MLB Trade Deadline 2013: Twitter Reaction and Analysis

Tyler ConwayFeatured ColumnistJuly 31, 2013

Jul 3, 2013; Houston, TX, USA; Houston Astros starting pitcher Bud Norris (20) pitches during the fourth inning against the Tampa Bay Rays at Minute Maid Park. Mandatory Credit: Troy Taormina-USA TODAY Sports
Troy Taormina-USA TODAY Sports

A yearly staple of player movement, pennant-changing risks and rampant excitement across the entire sport, the 2013 MLB non-waiver trade deadline finally passed at 4 p.m. ET on Wednesday. 

Only you wouldn't have known it without looking at the calendar. While there were plenty of rumors and innuendo passed along over the past few days and weeks, this year's deadline was more notable for the moves that didn't happen than the ones that did.

The Philadelphia Phillies kept their entire roster. The New York Yankees did nothing in the last few days to make a late surge for an American League playoff spot. Across the league, sellers weren't selling and buyers weren't offering enough to make teams on the fence think twice. Perhaps the best descriptive quote of the day's activity and the overall feeling of the deadline came from San Francisco Giants general manager Brian Sabean, who spoke with the San Francisco Chronicle's Henry Schulman:

Although there weren't many moves—or many substantial offers from what we can gather—that only means the reaction was heightened around those deals that did get done. The day may have been a disappointment for fans hoping for a fantasy draft-like feel, but the lack of trades allowed for analysis, depth and even the occasional snarky comment.

OK, Twitter was full of mostly just snarky comments. But regardless, let's take a look around baseball's biggest day of player movement, checking in on the afternoon's most notable social media movements.


Red Sox Start Deadline by Landing Peavy While Everyone Sleeps

While the deal didn't technically get done on deadline day, we're going to give the Boston Red Sox acquisition of Jake Peavy an honorary pass into the discussion. After all, Boston's Twitter account didn't officially announce the seven-player, three-team deal until 11:55 p.m. ET:

The Red Sox landed Peavy from the Chicago White Sox in the deal, sending breakout infielder Jose Iglesias to Detroit and three prospects (flamethrower Francelis Montas, right-handed pitcher J.B. Wendelken and infielder Cleuluis Rondon) to the South Side.

ESPN Stats & Info had a great stat on Peavy, which had to make Boston fans feel better about losing Iglesias:

Only for ESPN's Buster Olney to twist the knife a bit:

On the bright side, not all of Boston's top prospects found themselves headed elsewhere. Red Sox minor league stud Jackie Bradley was pulled last Tuesday night amid the trade rumors, leaving fans everywhere worried he was the principal in the Peavy deal. Grantland's Bill Barnwell was likely pleased:

Either way, losing Iglesias stings. Not only did he garner Omar Vizquel comparisons, he also filled a potential long-term shortstop answer for the Red Sox—one they've struggled to find an answer to in recent years. Danny Knobler of CBS Sports noted that many scouts were quick to declare Detroit a major winner for landing the 23-year-old infielder:


Padres Take a Flier on Ian Kennedy

A year ago at this time, Ian Kennedy's name being on the trade block may have caused as much fervor as Peavy's. The 28-year-old righty was 16th among all pitchers with a combined 7.9 WAR from 2011 through 2012, putting him just a notch above a certain player whose socks switched colors late Tuesday night.

However, Kennedy's effectiveness took a downward spiral in 2013. He's 3-8 on the season with a 5.28 ERA and 1.42 WHIP, all of which ranked him among the bottom-feeders in the Arizona Diamondbacks' rotation. So it was understandable that Arizona moved quickly to send him elsewhere—even if it was to a team inside its division.

Corey Brock of was the first to note Kennedy was traded to the San Diego Padres in exchange for left-handed reliever Joe Thatcher, Double-A righty Matt Stites and a future draft choice:

While some were skeptical about the Padres' line of thought—they're not contending this year—Grantland's Jonah Keri thought it was a worthwhile chance to take:

Bleacher Report's Zach Rymer co-signed that sentiment, noting a return to form for Kennedy could be possible in 2014:

How about a little political humor to go with your trade deadline stew? Peter Botte of the New York Daily News has that for you in spades, though we doubt he'll ever get his wish:

Meanwhile, the underrated portion of the trade deadline is the effect these swaps have in the locker room. Arizona pitcher Daniel Hudson has been Kennedy's teammate for each of his seasons with the D'Backs and sent out a melancholic picture to express his disappointment:


Orioles Land Bud Norris

Once it became clear the Philadelphia Phillies weren't parting ways with Cliff Lee, the Houston Astros were instantly in pole position. They had Bud Norris dangling on the open market as the top available pitcher, with plenty of teams needing help in the rotation.

Unsurprisingly, the Baltimore Orioles became an obvious landing spot. They are 26th in team ERA heading into Wednesday night's action, and they needed an upgrade to keep the final AL wild-card spot. So Houston and Baltimore worked tirelessly throughout the day to consummate a deal, with word finally coming down with about an hour to go that Norris would be headed to Maryland.

Dan Connolly of the Baltimore Sun was the first to come through with details of the deal:

Norris superficially looks like a good pickup. He's 6-9 on the season but has a 3.93 ERA, a rate that his FIP backs up. Unfortunately for the Orioles, they'll be asking him to pitch outside of Houston—something ESPN Stats & Info points out he's struggled to do:

Hoes, meanwhile, will be making his professional debut against Baltimore. Steve Melewski of noted that the 23-year-old outfielder felt weird about already playing his former team:


Soo...That's It?

Do you all realize why we snuck Peavy in under the wire now? While July 31 was expected by most to be more quiet than most years, few expected almost complete silence throughout the day.

Then again, the deadline is never quite over at exactly 4 p.m. When Jayson Stark of ESPN reported a last-minute trade had come through the wire and it involved the Los Angeles Dodgers, some folks thought salvation was on the way. 

Nope. Los Angeles and Minnesota agreed on a deal for catcher Drew Butera, a 29-year-old career .182 hitter who has exactly three at-bats for the Twins this season:

That deal may be the perfect microcosm of what was a completely shrug-worthy Wednesday afternoon. As one would expect, the Twitter hounds were out in full force to mock a deadline that could have passed as your average run-of-the-mill hump day:

And with that folks, your MLB trade deadline has come to pass. Overall it was a day filled with excitement, rapid player movement and—oh never mind. You all are smarter than that. I'm going to take a nap.


Follow Tyler Conway on Twitter: