Being a talented goal scorer in the NHL is one thing. Any ol' player can light the lamp to pad a four-goal lead, or score into an empty net at the end of the game.
Being a prolific game-winning goal scorer or a clutch player in general is another thing all together. Which guys do you want out on the ice with a game on the line? Who tends to make the right plays at the right times, and who does the puck follow?
Some guys have it. Some guys don't.
This is a list of the guys that do, and as always, it is purely subjective. Feel free to make your case down in the comments.