Breaking Down the Jon Lester, Adam Wainwright World Series Game 5 Matchup

Use your ← → (arrow) keys to browse more stories
Breaking Down the  Jon Lester, Adam Wainwright World Series Game 5 Matchup
(Photo by Jamie Squire/Getty Images)

Game 5 of the World Series on Monday night features a scrumptious starting pitching matchup of Jon Lester and Adam Wainwright, the aces of the Boston Red Sox and St. Louis Cardinals, respectively.

Both excelled during the early rounds of the postseason, but Wainwright wasn't sharp at all in the opener of this series. Lester capitalized on his shakiness and led the Red Sox to an 8-1 rout.

By dissecting the highlights and crunching some numbers, we'll get a better idea of what to expect from them in the rematch from Busch Stadium.

Regardless of how you evaluate it, Lester was terrific last week. The 29-year-old completed 7.2 scoreless innings, piling up eight strikeouts while only issuing one walk. It was among the most dominant World Series outings of the past several generations for the Red Sox:

Courtesy of MLB.com

Highest World Series Game Scores for Red Sox Since World War II
Starting Pitcher Date Opponent Game Score
Jim Lonborg Oct. 5, 1967 St. Louis Cardinals 88
Jim Lonborg Oct. 9, 1967 St. Louis Cardinals 81
Joe Dobson Oct. 11, 1946 St. Louis Cardinals 80
Bruce Hurst Oct. 18, 1986 New York Mets 78
Luis Tiant Oct. 11, 1975 Cincinnati Reds 78
Jon Lester Oct. 23, 2013 St. Louis Cardinals 76
Dave Ferriss Oct. 9, 1967 St. Louis Cardinals 76

Baseball-Reference.com

Lester's knack for elevating the quality of his pitching in October puts him in the company of a few all-time greats, tweets ESPN's John Buccigross:

To the dismay of the Cardinals and their fans, he has also been in an excellent groove since early August. The Game 1 masterpiece was his 12th quality start in the past 14 tries. During that stretch, the veteran lefty has consistently kept the basepaths clean:

Jon Lester's Past 14 Starts
Date IP H ER BB K
Aug. 8 7.0 5 1 2 4
Aug. 14 6.1 6 2 2 3
Aug. 19 8.1 6 0 2 3
Aug. 24 7.1 3 1 4 6
Aug. 29 6.0 5 3 3 4
Sept. 3 7.0 8 1 0 9
Sept. 8 8.0 10 3 1 6
Sept. 14 8.0 3 1 2 5
Sept. 20 7.0 5 1 2 8
Sept. 28 5.0 9 4 2 4
Oct. 4 7.2 3 2 3 7
Oct. 12 6.1 6 1 1 4
Oct. 17 5.1 7 2 3 3
Oct. 23 7.2 5 0 1 8
Aug. 8 - Oct. 23 97.0 81 22 28 74

Baseball-Reference.com

We're looking at two-and-a-half months of a 1.12 WHIP against mostly American League lineups.

In other words, putting on multiple baserunners against Lester in any inning is a rare luxury. Ending his evening early will require the Red Birds to rack up extra-base hits.

This is where National League rules come back to bite St. Louis. No designated hitter spot means no plate appearances from banged-up Allen Craig until the later innings. Besides him, this club doesn't flash much power against southpaws:

Possible Cardinals Starters vs. Left-Handed Pitching Since 2010
Batter PA HR BA ISO
Matt Adams 73 3 .208 .167
Carlos Beltran 547 29 .272 .260
Matt Carpenter 329 9 .284 .186
Daniel Descalso 247 2 .247 .096
David Freese 435 13 .318 .160
Matt Holliday 612 23 .310 .209
Jon Jay 465 3 .269 .077
Pete Kozma 172 0 .205 .093
Yadier Molina 510 15 .290 .168
Shane Robinson 193 2 .236 .073
Allen Craig 390 21 .302 .247

FanGraphs

Manager Mike Matheny doesn't have any decent options at shortstop or center field. Likewise, Adams will be of little value at first base so long as Lester is on the mound.

/Getty Images

No Cardinals regular has taken lefties deep at the same frequency Craig has in recent years. Beltran, the only one who comes close, was uncharacteristically ineffective in such situations throughout 2013.

All signs point to this being another smooth performance for Lester, with only Holliday and Molina posing legitimate threats.

Of course, Wainwright has proven all year that he can match zeroes with anybody for as many innings as the Cardinals need him to.

So what was this all about? 

