MLB Trade Deadline: Pros and Cons of Oakland A's Pursuit of Jake Peavy

D.J. O'ConnorSenior Analyst IIIJuly 26, 2013

CLEVELAND, OH - APRIL 14:  Starting pitcher Jake Peavy #44 of the Chicago White Sox pitches during the first inning against the Cleveland Indians at Progressive Field on April 14, 2013 in Cleveland, Ohio. (Photo by Jason Miller/Getty Images)
Jason Miller/Getty Images

With less than a week until the MLB trade deadline, it was reported by CSN Bay Area that the Oakland A's are interested in acquiring Jake Peavy from the Chicago White Sox.  Oakland's interest in Peavy could just be a knee-jerk reaction to the division-rival Texas Rangers acquiring Matt Garza from the White Sox's geographic rival, the Chicago Cubs.

According to the report, the A's interest revolved around Oakland having one scout watching Peavy in a game, which is nothing unusual.  However, if the A's are seriously interested in acquiring Peavy, we should consider the pros and cons of Oakland pulling off the trade.



Peavy is regarded as one of the game's best starting pitchers.  His record is 7-4 with a 4.19 ERA, but with the way some of Oakland's younger pitchers have been starting to slip, like Dan Straily against the Angels, Peavy would be a great addition to the starting rotation.

Upon the return of a healthy Brett Anderson, the A's would be able to have a playoff rotation consisting of Anderson, Peavy and All-Star Bartolo Colon in any order for a trio of quality starters that the A's haven't seen since Barry Zito, Mark Mulder and Tim Hudson.

Peavy is under contract for 2014 as well so he would be unlike many other trade targets in that he wouldn't just be a three-month rental, such as a player like Chase Utley would be.



As with any trade the A's would make to build up their roster for a playoff run, the price would be high to land Peavy.  The A's are looking at giving up some quality prospects to land Peavy.  With the A's and their low payroll, prospects are far more important to them than any other team because of their inability to sign superstars in free agency.

The A's do need to upgrade via trades, so some prospects have to be sacrificed for the sake of making more noise this year in October.  Oakland has higher priorities than pitching though.  Second-base anyone?  The A's could survive in October with Anderson, Colon and any of their other young pitchers like Jarrod Parker, Tommy Milone or maybe even Sonny Gray stepping up their game.

While it was a positive that Peavy is signed through next year, it is a negative that his contract is worth up to $29 million for this year and 2014.  Once that already expensive contract is up next year, then the A's likely will watch him leave and Peavy would have been a rental after all.