Pros and Cons of the 2013 NFL Free Agent Class

Alex Dunlap@AlexDunlapNFLContributor IFebruary 8, 2013

Pros and Cons of the 2013 NFL Free Agent Class

0 of 7

    As we turn our sights to the 2013 NFL free agency period, the top free agents are easy to identify.

    This free agency class is like a sprawling used-car lot, there are some sleek corvettes—and there are some real lemons.

    The shiniest toys will have their paperwork done by their original owners long before anyone else can take a peek under the hood. Free agents like Joe Flacco will be locked down before the gates even open to the general public.

    Others will not have this luxury.

    Others will have to put themselves out there and have their values tested on the open market. They will have their tires kicked, their hoods popped and their entire bodies of work test-driven.

    New owners are looking for pro and for cons. New owners are searching for value. Here we look over the free agent class by positional grouping, and we'll do the same.

    (Updated free agent player lists courtesy of Nick Mensio,   

PRO: The Wide Receivers

1 of 7

    The wide receivers that will be coming available via free agency in 2013 look like an all-star cast.

    Players like Mike Wallace, Dwayne Bowe, Wes Welker and Greg Jennings headline the list.

    That's a lot of potential upside.

    Bowe has proven that he is capable of pulling off 1,100-yard, 15-touchdown seasons and is entering what should be the prime of his career at 28, given the proper surrounding cast.

    The best-case scenario for Bowe would be to line up opposite A.J. Green in Cincinnati. The Bengals will have around $55.1 million burning a hole in their pockets, thanks to the new 2013 "salary floor" under the new CBA. The Bengals need to make a splash.

    Greg Jennings would be an excellent addition in Miami, who will hopefully be re-signing a free agent of their own in Brian Hartline.

    Wes Welker is likely to get the franchise tag in New England, and while Mike Wallace would make sense to keep in Pittsburgh, it feels like his days as a Steeler have been numbered since he started complaining about his contract. The re-negotiation of Antonio Brown's deal in the middle of Wallace's temper tantrum should tell fans all they need to know about how Steelers conduct their business.

    Here is the rest of the group, thanks to Nick Mensio at Rotoworld:

    Danny Amendola

    Julian Edelman

    Donnie Avery

    Terrell Owens

    Jerome Simpson

    Kevin Ogletree

    Randy Moss

    Braylon Edwards

    Austin Collie

    Josh Cribbs

    Domenik Hixon

    Ramses Barden

    Jabar Gaffney

    Brandon Stokley

    Brandon Gibson

    Plaxico Burress

    Mohamed Massaquoi

    Johnny Knox

    Chad Johnson

    Deion Branch

    Mark Clayton

    Donte' Stallworth

    Brandon Tate

    Ted Ginn

    Devery Henderson

    Louis Murphy

    Derek Hagan

    Chaz Schilens

    Sammie Stroughter

    Steve Smith (STL)

    Devin Aromashodu

    Adrian Arrington

    Courtney Roby

    Jason Hill

    Greg Camarillo

    Kassim Osgood

    Roscoe Parrish

    Mike Williams (SEA)

    Lee Evans

    Micheal Spurlock

    Mike Sims-Walker

    Legedu Naanee

    Ruvell Martin

CON: The Quarterbacks

2 of 7

    When Matt Moore and Jason Campbell are gems, it is a terrible year for QBs in free agency 

    Joe Flacco is technically a free agent, but there is absolutely no way he is going anywhere. The Ravens will either re-negotiate his deal or slap a franchise tag on him. GM Ozzie Newsome has to decide whether the organization should just bite the bullet and re-structure for the reported $20+ million Flacco is seeking or save the team $6 to $7 million by franchising Flacco, making the QB prove 2012 was no fluke.

    Remember, Flacco was a mediocre regular-season QB in 2012 before catching fire in the playoffs. Making him the highest-paid player in football is no small commitment.

    When looking over the QBs who are available, it's easy to wonder if half these guys are still even in the league, making for a sticky situation for QB-needy teams.

    Ultimately, The 2013 NFL draft class of QBs is a crapshoot.

    With no one prospect emerging from a pack of 6-7 players behind Geno Smith, these teams may be wise to build in other areas and (gulp) bring in one of these guys as a one-year scab.

    Matt Moore

    Tarvaris Jackson

    Jason Campbell

    David Garrard

    Josh Johnson

    Byron Leftwich

    Brady Quinn

    Vince Young

    Matt Leinart

    Rex Grossman

    David Carr

    Derek Anderson

    Drew Stanton

    Chase Daniel

    Brian Hoyer

    Charlie Batch

    Bruce Gradkowski

    Kellen Clemens

    Tyler Thigpen

    Josh McCown

    Sage Rosenfels

    Seneca Wallace

    Donovan McNabb

    A.J. Feeley

    Troy Smith

    Luke McCown

    Chris Redman

    John Beck

    Jordan Palmer

    J.P. Losman

    Kevin O'Connell

PRO: The Running Backs

3 of 7

    St. Louis RB Steven Jackson headlines a decent crop of good plug-and-play RB veterans scheduled to hit free agency.

