2013 NFL Draft Analysis: Rounding Up Experts' Thoughts

Tim KeeneyContributor IApril 26, 2013

NEW YORK, NY - APRIL 25:  Eric Fisher (R) of Central Michigan Chippewas stands on stage with NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell after Fisher was picked #1 overall by the Kansas City Chiefs in the first round of the 2013 NFL Draft at Radio City Music Hall on April 25, 2013 in New York City.  (Photo by Al Bello/Getty Images)
Al Bello/Getty Images

The first round of the 2013 NFL draft did not disappoint. 

During the days, weeks and even months leading up to anticipated event, we heard about the unpredictability. About how there was no clear No. 1 pick. About how players were going to fall and teams were going to reach further than we could even comprehend.

About how we should expect the unexpected. 

And ironically enough, the unpredictability all went according to plan, as shocking picks and trades ruled Thursday night. Let's take a look at how the experts reacted. 


No. 1

Most believed Luke Joeckel was going to be the posterboy of the Andy Reid era in Kansas City, but the Chiefs went a different direction, with the "other" offensive tackle, Eric Fisher.

NFL.com's Bucky Brooks tried to explain it:

As ESPN's Bill Williamson points out, the Joeckel and Fisher—who will likely be compared to each other for the rest of their careers—will see each other right off the bat when Kansas City takes on the Jacksonville Jaguars:

The run on offensive tackles continued at pick No. 4, where the Philadelphia Eagles selected Lane Johnson (via Brian Billick):


Steal of the Draft

It has to go to the Minnesota Vikings, for landing defensive tackle Sharrif Floyd—yeah, the same guy who you saw at No. 3 in many of the mock drafts—at No. 23 overall. 

ESPN's Todd McShay sums it up (via SportsCenter):

Floyd was the third defensive tackle off the board, following Sheldon Richardson and Star Lotulelei—who was also a bit of a steal at No. 14 to the Carolina Panthers—and the Vikings had to be shocked to see him still on the board.

While we're on the subject, Minnesota had itself quite a night. It no longer has a pick on Friday after dealing with the New England Patriots, but it pulled in Floyd, Xavier Rhodes and Cordarrelle Patterson with three choices in the 20s.

Not a bad start for new GM Rick Spielman (via NFL.com's Gregg Rosenthal):

This Vikings draft haul will help define the Spielman era. They stopped Sharrif Floyd's draft free fall. They picked up Florida State cornerback Xavier Rhodes. And they took a big risk giving up four picks for Patterson.


Reach of the Draft

One quarterback was selected in the first round. It wasn't Geno Smith. It wasn't Ryan Nassib. It wasn't Matt Barkley.

It was EJ Manuel.

NFL.com's Chris Wesseling discusses the, um, interesting decision by the Buffalo Bills:

It makes sense for the Bills to roll the dice on a quarterback with a high ceiling, but Manuel doesn't come without question marks. His accuracy was inconsistent and his footwork spotty with the Seminoles. He may have to sit behind Kevin Kolb or Tarvaris Jackson while Marrone tutors him as a rookie. In other words, Manuel is more of a project than recent first-round picks.

There's no question that Manuel has the skill set to be a superstar. But as a risky project with plenty of question marks, you have to wonder if the Bills could have landed him a little later.

Essentially, this (via FOX Sports' Jay Clemons):


Draft-Day Trades

Everyone loves a good draft-day trade, and as NFL.com points out, there were a whopping five of them on Thursday night. It wasn't 2012-esque, but there still some wild and crazy action.

Perhaps the most surprising was the deal between the Miami Dolphins and Oakland Raiders, not because of the teams involved, but because of the players selected (via NFL.com's Ian Rapaport):

The Raiders then took Houston cornerback D.J. Hayden with the No. 12 pick. It was rumored that they were enthralled with the young man, whose comeback story should inspire all of us, but many still felt it was too early. 


Best Available

It was a wild night, but we've got two more rounds fast approaching on Friday night. Rotoworld's Evan Silva takes a look at the best players who had a disappointing first round:

Geno Smith, of course, will one the most highly discussed names. The Jaguars, Eagles, Cardinals and Jets could all be in play for the former top-pick candidate, so don't expect him to drop much further.