The Mets' addition of Chris Young is provoking anger from fans, but maybe that's not completely logical.
So, we woke up this morning and the New York Mets did something. That was new. They signed free-agent outfielder Chris Young to a one-year deal worth $7.2 million. It's a little weird, but let's talk this through before we react.
Young struggled through a down year with the Oakland A's last year, hitting at just a .200 clip, striking out a ton, and playing kinda crappy defense. FanGraphs had his 2013 UZR at 0.2 with negative-six defensive runs saved.
His lowest single-season batting average was, as you'd imagine, a product of his lowest single-season BABIP. That mark was a sad .237—but it's easy to see why when you take a look at some batted-ball numbers. Young's infield fly ball percentage was nearly five percentage points higher than in 2012, and that makes sense considering the ballpark he played in. Using super-advanced Photoshop skills, here's a comparison of infield pastures between O.co Coliseum—or whatever you'd like to call it—and Citi Field.
So yeah, you can predict that Young probably won't pop out as much.
On the down side, he struck out a ton last season, K-ing in nearly 25 percent of his plate appearances. That was bad. Between the strikeouts and pop flies, Young's on-base clip was .280, which goes against pretty much everything general manager Sandy Alderson wants.
That OBP being significantly higher than his .200 AVG is pretty encouraging though, again alluding back to the projected drop-off in infield flies. As long as Young manages to strike out a little less often in 2014, it'd be reasonable to except that BABIP to creep back toward his .274 career average. If the Mets can get, say, a .245/.330/.430-type line from Young at the bottom of their order, that's a lot better than the scraps they'd be running out in right field without him.
The Mets obviously have a need for both corner outfield spots, and Young fills one. You'd presume they'll try and build the outfield with Juan Lagares planted in center. Lagares posted a crazy 28 DRS last season in just over 900 innings, roughly 400 and 300 less than outfield leaders Gerardo Parra and Carlos Gomez. Young will probably be slotted into right, according to Adam Rubin. Prior to last season, Young had no MLB experience at either corner, but he played 26 games in right and 24 in left for the A's. At the moment, Eric Young Jr. (this will probably get confusing) is penciled in, starting in left.
The $7.2 million salary is questionable, but it's not a long-term handicap, as it expires after this season. It seems like an overpay, but at a certain point, if everybody is getting overpaid, maybe that's just the way of the market in 2013. With Matt Harvey down until 2015, that's when the Mets are building toward. Young has the potential to be a solid starter in right, and if not, his career .262 average against lefties—compared to .225 against right-handers—makes him a platoon candidate, with Matt den Dekker as a possible partner.
With Lagares able to cover plenty of ground, Young won't need to be spectacular with the glove, but the Mets will hope for an improvement from 2013, when he finished 264th out of 299 qualified outfielders in runs saved.
The value is questionable, but Alderson needed a corner outfielder and wasn't going to get anyone else of worth on a one-year pact. The deal makes for a good trial run for the 30-year-old Young, who'll need to prove that he can be worth significant free-agent consideration next year.
If it works out, it's a win for both sides. The Mets will get 2014 outfield help and Young will garner a multi-year deal from somebody next winter. If the deal blows up in Sandy's face? Oh well. That $7 million is off the books immediately and they can try again next winter.
Will the Chris Young signing work out for the Mets?
With one corner down, Alderson still needs a power-hitting bat to line up in left, which will more than likely be acquired via trade.
The Mets have Daniel Murphy and one of the Ike Davis/Lucas Duda pu pu platoon to dangle as major-league bats, along with one of Jon Niese or Jenrry Mejia and a glut of prospect arms. If Murphy is dealt, E.Y. Jr. or Wilmer Flores could presumably slide in at second base full time, and the remaining of Davis or Duda (or possibly even Josh Satin?) would take the first base job.
Meanwhile, the team still has no suitable shortstop anywhere in the system, which is...err...less than ideal. New York is also still looking to add a starter or two, so keep an eye on guys like Phil Hughes and Bronson Arroyo as potential Mets in the coming weeks.
Alderson has his work cut out for him, especially with the pitiful budget he's being allocated this winter, but the Young addition is a decent move to get the ball rolling.
Follow me on Twitter at @JSDorn6.