    Jackson is not technically a free agent, but since he has a player option on his contract in his final year, it is up to him to decide if he would like to accept the $7 million option before March 12 or enter the free market.

    Jackson is still undecided according to the St. Louis Post-Dispatch.

    “We’re going to sit down this next coming month, in February. Both sides have been very classy about how they’ve handled the situation. We’re going to talk about my possibilities, where I want to go, and does it fit? I believe we’ll get everything resolved before March.”

    Jackson would be wise to take less in order to work out a long-term deal.

    Reggie Bush, another player scheduled to hit the open market, only got a $10 million deal two years ago and is not expected to earn more than that this go-round. Being in your late twenties at running back is different than being that age as a wide receiver or QB.

    In other words, Reggie and S-Jax are getting too old for a raise.

    If Jackson can lock up a deal to keep him in St. Louis, it is safe to say that his agent, Eugene Parker, may advise taking the Rams up on the offer.

    Ahmad Bradshaw is a new addition to the market and should draw interest from numerous teams despite having a foot made of metal rods and Frankenstein screws. Green Bay would be a terrific destination, as the Packers need a running back and feature an offense that thrives when their runner gets around 18 carries a game. This could lead to Bradshaw playing "fresh" for the first time in many seasons.

    As for the rest of the class:

    Rashard Mendenhall

    Cedric Benson

    Shonn Greene

    Bernard Scott

    Felix Jones

    Peyton Hillis

    Brandon Jacobs

    Danny Woodhead

    Cedric Peerman

    Rashad Jennings

    La'Rod Stephens-Howling

    Justin Forsett

    Javon Ringer

    Ronnie Brown

    Tim Hightower

    Chris Rainey

    Kevin Smith

    Brian Leonard

    Mike Goodson

    Jalen Parmele

    Ryan Grant

    Steve Slaton

    Thomas Jones

    Joseph Addai

    Mewelde Moore

    Cadillac Williams

    Jackie Battle

    Kahlil Bell

    Tashard Choice

    Brandon Jackson

    Stefan Logan

    Jerome Harrison

    Tyrell Sutton

    Darius Reynaud

    Kregg Lumpkin

CON: The Guards

4 of 7

    All-star Offensive guards usually aren't household names, even to the biggest NFL fans, and this group is no all-star team.

    The obvious headliner is Andy Levitre, who has been a huge part of the Bills' success running the ball and a key cog in the middle of their offensive line. He'll command one the more lucrative deals on the free agent market in 2013, despite the fact that NFL teams do not like to overspend on interior offensive line.

    Brandon Moore of the Jets is underrated but no spring chicken at age 33. It will be interesting to see whether the Jets are smart enough to try and re-sign him, despite their terrible cap situation.

    While there is a wealth of abundance along the interior of the offensive line in the 2013 NFL draft, more than a few of these guys won't have NFL jobs in 2013.

    Donald Thomas

    Louis Vasquez

    Lance Louis

    Eben Britton

    Jake Scott

    Ramon Foster

    Kevin Boothe

    Geoff Schwartz

    Matt Slauson

    Stephen Peterman

    Leroy Harris

    Tyronne Green

    Chad Rinehart

    Garrett Reynolds

    Mike Pollak

    Deuce Lutui

    Kory Lichtensteiger

    Antoine Caldwell

    Chilo Rachal

    Nate Garner

    Chris Spencer

    Rex Hadnot

    Vince Manuwai

    Rob Turner

    Chris Williams

    Leonard Davis

    Jeremy Bridges

PRO: The Tight Ends

5 of 7

    Tight end is the most stacked group in free agency, which is music to the ears of teams such as the Atlanta Falcons.

    Fred Davis is an athletic playmaker that could be a star if he cleans up his act off the field.

    Dustin Keller has been under-utilized his entire career, due to the horrible play of Mark Sanchez.

    Jared Cook is arguably one of the NFL's most freakish athletes but never seemed to find a real spot in Tennessee.

    Martellus Bennett was once thought of as a blocking TE before joining the Giants, where coach Mike Pope used him as a red-zone receiving threat.

    Brandon Myers was a godsend in 2012 for the Raiders and had the most receptions of any receiver on the team.

    James Casey looked like the Texans "Aaron Hernandez" during preseason camp, but wasn't even part of many game plans.

