Adjusted Best-Case/Worst-Case Comparisons for Every All-NBA Rookie

Daniel O'Brien@@DanielO_BRFeatured ColumnistMay 15, 2013

Mar 20, 2013; New Orleans, LA, USA; New Orleans Hornets power forward Anthony Davis (23) rebounds over Boston Celtics center Kevin Garnett (5) during the first quarter of a game at the New Orleans Arena. Mandatory Credit: Derick E. Hingle-USA TODAY Sports
Derick Hingle-USA TODAY Sports

The NBA has unveiled its 2012-13 All-Rookie Team, and it's a collection of highly-talented youngsters with tremendous potential for brilliant pro careers.

Damian Lillard led the way as the only unanimous selection by the NBA's coaches, and the First Team was rounded out by Anthony Davis, Bradley Beal, Dion Waiters and Harrison Barnes.

Most of these guys either met or exceeded the expectations set for them prior to their rookie campaigns. However, some of their careers are taking a different shape than we might have anticipated.

It's time to give the best and worst-case pro comparisons for each premiere NBA newcomer.


Dion Waiters

Stats: 14.7 PPG, 3.0 APG, 41% FG

As the starting shooting guard for the Cleveland Cavaliers, Waiters proved to be an exciting playmaker and a capable sidekick to Kyrie Irving.

Injuries interrupted his campaign a couple times, but he still showed enough firepower to be considered one of the best rookies in the Eastern Conference.

Moving forward, he could be a top-tier wing with the ability to facilitate and create for his teammates.

Best Case: James Harden

Waiters should be flattered by this comparison, because Harden is an elite playmaker.

The Cavs' promising youth has the potential to be a good, but not great three-point shooter, much like the bearded Houston Rocket. If Waiters irons out his mechanics, he can increase his triple percentage from 31 percent to a more Harden-like 37.

The greatest similarities between these two are their knack for strong slashes to the paint while also being capable passers.

Defensively, Waiters can replicate the kind of quick, physical and opportunistic stoppage Harden exhibits.

Worst Case: Rodney Stuckey

If Waiters fails to develop offensively, his shooting numbers could remain similar to Stuckey's: hovering right around 40 percent from the field and 30 percent from distance.

Both have combo-guard tools, and both are secondary scoring options on their respective teams.

Stuckey is a dangerous, creative player, but Waiters' impact will be similar only if he regresses substantially in his sophomore and third seasons.


Harrison Barnes

Stats: 9.2 PPG, 4.1 RPG, 44% FG

In a revamped Golden State Warriors' lineup, Harrison Barnes held his own as a critical swingman who could stretch the floor with his shot and defend almost any forward.

The North Carolina product went from a peripheral role player in the regular season to a game-changing x-factor in the playoffs.

Best Case: Paul Pierce

After watching his two-year college career, it seemed like it would be a stretch to consider Pierce as a possible ceiling for Barnes.

At this point it's realistic, as Barnes' ball skills have flourished in the NBA, and his shot-making ability could make for an All-Star caliber career.

His 36 percent three-point shooting in the regular season will likely rise to meet Pierce's career 37 percent, and his play-making abilities could reach Pierce's neighborhood.

Barnes is a noticeably better athlete, and Pierce is a better ball-handler, but the two may have similar bodies of work once Harrison's career is over.

Worst Case: Poor-man's Caron Butler

Barnes' recent outburst of back-to-back 25 point games in the playoffs make it difficult to see him descending below Caron Butler's level in his career.

Butler averaged more than 15 points per game nine times in his career, and eclipsed 20 a couple of times, but he played in just one All-Star Game. 

Barnes seems headed for more than that, especially defensively, although a Butler-like career isn't unimaginable.


Bradley Beal

Stats: 13.9 PPG, 2.4 APG, 41% FG

When John Wall returned to the Washington Wizards' lineup in January, he brought out the best in Bradley Beal as a rookie.

The 6'3" shooter displayed his lethal shooting touch, but also demonstrated a healthy dose of all-around skills, including defense, slashing and passing.

His sensational April included 17.5 points per game and 42 percent shooting from downtown.

