College Football Rankings 2013 Week 5: Teams That Deserve Higher Spot in Top 25

Use your ← → (arrow) keys to browse more stories
College Football Rankings 2013 Week 5: Teams That Deserve Higher Spot in Top 25
Andrew Weber-USA TODAY Sports

Thank goodness a playoff is coming, because the most recent AP Poll looks like it will cause some major problems down the line.

Right now, the poll is in that weird place where it has to balance its preseason rankings with the results on the field. Teams are dropping two or three spots despite not having lost yet.

If you're going to have a preseason poll in the first place, it doesn't make a lot of sense to drop a Top Five team too far when it's still undefeated.

If you want to base the polls off results, why have a preseason poll in the first place? You'd get a more accurate picture of the college football landscape after six or seven weeks.

However, this is the best college football has, so we have to make the best of what we've got.

Here's the AP Top 25, followed by three teams that should feel hard done by the voters in the most recent poll.

AP Top 25—Week 5
Rank Team Record Points LW
1 Alabama 3-0 1,496 1
2 Oregon 3-0 1.418 2
3 Clemson 3-0 1,340 3
4 Ohio State 4-0 1,320 4
5 Stanford 3-0 1,270 5
6 LSU 4-0 1,167 6
7 Louisville 4-0 1,088 7
8 Florida State 3-0 1,049 8
9 Georgia 2-1 1,029 9
10 Texas A&M 3-1 1,011 10
11 Oklahoma State 3-0 849 11
12 South Carolina 2-1 828 12
13 UCLA 3-0 798 13
14 Oklahoma 3-0 689 14
15 Miami (FL) 3-0 687 16
16 Washington 3-0 559 17
17 Northwestern 4-0 477 18
18 Michigan 4-0 450 15
19 Baylor 3-0 3-0 20
20 Florida 2-1 414 19
21 Ole Miss 3-0 342 21
22 Notre Dame 3-1 256 22
23 Wisconsin 3-1 130 24
24 Texas Tech 4-0 127 25
25 Fresno State 3-0 110 NR

ESPN.com

 

Ohio State Buckeyes

Greg Bartram-USA TODAY Sports

How in the world did this happen? How did the Ohio State Buckeyes drop two spots without actually losing a game or really even coming close to losing?

Where should Ohio State be ranked?

Submit Vote vote to see results

The Bucks went from No. 2 to No. 3 in Week 2 and then from No. 3 to No. 4 in Week 3. Putting Oregon in the second spot is one thing, but having Clemson jump ahead of the Buckeyes is a bit of a stretch.

Sure, Ohio State hasn't really beaten a team close to the caliber of Georgia, like the Tigers have. But this is a team that went 12-0 last season and remains unbeaten in 2013. It also won its last two games without its best player.

The Buckeyes can only beat the teams that are put in front of them, and they've done so in convincing fashion.

Clemson deserved to rise in the rankings after beating the Bulldogsand it did, jumping from fourth to eighth in the Week 2 poll. And then it jumped again. To have Clemson move ahead of OSU off of wins against South Carolina State and NC State is a bit too much.

 

UCLA Bruins

Richard Mackson-USA TODAY Sports

When you get past the Top 10, it's hard to sort out which teams are better than others. You've got so many teams with 4-0 or 3-0 records and just about equal resumes. Then there are the South Carolina Gamecocks, whose only loss came against the Georgia Bulldogs.

With that said, it's hard to see how the UCLA Bruins are ranked No. 13. Their wins against Nevada and New Mexico State are pretty much meaningless. They won handily, just as you would have expected them to.

The difference between the Bruins and some of the teams around them is that they went into enemy territory and walked away with a 20-point win. Nebraska might have fallen out of the Top 25, but it's not easy to walk into Lincoln and come back from 18 points down and score 38 unanswered points.

If anything, swapping UCLA with Oklahoma State makes the most sense.

 

Arizona State Sun Devils

Bob Stanton-USA TODAY Sports

The Arizona State Sun Devils have reason to feel aggrieved. They lost their spot in the Top 25 after a loss to No. 5 Stanford. It wasn't an embarrassing loss, and it's understandable that some voters might have them drop out of the poll.

What seems a bit off is that Wisconsin is ranked No. 23.

The Badgers fell 32-30 to the Sun Devils on Sept. 14. So a team that already beat Wisconsinand has the same number of lossesis ranked behind the Badgers. Who cares if the game ended in a bit of controversy? That play alone didn't decide the outcome of the game.

Arizona State's biggest mistake was losing to what should be one of the best teams in the country.

It must be the wins against Massachusetts and Tennessee Tech that make the difference for Wisconsin.

Load More Stories

Follow B/R on Facebook

Out of Bounds

College Football

Subscribe Now

We will never share your email address

Thanks for signing up.