Is Randy Moss the Greatest Wide Receiver in NFL History?

Use your ← → (arrow) keys to browse more stories
Is Randy Moss the Greatest Wide Receiver in NFL History?
Elsa/Getty Images
Randy Moss scored 90 touchdowns in his first 7 seasons with the Vikings.

Randy Moss hasn't made much noise on the field for the San Francisco 49ers this year. But he caused quite a commotion at Super Bowl Media Day on Tuesday. "I really do think I'm the greatest receiver to ever play this game," Moss said with a straight face.

It didn't take long before Jerry Rice fired this shot back: "Put my numbers up against his numbers."

Fair enough. Let's do it!

Rice played 20 NFL seasons.  He compiled 1,549 catches, 22,895 yards, and 197 touchdowns. He's the league's all-time leader in all three categories.

As for Moss, he's currently in his 14th season. His career totals sit at 982 catches, 15,292 yards, and 156 touchdowns. Those are Hall of Fame numbers for sure, but not at Rice's level. And even though Moss plans on playing at least one more year, he won't threaten Rice's records.

Of course, Rice's longevity has a lot to do with his gaudy numbers. So how does Moss compare on a per-game basis?

Rice played in a whopping 303 regular season games. His average line was 5.1 catches, 75.6 yards, and .65 touchdowns.

Moss, meanwhile, has 218 games on his NFL resume. That gives him per-game averages of 4.5 catches, 70.1 yards, and .72 touchdowns.

He still falls short in the catch and yardage departments, but Moss gets the check mark in scoring rate. He also holds the edge in yards-per-catch average, sporting a career 15.6 mark, compared to Rice's 14.8.  

 

 

Still, Rice was a more consistent producer. And he did it over a longer period of time. The guy recorded 14 different 1,000-yard seasons; 11 over 1,200 yards. Moss has hit quadruple digits 10 times, with eight of those topping 1,200 yards. 

Moss does stack up well against Rice if we look at season-to-season TD production. Moss' 23 scores with the Patriots in 2007 were the most in NFL history. Rice previously held the record with 22 in 1987 -- and that came in just 12 games.  Both guys have nine seasons of 10+ touchdowns.

It's not a stretch to argue that Moss is the best big-play and scoring threat the position has ever seen.  But that doesn't make him the greatest wide receiver of all time. Rice more was well rounded and more reliable.

Now, Moss was certainly the superior natural athlete. The guy is 6'4", 210 pounds and blazed a 4.25 40-yard dash at his Pro Day prior to the 1998 NFL Draft. Rice's measurements were much more human: 6'2, 200 pounds and a 4.71 40-time.

Moss had the physical ability to be the greatest wide receiver in NFL history, but he was always a little too concerned about his next TD celebration. Rice on the other hand, was blessed with plenty of natural ability. He coupled that with elite work ethic, drive and commitment to become the best to ever play the game.

The NFL is a production-based business. And simply put, Rice was more productive than Moss. His name litters the record books. The accolades are far too voluminous to list. 

And there's one more thing Jerry's produced more of: Super Bowl rings. Three of them. Moss is still looking for his first title.

So Randy, next time you go tossing "greatest ever" claims around, check the numbers.

 

For more from Jared Smola, head on over to DraftSharks.com!

Load More Stories

Follow San Francisco 49ers from B/R on Facebook

Follow San Francisco 49ers from B/R on Facebook and get the latest updates straight to your newsfeed!

San Francisco 49ers

Subscribe Now

We will never share your email address

Thanks for signing up.