The Buffalo Bills have officially announced via Twitter that the team’s former practice squad quarterback Thad Lewis will get the start in Week 6 against the Cincinnati Bengals.
#Bills QB Thad Lewis will start for Buffalo against the Bengals— Buffalo Bills (@buffalobills) October 7, 2013
This news has fantasy owners of running backs CJ Spiller and Fred Jackson concerned.
While it was already tough enough trying to decipher how the team would split carries between the two backs week by week, the equation has become even more convoluted with an unproven player like Lewis taking the helm of the offense.
Lewis played in one game for the Cleveland Browns in 2012—throwing for 204 yards with one touchdown and one interception—and that lack of experience will force Buffalo to keep Sunday’s game plan simple.
Which player is the better fantasy option?
Fantasy owners should expect between 13-17 touches for each back—a mixture of receptions and carries for both versatile players—but the statistics will not be as impressive as they would have been with rookie EJ Manuel still under center.
With Manuel recovering from a knee injury that will keep him out of the lineup for several weeks, according to Lindsay H. Jones of USA Today, the game plan in Buffalo must shift to a more West Coast style built on short passes and running the ball effectively.
Of the two running backs featured for the Bills, the veteran Jackson will likely see his role increase the most. As the more consistent of the two, the more reliable on third downs and the more effective pass-blocker, Lewis will look to the calming force of Jackson early and often.
Spiller is still one of the most dynamic players in the NFL, but he needs to get the ball in open space to be at his most effective. With the Bengals focusing in on the short passes because of Lewis’ inexperience, Spiller won’t have a chance to breath on Sunday, let alone break off a huge run.
Jackson is also the more effective red-zone running back (the veteran has four touchdowns to Spiller’s one), but the team will give both men ample opportunities to shine.
With Spiller running for 66 yards on eight carries last week against Cleveland and Jackson amassing 17 carries for 53 yards and two touchdowns while adding four receptions for 40 yards, it’s clear that both men will be in for a heavy workload with Lewis under center.
It won’t be easy running on Cincinnati’s 11th-ranked rush defense, but each back will get enough touches on Sunday to warrant a fantasy start. As long as Lewis is the starting quarterback, expect Spiller and Jackson to carry most of the offensive workload.