Should Andrea Bargnani or Metta World Peace Start for NY Knicks in 2013-14?

Ciaran Gowan@@CiaranGowanContributor IIISeptember 27, 2013

TORONTO - JANUARY 24:  Ron Artest #37 of the Los Angeles Lakers looks to score against Andrea Bargnani #7 of the Toronto Raptors during the game on January 24, 2010 at Air Canada Centre in Toronto, Canada.  The Raptors won 106-105. NOTE TO USER: User expressly acknowledges and agrees that, by downloading and/or using this Photograph, user is consenting to the terms and conditions of the Getty Images License Agreement. Mandatory Copyright Notice: Copyright 2010 NBAE   (Photo by Andrew D. Bernstein/NBAE via Getty Images)
Andrew D. Bernstein/Getty Images

The New York Knicks have made some fantastic additions in the 2013 offseason, but the question of how they'll be used remains to be answered.

In all likelihood, the Knicks will be going with a new starting five this season, with the incoming Andrea Bargnani and Metta World Peace both competing for a forward spot alongside Carmelo Anthony.

Elsewhere on the court, we know Raymond Felton and Tyson Chandler will be starting at point guard and center, respectively, while Iman Shumpert is likely to move back to his natural shooting guard position, whether off the bench or as a starter.

The big question, however, is the second forward spot. We know New York can have success with small ball, but with much more depth at power forward and the worry of Anthony taking too much of a physical beating, the Knicks may go in a different direction in 2013-14.

There's a good argument to be made for either Bargnani or World Peace to play alongside Melo, so let's take a closer look to see who has the strongest case to start for New York.

The Case for Andrea Bargnani

Starting Melo at power forward has given the Knicks plenty of spacing on offense, but with the addition of Bargnani, they can now build a small ball-style offense without actually matching him up with bigger players.

Feb 13, 2013; New York, NY, USA; New York Knicks small forward Carmelo Anthony (7) attempts a shot over Toronto Raptors center Andrea Bargnani (7) during the second half at Madison Square Garden. The Raptors won the game 92-88. Mandatory Credit: Joe Campo
Joe Camporeale-USA TODAY Sports

Because of Bargnani's ability to spread the floor with his three-point shot, the Knicks should be able to play Melo in the post without clogging up the lane, much like they did last season.

The only major difference for New York will be Melo's matchup on the offensive end. As a 7-footer, Bargnani will likely be guarded by the opposition's power forward, leaving Anthony to work on a smaller player whom he'll physically dominate in the post.

Melo is faster than most power forwards and stronger than most small forwards, so as long as he has spacing, he'll find an advantage over just about anyone this side of LeBron James.

Defensively, both Anthony and Bargnani have poor reputations, but the former improved significantly this season. We should expect the same from "Il Mago" given time to work with coach Mike Woodson.

Having two 7-footers in the middle while still spacing the floor on offense is something most NBA teams can't do, so as long as Melo and Bargnani put in the work on defense, this lineup has the potential to cause some trouble around the league.

With that said, this does operate on the assumption that Bargnani can improve his play after a woeful past two seasons with the Toronto Raptors. He has played in only 66 games since the lockout due to injury and has shot only 30 percent from downtown, which won't help when it comes to spacing.

Clearly, this is the best team that Bargnani has ever been on, which will let him work as a role player rather than an offensive centerpiece. He'll have plenty more space to work with when Melo draws double-teams and finally has a real center behind him in Chandler to help out on the defensive end.

Bargnani is still young and has a chance to improveespecially now that he's had a change of scenerybut his recent struggles have kept him from being a lock for the starting job.

The Case for Metta World Peace

If Bargnani can improve his play defensively and start shooting at a higher percentage, he'd be the man for the job, but based on recent performance, starting World Peace makes the most sense.

LOS ANGELES, CA - DECEMBER 25:  Carmelo Anthony #7 of the New York Knicks and Metta World Peace #15 of the Los Angeles Lakers faceoff after the whistle during the NBA game at Staples Center on December 25, 2012 in Los Angeles, California. The Lakers defea
Victor Decolongon/Getty Images

While World Peace doesn't have Bargnani's height, he's capable of guarding both forward spots. He has earned a reputation as one of the league's best defenders over the last decade.

At the very least, his presence in the lineup gives New York the flexibility to put Melo on the opposition's weaker forward, leaving him more energy to work with on offense.

World Peace is limited offensively, but the Knicks aren't in need of a major scorer here. All they need is someone who can consistently hit an open three-point shot, which he's capable of doing. Over the last five seasons, he has shot 36 percent from beyond the arc, which is the same as Bargnani's career percentage.

In other words, although Bargnani has higher upside, these two are evenly matched in terms of what they bring to the table. World Peace provides more flexibility on defense, while Bargnani has a more diverse offensive game.

One other factor to consider, though, is how the second unit will look depending on who starts, If World Peace starts, the Knicks will have Bargnani, Amar'e Stoudemire, Kenyon Martin and Jeremy Tyler—all natural power forwards—competing for minutes off the bench.

If Bargnani starts, the bench frontcourt will be relatively clear-cut. World Peace will play at small forward and Martin will play at power forward, while Stoudemire will play at center with Tyler taking over when he needs rest.

The Verdict

Unless Bargnani comes into camp playing as well as he did between 2008 and 2010 with improved defense, there's no need for the Knicks to commit to a starter just yet.

Both players spread the floor fairly well and can help to reduce Melo's injury risk, so it makes sense to let them compete in camp or even change the lineup situationally based on whether the team needs extra offense or defense.

Considering the injury history of certain players in the frontcourt, the Knicks could definitely use this kind of flexibility. It'll also stop them from becoming too predictable and instead allow them to exploit different match ups on a game-to-game basis.


    Miles Bridges Is on the Come-Up

    NBA logo

    Miles Bridges Is on the Come-Up

    Yaron Weitzman
    via Bleacher Report

    Does Melvin Frazier Fit with the Knicks

    New York Knicks logo
    New York Knicks

    Does Melvin Frazier Fit with the Knicks

    Posting and Toasting
    via Posting and Toasting

    Knicks’ London return comes with Porzingis question

    New York Knicks logo
    New York Knicks

    Knicks’ London return comes with Porzingis question

    New York Post
    via New York Post

    Swaggy Wants to See Cocaine Legalized

    NBA logo

    Swaggy Wants to See Cocaine Legalized

    Adam Wells
    via Bleacher Report