Doug Pensinger/Getty Images
With another strong performance when it counted most, Matt Cain can be considered one of the best overall pitchers in baseball.
A starting pitcher's success in the regular season is worth as much as a rosin bag if it does not translate to success in the postseason. Justin Verlander and Matt Cain present an excellent case study for this baseball truism.
Both pitchers have played in the same eight major league seasons, with very similar career statistics. Cain has three more career starts, while Verlander has 27.0 more innings pitched.
Verlander has already compiled a 124-65 record during his eight-year career, with a 3.40 ERA and 1465 strikeouts. He won both the 2011 AL Cy Young and 2011 AL MVP—the first starting pitcher to achieve that double since Roger Clemens in 1986. Pulling off that feat solidified him as one of the most dominant pitchers in baseball.
And Verlander followed that up by finishing second in the 2012 AL Cy Young voting.
David Price of the Tampa Bay Rays won the AL Cy Young last season in what ESPN described described as "one of the closest votes ever." But ESPN's own David Schoenfield admitted Justin Verlander deserved to win the Cy Young—an achievement that would have seen him join the ranks of Roy Halladay, Johan Santana and Tim Lincecum as the only active pitchers with multiple Cy Young awards.
Prior to that, Verlander's 2012 regular season was highlighted by having his third career no-hitter broken up with one out in the ninth inning on May 18, 2012.
That said, Justin Verlander has struggled in his postseason career, specifically the World Series. Overall in the postseason, he is 6-4 in 12 starts with a 4.22 ERA, one complete game and one shutout. But in three World Series starts, he is 0-3 with a 7.20 ERA in only 15.0 innings pitched.
Verlander bombed in his only 2012 World Series start—a Game 1 debacle in which he surrendered five earned runs in only 4.0 innings of work. And his Tigers got hammered 8-3 by the San Francisco Giants en route to getting swept in the series.
Verlander's performance was so bad that Bleacher Report's Ian Casselberry wondered at the time if it was just one bad start or if Verlander had folded under the pressure. That sort of question is not asked of a true big-game pitcher.
Then there's Matt Cain, the San Francisco Giants right-hander, who is now considered the quintessential big-game pitcher. Cain won the clinching games of the 2012 NLDS and NLCS. And in the decisive Game 4 of the 2012 World Series, he gave up only five hits and three earned runs over 7.0 innings, earning a no-decision. His Giants eventually won the game to clinch their second World Series title in three seasons.
Over his entire postseason career, Matt Cain has been brilliant. He is now 4-2 with a 2.10 ERA in eight starts. In the World Series alone, Cain is 1-0 in two starts with a 1.84 ERA. In addition to the Game 4 performance in 2012, his only other World Series start came in 2010 against the Texas Rangers. All he did was shut out the potent Rangers lineup for 7.2 innings of Game 4, surrendering only four hits.
But Matt Cain's postseason dominance helps mask an eight-year career that is inferior when compared to that of Justin Verlander.
Cain has an overall record of 85-78, with a 3.27 ERA and 1278 strikeouts. But unlike Verlander, he has never won twenty games, instead peaking at 16 wins in 2012. And despite reaching double-digit wins five different times, Cain has also reached double-digit losses five times as well. Justin Verlander, meanwhile, has seven different seasons of double-digit wins, but only one season of double-digit losses.
As far as the Cy Young award goes, the best Matt Cain ever finished in Cy Young voting was sixth in 2012.
The two biggest highlights of Cain's regular season career also occurred in 2012. On June 13, he threw the first perfect game in the San Francisco Giants' history. And at the 2012 All-Star Game, he was named the starting pitcher for the National League. Ironically enough, he out-dueled Justin Verlander.
Despite this disparity in regular-season achievements, Matt Cain is still considered one of the best overall pitchers in baseball, while Justin Verlander comes up a little short.
Why is that? Because Matt Cain knows a World Series start isn't just another game. And he pitches accordingly.
Together, Justin Verlander and Matt Cain help illustrate the priority placed on postseason success versus regular-season success. If Stephen Strasburg wants to be considered the best overall pitcher in baseball, he must pitch like Matt Cain, not Justin Verlander, when he begins his journey into postseason baseball.