    On top of those guys, there are even more big names on the TE list.

    Fred Davis

    Dallas Clark

    Ben Watson

    Anthony Fasano

    Delanie Walker

    Kellen Winslow

    Todd Heap

    Jeremy Shockey

    Visanthe Shiancoe

    Chris Cooley

    Dante Rosario

    Travis Beckum

    Alex Smith

    Cameron Morrah

    Leonard Pope

    Billy Bajema

    Gary Barnidge

    John Phillips

    Will Heller

CON: The Inside Linebackers

6 of 7

    It's hard to imagine Brian Urlacher in any uniform other than the Chicago Bears, but he's set for free agency and not the player he used to be.

    The Bears will need to free up some cash in order to keep Henry Melton around, and under new DC Mel Tucker, getting pressure bringing only four defensive lineman will be emphasized. The Bears won't be retaining Urlacher for memory's sake alone. 

    Of course, Urlacher wants to stay in Chicago, as he told,

    "There's a lot of things going on beyond football for myself. I love football. I love to play. I love this organization. I'd still like to keep playing here. This is where I made my home. I'm going to stay here. My children are here, and I've got a lot of things going for me other than that.

    "But I want to keep playing football and I want to play it here."

    Rey Maualuga has proven to be a good two-down player. Despite his struggles in pass protection, he may be intriguing to a 3-4 team as a strong-side linebacker.

    Larry Foote was once thought of as among the league's elite, but like Urlacher, has seen his production dip in recent years—turning 33 during the 2013 NFL season, he may not draw too much attention.

    Dannell Ellerbe made a name for himself during the Ravens 2012-2013 Super Bowl run, and it was perfect timing, as there is little chance he will be retained when GM Ozzie Newsome starts clearing out some room for Joe Flacco's new deal.  

    Tim Dobbins

    Moise Fokou

    Brad Jones

    Bradie James

    Keith Brooking

    Chase Blackburn

    Ernie Sims

    Jasper Brinkley

    E.J. Henderson

    Paris Lenon

    Mike Peterson

    Channing Crowder

    Brandon Siler

    Barrett Ruud

    Larry Grant

    Tavares Gooden

PRO: The Pass Rushers (DE/OLB)

7 of 7

    Whether teams are looking for a pass-rushing 4-3 defensive end or a 3-4 outside linebacker to bring pressure, the options are all over the place, but as usual, will come with hefty price tags. 

    Dwight Freeney of the Colts was given $14 million last year to see how things would work out in Chuck Pagano's 3-4 scheme, brought in from Baltimore. While Freeney was better-than-average, it is likely that the Colts will be parting ways with one of their best pass rushers in history, just a year after parting ways with Peyton Manning, the man who built downtown Indy. 

    In regards to Raven Paul Kruger, Ozzie Newsome has said the Ravens will not make the same mistake in 2013 as they did in 2001. By this, he means holding on to the core group that won them a Super Bowl without keeping an eye towards the future. Kruger will be one of the hottest names in free agency and may end up replacing Freeney in Indianapolis, reuniting him with his old defensive coordinator.

    Cliff Avril has the Lions in a tough spot. The Lions salary cap is a mess, and Avril won't come on the cheap, after turning down a three-year, $30 million deal last summer. Avril had a down season in 2012, a contract year. He was playing under a franchise tag and was dealing with a back injury. Avril can play in the 4-3 or the 3-4, but when surveying possible suitors, keep a close eye on which teams play on grass surfaces, as Mlive reports.

    The Texans would love to keep Connor Barwin, but with all the other needs they face, the money simply is not likely to be there. They need to re-sign Glover Quin, address the interior of their offensive line, and find Matt Schaub more receiving weapons. While Barwin's numbers were down in 2012, that had quite a bit to do with the transcendent play of J.J. Watt, and DC Wade Phillips using Barwin more often dropping into coverage and occupying zones. 

    As for a few other names garnering consideration:

    Osi Umenyiora

    Israel Idonije

    Michael Johnson

    Michael Bennett

    Matt Shaughnessy

    Mike DeVito

    Andre Carter

    Kenyon Coleman

    Juqua Parker

    Darryl Tapp

    William Hayes

    Kyle Vanden Bosch

    Ray Edwards

    Lawrence Jackson

    Anthony Spencer

    Shaun Phillips

    Victor Butler

    Daryl Smith

    Philip Wheeler

    Erin Henderson

    Thomas Howard

    Manny Lawson

    Kaluka Maiava

    Leroy Hill

    Justin Durant

    Michael Boley

    DeAndre Levy

    Nick Roach

    Jonathan Casillas

    Gerald McRath

    Will Witherspoon