Browns Quarterback Watch: Week 12 Rankings for Top 2014 Draft QB Prospects

Use your ← → (arrow) keys to browse more stories
Browns Quarterback Watch: Week 12 Rankings for Top 2014 Draft QB Prospects
Matt Sullivan/Getty Images

Welcome to the Cleveland Browns Week 12 college quarterback watch. 

The top nine 2014 QB NFL draft prospects, according to, will be ranked weekly here on Bleacher Report to determine who would best fit this Cleveland organization. A 10th "wild card" option is added in as a potential later-round developmental project for the Browns.

Since the franchise returned in 1999, it has had 20 different starting quarterbacks. Browns Backers worldwide are praying that this front office, led by CEO Joe Banner, can finally get it right.

NCAA Quarterback Week 12 Results
Name & Ranking School Passing Touchdowns Interceptions Passing Yards Rushing Yards Completion Percentage
1. Teddy Bridgewater Louisville 0 0 203 -20 65.5
2. Marcus Mariota Oregon 3 0 288 -18 73.1
3. Johnny Manziel Texas A&M No Game No Game No Game No Game No Game
4. Derek Carr Fresno State No Game No Game No Game No Game No Game
5. Zach Mettenberger LSU No Game No Game No Game No Game No Game
6. Brett Hundley UCLA 2 0 159 15 59.1
7. Tajh Boyd Clemson 4 1 340 43 76.9
8. A.J. McCarron Alabama 2 2 187 12 56.3
9. Aaron Murray Georgia 2 1 415 37 67.3
13. Logan Thomas (Wildcard) Virginia Tech 2 0 210 -17 61.3

Stats by and ranking by


Wild Card: Logan Thomas

A projected fifth- or sixth-round pick, Logan Thomas possesses the combined throwing power and speed to extend plays with his legs that the Browns' coaching staff would love.

Mike Ehrmann/Getty Images
Virginia Tech quarterback Logan Thomas

At a mighty 6'6" and 257 pounds, this raw talent out of Virginia Tech can be brilliant or incredibly frustrating in his performances. His 15 touchdowns, 12 interceptions and 58.3 completion percentage emphasize that inconsistency.

However, the senior is on an upward trend over the past two games, and continued improvements would lead to a rise in his draft stock.

The Hokies signal-caller threw for four combined scores in those matchups and did not turn the ball over. Thomas' completion percentages were also above his seasonal average in the win over Miami (80.6) and overtime loss against Maryland (61.3).

Power Rankings: Week 12 

The below power rankings are based on what quarterback's skill set and statistics to date would be most suitable for Cleveland offensive coordinator Norv Turner's aggressive vertical downfield game plan.

Ideal criteria includes an accurate arm with deep ball strength, quick decision-making ability as well as some mobility in and out of the pocket.

Power Rankings: Top Five Week 12 QB Prospects for Cleveland
Name & Ranking School Height/Weight 2013 TD/INT 2013 Passing Yards 2013 Completion Percentage 2013 Passer Rating
1. Derek Carr Fresno State 6'3"/218 32/4 3,421 69.5 152.3
2. Zach Mettenberger LSU 6'5"/230 20/7 2,733 65.7 176.6
3. Marcus Mariota Oregon 6'4"/211 25/0 2,819 64.2 176.2
4. Aaron Murray Georgia 6'1"/208 22/8 2,892 63.9 156.3
5. Logan Thomas Virginia Tech 6'6"/257 15/12 2,632 58.3 126.4

Browns Quarterback Prospect of the Week: Derek Carr 

Fresno State's Derek Carr is transforming this season into the moldable clay perfect for Turner's attack strategy. Even his flaws land right into the offensive coordinator's wheelhouse of development.

The senior demonstrated throughout 2013 that he can outwit defenses and make NFL-quality throws. 

Any collegiate prospect from sunny California usually raises fan questions of whether he can handle the unpredictable weather of Northeast Ohio.

Well, Carr certainly can and proved it in the November 9 contest at Wyoming. He was able to sling the rock with authority through the cold, windy conditions and finished with a four-touchdown, zero-interception road victory.

As of Week 12, What College Quarterback Should the Cleveland Browns Draft?

Submit Vote vote to see results

The Bulldog's arm strength is a crucial asset, but his speed in getting rid of the football and accuracy on all types of throws are what really stands out. At 6'3", the 218-pounder is nimble enough to have defenses respect the threat of him scampering for positive gains. 

Turner and head coach Rob Chudzinski thrive in improving the mechanics and footwork of young quarterbacks. Both are areas that Carr needs to clean up to have a chance at becoming elite at the pro level.

Names like Troy Aikman, Alex Smith and Philip Rivers all suffered from similar deficiencies and benefited from Turner's veteran tutelage during their early years in the league.

Over 70 percent of Carr's passes were completed during the past two weeks, which is above his 2013 average of 69.5. More good news for the Dawg Pound is that No. 4 is on pace to match or surpass his impressive 2012 numbers.

He may not get all the media attention like a Teddy Bridgewater or Johnny Manziel, but Carr is quickly developing into this draft's safest bet under center.

Andy McNamara is an international sports broadcaster and journalist.

Follow Andy on Twitter @AndyMc81.

Follow Cleveland Browns from B/R on Facebook

Follow Cleveland Browns from B/R on Facebook and get the latest updates straight to your newsfeed!

Cleveland Browns

Subscribe Now

By signing up for our newsletter, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.

Thanks for signing up.