with deep ball strength, quick decision-making ability and some mobility in and out of the pocket.

Power Rankings: Top Five Week 14 Prospects for Cleveland
Name & Ranking School Height/Weight 2013 TD/INT 2013 Passing Yards 2013 Completion Percentage 2013 Passer Rating
1. Derek Carr Fresno State 6'3"/218 45/5 4,462 70.3 163.3
2. Teddy Bridgewater Louisville 6'3"/196 25/3 3,268 71.0 172.8
3. Jimmy Garoppolo Eastern Illinois 6'3"/222 48/8 4,489 65.0 170.6
4. Brett Hundley UCLA 6'3"/222 22/9 2,845 67.8 153.7
5. Zach Mettenberger (injured) LSU 6'5"/230 22/8 3,082 64.9 171.4

Browns Quarterback Prospects of the Week:

Derek Carr remains atop the Browns' power rankings for a third consecutive week, which is no surprise considering the circumstances surrounding the other highly touted quarterbacks. 

LSU's Zach Mettenberger sat second in these power rankings the last two weeks and looked to be a sure-fire first-round selection in May's NFL draft. The Tigers' signal-caller slumped over his last three outings as he threw only three touchdowns during that stretch, twice failing to pass for more than 200 yards in a game.

More concerning, of course, is that Mettenberger joined Georgia's Aaron Murray with a season-ending ACL tear. Leaning on crutches, the injured QB watched from the sidelines, as his Tigers came back to defeat Arkansas on Nov. 29.

When news broke about the severity of the knee injury, Mettenberger's draft stock plummeted on some mock draft boards, including that of CBS Sports, which now has him falling out of the first round.

Crystal LoGiudice-USA TODAY Sports
LSU QB Zach Mettenberger on crutches and with an ice pack on his injured left knee

Mettenberger still remains at the bottom of Cleveland's top-five prospects because his size, downfield-throwing ability and quick reads are very much in line with what a Norv Turner offense looks for. 

Like Murray, this ailment requires a long recovery time. With Brian Hoyer rehabbing the same type of injury, do the Browns really want their new recruit coming in as damaged goods?

Highly touted, but infuriatingly inconsistent, Oregon's Marcus Mariota decided to return to school for his junior year.

Mariota was rated by Scouts Inc. as the No. 3 overall player available in the upcoming draft, but, per CBS Sports' draft breakdown, the Oregon quarterback's occasional subpar play in recent weeks bumps Derek Carr up to the second-ranked QB behind Louisville's Teddy Bridgewater.

With injuries, poor performances and some prospects returning to school, what quarterback should the Browns draft?

Submit Vote vote to see results

This is potentially bad news for the Browns if they are coveting Carr, since quarterback-seeking teams are above them on the draft board.

Disappointing efforts plagued several prospects over Thanksgiving weekend. Johnny Manziel, Brett Hundley and Tajh Boyd all put up below-average or disappointing numbers. 

It was the second straight dud for Manziel, and both Hundley and Boyd continue to be alarmingly inconsistent.

Bowl season is fast approaching. There is still plenty of time for these NCAA quarterbacks to turn heads and raise their value to eagerly awaiting scouts.

Andy McNamara is an international sports broadcaster and journalist.

Follow Andy on Twitter @AndyMc81

Follow Cleveland Browns from B/R on Facebook

Follow Cleveland Browns from B/R on Facebook and get the latest updates straight to your newsfeed!

Cleveland Browns

Subscribe Now

By signing up for our newsletter, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.

Thanks for signing up.