Courtesy of MLB.com

Waino finished with five runs allowed and four strikeouts, the least impressive totals he's had in those categories since a Sept. 2 outing. It took him 95 pitches to get through five innings.

Here's what the 32-year-old had to say afterward, according to Anthony Gulizia of The Boston Globe:

I felt very out of synch tonight, unfortunately...It's something usually I can make adjustments on the fly a lot quicker than I was able to tonight. It’s pretty disappointing to do that on this stage.

It was difficult from the first pitch on. I didn't make it real tough on them. I threw a lot of balls out of the zone, no contest pitches, and a lot pitches up for them to hit. Kind of a perfect storm of pitching.

From those comments, we can gather that there was an issue with Wainwright's delivery. That surely contributed to his diminished fastball velocity:

Adam Wainwright's 2013 Postseason Game Log
Date Opponent IP ER FB Velocity
Oct. 3 Pittsburgh Pirates 7.0 1 93.69 mph
Oct. 9 Pittsburgh Pirates 9.0 1 94.25 mph
Oct. 14 Los Angeles Dodgers 7.0 2 93.05 mph
Oct. 23 Boston Red Sox 5.0 3 91.91 mph

Brooks Baseball

With an extra one or two miles per hour, the reliable right-hander could've gotten away with more mistakes. It's easier to upset batters' timing at the plate when there's a substantial difference in speeds between fastballs and secondary stuff.

However, there's no guarantee Waino will return to form Monday night. His 2013 workload has been among the heaviest of the past decade:

Most Innings Pitched in a Year, 2004-2013
Pitcher Year Total Innings (Regular Season and Postseason)
Chris Carpenter 2011 273.1
Roy Halladay 2010 272.2
Justin Verlander 2011 271.1
Adam Wainwright 2013 269.2
Roy Oswalt 2005 269.0

Baseball-Reference.com

And notice how the others on that list generally limped to the finish:

Most Innings Pitched in a Year, 2004-2013
Pitcher Year Regular-Season ERA ERA in Final Two Starts
Chris Carpenter 2011 3.45 2.77
Roy Halladay 2010 2.44 4.15
Justin Verlander 2011 2.40 5.56
Roy Oswalt 2005 2.94 4.15
Combined 2.80 4.11

Baseball-Reference.com

On the bright side, Wainwright historically excels against the players on Boston's roster. Even including the matchup earlier this series, he has limited them to a .189 batting average (17-for-90) and .582 OPS.

More stats from those who have faced Waino at least 10 times:

Red Sox Batters vs. Adam Wainwright (min. 10 PA)
Batter PA BA OBP SLG K
Shane Victorino 26 .200 .231 .260 2
Stephen Drew 23 .143 .217 .190 6
Jonny Gomes 14 .154 .214 .462 4
David Ross 14 .231 .286 .538 5

Baseball-Reference.com

There's a strong possibility all four will start for the Red Sox in Game 5. 

That scenario would give Wainwright tons of confidence, as Drew and Victorino—who is day to day with a nagging back injury, per Rob Bradford of WEEI.com—have both slumped miserably during the past two series. Ross, the only one who owns decent numbers against the Cardinals rotation leader, hasn't played on consecutive nights since early September. Attempting to do so might be counterproductive for the 36-year-old.

In his previous start, Wainwright threw about as many first-pitch strikes and total strikes as he did throughout his extraordinary regular season and postseason. The issue was that he left a few offerings above the belt, where the opposition could make solid contact. Mike Napoli's bases-clearing double and David Ortiz's near-grand slam both resulted from such pitches.

/Getty Images

Getting ahead in the count is crucial to Waino's success. Nearly one-third of all regular-season plate appearances he began 0-1 culminated in a strikeout. The helpless batters who found themselves in that predicament combined for a lousy .528 OPS (.799 OPS when count begins 1-0).

He should fearlessly aim over the plate when initiating new battles. According to Baseball-Reference.com, the Red Sox swing at the fewest first pitches in baseball.

Lester will almost certainly turn in an effective and lengthy effort. Meanwhile, Wainwright's performance hinges on whether Game 1 was an anomaly or the manifestation of fatigue.

 

Ely is a national MLB Featured Columnist for Bleacher Report and a sportscaster for 90.5 WVUM in Miami. He wants to make sweet, social love with all of you on Twitter.

 

Load More Stories

Follow B/R on Facebook

Out of Bounds

MLB

Subscribe Now

We will never share your email address

Thanks for signing up.