Best Case: Ray Allen/Eric Gordon hybrid

If that doesn't sound dangerous, I don't know what does.

Beal has the wherewithal to liken himself to the game's best shooter (Allen), along with one of the great crafty young playmakers (Gordon).

In his prime, Allen could dish four to five assist per night, which is the kind of facilitating Beal could provide in addition to accurate long-range offense.

Worst Case: More athletic Randy Foye

If Beal's rookie campaign somehow ends up being one of his better seasons, he would become a rich-man's version of Randy Foye.

Foye has enjoyed a couple of solid outside shooting seasons above 40 percent from deep, and he's a decent passer. But he is a relatively unspectacular player, and not someone to lean on for massive production.

All signs point to Beal trending toward stardom, but he could get hampered into mediocrity if injuries persist.


Anthony Davis

Stats: 13.5 PPG, 8.2 RPG, 52% FG

The league's No. 1 selection in 2012, Davis worked through knee troubles to develop into a versatile post player.

His mid-range shooting is more than respectable, he's got a great nose for the ball and his collegiate defensive prowess translated to the pro game.

Davis has a superb feel for the game, and it's only going to get better.

Best Case: Kevin Garnett

Davis has a long way to go to reach Big Ticket status, but the necessary tools are attainable.

He already has the lob wide receiver skills much like Garnett, along with the defensive emphasis, length and mobility.

If his pivot moves, post toughness and jump shot improve over the next couple seasons, a Garnett-like power forward will be patrolling the New Orleans Hornets paint.

Worst Case: Larry Sanders

From a defense and rebounding standpoint, Davis and Sanders are similar. Both have tremendous wingspans and a nose for the ball.

Davis projects to be a smoother, better offensive player than Sanders, but if he doesn't develop as expected, he could end up being a slightly worse shot-blocker and rebounder.

It's a testament to Davis' potential that eight or nine rebounds per game would be a worst-case career mark.


Damian Lillard

Stats: 19.0 PPG, 6.5 APG, 43% FG

The 2012 NBA Rookie of the Year went from mid-major playmaker to professional standout in a matter of months.

With poise and confidence, Lillard helped LaMarcus Aldridge lead the Portland Trail Blazers back to relevance, even if they fizzled late.

His silky-smooth combination of scoring and passing gave him the ROY upper hand all year. The production immediately put him on the "elite point guard" radar for the near future.

Best Case: Chris Paul/Stephen Curry hybrid

Chris Paul averaged 7.8 assists in his rookie year, so it's going to be tough for Lillard to match that kind of pace moving forward.

Lillard also won't likely reach Curry's exceptional shooting (45 percent career from deep), but his ability to get off a smooth shot is similar. They also both went to mid-major schools:

When you think of Lillard's combination of the two duties, he could be a slightly inferior version of this hybrid.

Worst Case: Jeff Teague

Jeff Teague is an above-average, but not All-Star caliber point guard.

Sixteen points, seven assists and 36 percent three-point shooting is solid, playoff floor general material. But it's on the low end of the spectrum of Lillard's potential.

If defenses force him into helter-skelter plays and he never makes the playoffs, it's not impossible that Lillard could be remembered more as a "starter" than a "superstar."


Follow me on Twitter for more hoops analysis: @DanielO_BR


    Realistic FA Targets for Eliminated Playoff Teams

    NBA logo

    Realistic FA Targets for Eliminated Playoff Teams

    Grant Hughes
    via Bleacher Report

    Klay Guarantees He'll 'Be Better' in Game 3

    NBA logo

    Klay Guarantees He'll 'Be Better' in Game 3

    Mike Chiari
    via Bleacher Report

    Draymond: 'Now It's Time to Lock In'

    NBA logo

    Draymond: 'Now It's Time to Lock In'

    Joseph Zucker
    via Bleacher Report

    Jaylen Brown 'Ready to Fight' in Game 4 vs. Cavs

    NBA logo

    Jaylen Brown 'Ready to Fight' in Game 4 vs. Cavs

    Joseph Zucker
    via Bleacher Report